Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Canada Politics

    Is the Harper government’s policy in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict the right one?

    Canadian Foreign Minister, John Baird, walks during a visit to the Yad Vashem Holocaust memorial, in Jerusalem, …There's no subtlety when it comes to the Harper government's position on Israel.

    Speaking at the opening of the 12th annual Herzliya Conference on Monday, Foreign Minister John Baird blasted the Palestinian leadership calling on them to return to peace negotiations without conditions, to give up on their bid for recognition as a sovereign state by the UN, and accept Israel as the homeland of the Jewish people.

    Baird added that, "whether it is rockets raining down on Israeli schools, or the constant barrage of rhetorical demonization, double standards and delegitimization, Israel is under attack."

    "Clearly, Baird is working to entrench Canada as one of the world's most unbending supporters of the Israeli government," noted MacLeans Magazine's Alex Ballingall.

    According to poll results published in the Globe and Mail, nearly half of all Canadians agree with the Harper government's policy in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

    The poll, conducted by Environics Research Group, found that 48 per cent of those surveyed said the government has struck "the right balance," while only 23 per cent said Canada's policy was "too pro-Israel."

    There are some dissenting voices.

    Journalist Michael Harris says the government's decision to pick a side in this dispute means Canada will be left on the sidelines in future peace negotiations.

    "The Harper government's policy on the Middle East is uninformed and crassly political," he wrote for iPolitics.

    "In Ottawa's one-sided world, there is no UN Resolution 232; no human catastrophe of millions confined to refugee camps for decades; no international right of return; no excessive force or collective punishment against a civilian population; no such thing as Arab East-Jerusalem; no illegal settlements; no Janine refugee camp atrocity; no brutal assault on Lebanon; no Gaza."

    Last September, Paul Heinbecker, Canada's former ambassador to the UN penned a column questioning Canada's policy of backing Israel "to the hilt."

    "German Chancellor Angela Merkel has in the past accused [Israeli Prime Minister]Benjamin Netanyahu of not having 'made a single step to advance peace,'" Heinbecker wrote.

    "Former Bush and Obama defense secretary Robert Gates described Netanyahu as ungrateful and endangering Israel by refusing to grapple with its growing isolation.Former U.S. president Bill Clinton has said that the Netanyahu government has received all of the assurances previous Israeli governments said they wanted but now won't accept those terms to make peace."

    And, as you might imagine, the Palestinian community in Canada disagrees with the Harper government's staunch support of Israel.

    "Regrettably, Mr. Baird is an Israeli mouthpiece,"  Hanna Kawas, Chairperson of the Vancouver branch of the Canada Palestinian Association told Yahoo! Canada News.

    "Would he have asked Kuwait to sit with Iraq without preconditions to negotiate the Iraqi withdrawal from Kuwait? Israeli occupation of Palestinian lands was allowed to continue for the past forty four years with the support of western governments including successive US and Canadian governments."

    What do you feel about this article?

     
    • Shadow  •  Victoria, British Columbia  •  3 months ago
      David, you are blind and foolish. Israelis do not negotiate in good faith, never have. What you are doing and saying is twisting excuses as the Israelis have done. The West should say to Israel; Enough is enough! now back off and back out, but they are all afraid of the AIPAC. The West should also say to the Palestinians: you will have your state and ragain all your land including part of Jerusalem but if you don't keep the peace, 'We' will come down on you like a tone of bricks. For people to think that these two parties can negotiate in good faith is clear nonsense and a cop-out.
      • JumpinJack 3 months ago
        Funny, they negotiated in good faith with Egypt and Jordan to achieve peace.
    • r  •  3 months ago
      shooting children in the head in front of their parents is not a Canadian value
      • David Sage 3 months ago
        Really you believer that, your so stupid
      • Harold 3 months ago
        David Sage. Get educated!

        One example of several: Chris Hedges, Middle East bureau chief for the New York Times. In describing the actions of Israeli soldiers, Hedges notes that while he has seen children killed and wounded in other conflicts around the world, he has
        "...never before watched soldiers entice children like mice into a trap and murder them for sport." ("A Gaza Diary," Harpers, October, 2001).
        It is still going on in the occupied West Bank and occupied East Jerusalem as well as Gaza.
      • Adrianna 3 months ago
        Those are the muslims not the israelies.Palestinians dont blong in gaza.
    • Will  •  Toronto, Ontario  •  3 months ago
      Israel is sucking the democracy out of countries that help it and out of the countries that are their foe. Let Israel support Israel. The USA has plenty of Israeli politicians in the Fed Gov to the point that American laws are set up to help Israel.
      • Brianna 3 months ago
        lol lol sucking the democracy? hahahhahhaha what an idiot yes because palastianins have great human rights great gay rights and amazing civil rights.. we are so naive and damn here to let all those Muslim immigrants come .
      • waynechase11 3 months ago
        It's all about controling oil...please get a grip
      • monicat 3 months ago
        When will the Americans realize what their true interests are ? Why send all these billions of $ to Israel when many Americans live in poverty. Wake up Americans !
    • ala  •  3 months ago
      lately and in recent years everything you say in canada refers to hate crimes
    • Knightgamer  •  3 months ago
      It's called Harper's government because he runs it like little Hitler! I made a mistake in the last election and I accept that but I don't have to like it! Baird's always been a bully but now he has the power to flaunt it and he does. If Israel was carved out of Canada in 1948 and a and thousands of canadian families were forced out of their homes and forced into refugee camps, how would you react? How would you react to immigrants taking over your homes that you can trace your ancestors back hundreds of years. Would you turn the other cheek and say "Oh that's OK"! When the americans fought against British tyranny they were called "Patriots" and please don't turn the clock back 2000 years or we are all in trouble! Remember even Germany was re-united, yet Israel keeps expanding it's territory.
      Canada's stance is wrong! What the solution is, I don't know but it seems to me that since Harper has been PM, I can no longer say, I'm a proud canadian when I'm in other countries. Canada has lost a lot of respect in the world!
      No, I won't vote conservative in the next election!
      • Ash 3 months ago
        I agree, but I didn't make a mistake with my vote. I am ashamed to say Im Canadian, with that piece of shit in office.

        Youtube G20 and see how the police took over the streets of Toronto and made illegel arrests. Its sick.
      • monicat 3 months ago
        Knightgamer - I'm glad you won't repeat the mistake of voting conservative. The liberals give the same kind of support to israel. I respectfully suggest you give your vote to the NDP.
      • edjoy74 3 months ago
        I am ahsamed to be called a Canadian. If I had the big money I would literally leave here in a flash and go elsewhere. Just like all the rich people leaving the US I would too. All what is going on in the US has to do with the Israeli Jews (dual cititizenship) stealing the money from the cofers of the US for IS RA HELL and they are doing the very same things to Canada and elsewhere and people blame Hitler for what he did. You have no idea what the Jews did to the German people. Why don't you all ask yourselves why we don't have jobs left here in Canada nor the US - the Jews took them away and continuing to do so. I can go on and on here but not enough place to say all what I know - wake up Canada.
    • rick  •  Montreal, Quebec  •  3 months ago
      I love it when the head line says "the Harper government policy" doesn't any one remember the speech both Harper and Australia prime Minster give 2 days apart that were word for word in favour for the U.S. invasion. Clearly its not Harpers policy The Tory specking notes come from the U.S. look these up, The speeches are on You Tube.
      • sam 3 months ago
        Are these the same specking notes you are reading from now?
      • sam 3 months ago
        P.S. I'm dis agreeing with you!
      • rick 3 months ago
        look it up. i dont need notes. i can forward it to you. you must be young because you should have remember it
    • Will  •  Toronto, Ontario  •  3 months ago
      New Name for the Harper Government - Israel Governement
    • Himadri  •  Vancouver, British Columbia  •  3 months ago
      Canada wants to be a voice in world politics by siding with USA. No, it will not work. World will see it as a puppet govt like UK. F.M is blind to atrocities of Israel. His satements are far away from neutrality. No, you cannot become world voice by walking behind USA. You are to stand up yourself. Canda has that resource I think.
    • 1984  •  3 months ago
      NO, once you choose a side in any conflict you lose any real influence in that conflict, the decision was made for domestic political reasons.
    • James  •  Toronto, Ontario  •  2 months ago
      Neat that Germany and France do not have these money problems
    • Terry Ranchero  •  Halifax, Nova Scotia  •  3 months ago
      Treating Palestinians as hostages in Gaza and West Bank does not a good neighbor make. The receding 50% of Canadians quoted as supporting Mr. Harper's position see the Palestinian non-violent UN action as a valid way to move the peace process forward. Anything less is hypocrisy for we cannot criticize them for violent protest one day and peaceful protest the next. This along with threats to attack Iran are going to backfire on Harper come the next election.
    • ross_doudu  •  3 months ago
      Adrianna teaching history that the Jews where in Canada first! And she/he actually believes it . Now thats comical..I hope she/he is not teaching First Nation children good lord..
    • snowgoose  •  Halifax, Nova Scotia  •  3 months ago
      For Canada to support Israel totally without any consideration of their actions is not only against the norms of diplomacy; but, it is foolish and shows the ignorance of the Harper Govt. Canada had the reputation for being a fair mediator taking both sides into consideration. Not any more. Harper's slavish adoration of the Israeli state blinds him to the atrocities perpetuated on the Palestinians. Gaza for instance is a walled prison for Palestinians rom which there is no escape. The so called "settlements" are an outright land grab breaking International Law. Is this the Cdn way? Harper is supporting an extremist party that appears to want war with Iran. Is that where we want our troops to be sent next? I don't fully understand the religious connections between born again Christians and the Jewish imperative in the mid-east; but, it makes me very nervous to think that they could be influencing our foreign policy. It is unwise to favour one side in a dispute where both have committed crimes when our country has a multi-cutlural society. Once again, what is Harper's motive?
    • Ash  •  Chetwynd, British Columbia  •  3 months ago
      Harper is turning us into Americans.. Look at the people who voted for him, I know many because they are in my family and they can't tell me why they voted, except they didn't want the NDP to win because they would destroy our country. Actually most of the people Ive spoken to who did vote Conservitive thought we were in debt before Harper took power and it was the NDP who did it.

      Now I am not that big into Politics, but I know the NDP have never had a majority government or even a Primeminister. So why do my conservitive Family members and friends think these things?

      Just a thought! Lies and more lies. Attacking Libya, Afghanistans or any other nation is a war crime.. Lets keep our troops at our boarder and protect our country.

      Now after seeing Harper spend 1 billion on a G20 summit, would it be to much of me to say he doesn't really care about Canadian people and maybe he is working for Bankers?
    • Philip  •  Kelowna, British Columbia  •  3 months ago
      The Conservatives have a lot of bad policies, but this is one of their worst. Since 67 Canada has had a stance of neutrality on the Israel/Palestine conflict. It doesn't surprise me that the God Party (Conservatives) have taken this route. This boils down to religion and the Temple Mount. The Jews and Christians want to destroy the Dome of Rock a Mosque that presently sits on the Temple Mount, that represents the 4th most holy site in the Muslim Religion. But, for the Jews they need a Temple of God on the Temple Mount for their Messiah to come. For the Christians they need the third Temple of God to be built for the second coming of Christ. There has already been 2 Temples of God on the Temple Mount. This is why Christian Governments have always supported Israel. Governments like we have seen in the States and the present Conservative Government here in Canada. That is why the conflict will never be resolved. Both side refuse to give up Jerusalem and the Temple Mount. All this religion crap is the number one reason I support neutrality on the Middle East conflict. Hell, Palestinians and Jews are the descendants of 2 half brothers from the bible, Issac and Ismael who have been fighting for over 2000 years and probable will be fighting for another 2000 years. If ever there was a reason to be neutral.
    • A Yahoo User  •  3 months ago
      No, Harper's policy is not the right one. One needs to do some digging to find out some of the horrible things the Israelis are doing to the Palestinians. Even many Jewish residents of Israel do not support these horrible actions.
      For a group of people who were victimized by The Halocaust, it is unconscienable that these actions occur, and it may end up being a situation of genocide. Canada should definitely not be supporting this sort of behavior.
    • iluvjapanesegirls  •  3 months ago
      Why do i hate that ugly pr-k Baird so much?
      almost as much as i hate Harper (yes, i really hate him, in fact, i hate all you lousy freaking "conservatives").
    • Kt  •  Grande Prairie, Alberta  •  3 months ago
      I'd like to know where they are doing their polling? I haven't heard anyone say that they support Canada's new hard-line pro Israel stance.
    • David  •  Ottawa, Ontario  •  3 months ago
      It's time Israel started acting like an adult.
    • Spike  •  Thunder Bay, Ontario  •  3 months ago
      I feel I speak for the vast majority of First Nations peoples on this subject. If you are Palestinian or Arab ancestry I would like to take this opportunity to apologize for the ignorance of "Harper Government", and to assure you they speak strictly for themselves. We have more in common than you might think. This is NOT a reflection of the general populous. I Champion David Ahenekewe,

    Blog Authors / Profiles