'Idol' spares controversial singer in first elimination round of new season

from: The Canadian Press - Thu Feb 21, 11:12 PM

Comments

(198)
SHOW What's this?
  • Emma

    Emma

    POSTED FRI, MAY 23, 2008 01:42 AM -0400

    I don't care what others think, but for me, David Cook can't sing, there's no strength in his voice. The other David Achuletta didn't win because his younger fans couldn't keep up with the cost to vote for him.

  • rdraxxgirl@v...

    rdraxxgirl@v...

    POSTED THU, MAY 22, 2008 11:33 PM -0400

    congrats David! thank you for all the drinks you've poured me and all the wonderful songs you have sang! You dream is about to come true! Best of luck to you,

  • evildnalor

    evildnalor

    POSTED THU, MAY 22, 2008 05:30 PM -0400

    http://kungfu.f-sw.com

  • Flashback

    Flashback

    POSTED THU, MAY 22, 2008 03:16 PM -0400

    THE VOTES WERE RIGGED. THERE IS NO WAY COOK COULD HAVE BEATEN ARCHIE BY SUCH A WIDE MARGIN. HE DIDN'T EVEN PERFORM WELL DURING THE FINALS. GOODNITE AI. YOU HAVE LEFT ANOTHER BITTER TASTE IN MY MOUTH

  • bubblibabigrl

    bubblibabigrl

    POSTED THU, MAY 22, 2008 02:45 PM -0400

    The wrong David took the prize!

  • Baldrick

    Baldrick

    POSTED THU, MAY 22, 2008 01:03 PM -0400

    who cares?????

  • Joyce D

    Joyce D

    POSTED THU, MAY 22, 2008 08:39 AM -0400

    If Simon had not opened his big mouth, calling Achuletta the winner, i am sure that Achuletta would have won.With Simon stating the winner, everyone wanted to prove him wrong so voted for Cook. Nice work Simon. Next time Simon PLEASE shut your mouth and let the voters pick the winner. I am absoutely sure the voters can and should pick the best Idol. Your there to voice your opinion not state your Declareation on who the winner is on the last show.

  • oneinthestinkca

    oneinthestinkca

    POSTED THU, MAY 22, 2008 08:38 AM -0400

    On Jay Leno Monday night, Simon picked DC to win. Although Archie has a great voice, would you pay money to see his show?? One dimensional, hour and a half of ballads. Cook is much more versatile and has an wamazing stage presence. Good on ya.

  • jhaward59

    jhaward59

    POSTED THU, MAY 22, 2008 08:29 AM -0400

    Supurb! Great! Although both contestants were talented the star shone brightly.

  • cheryl n

    cheryl n

    POSTED THU, MAY 22, 2008 08:13 AM -0400

    I am sooooooo happy that David Cook won American Idol!! I may be a grandmother of three but I still watch both American as well as Canadian Idol faithfully and I must say that David Cook is one singer that I would definitely pay money to see, he is an individual who has proved his own style again and again. He deserved to win the American Idol, so from Canada Dave.... way to go eh!!!! Hope you can make it to Nova Scotia someday bud. Congrats kid! cheryl

1 - 10 of 198 | Prev | Next

POST YOUR COMMENT HELP

You must sign in to leave a comment.