Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Canada Politics

    NDP rookie MPs avoid media questions, even though party criticized Harper for same thing

    In an ironic twist, the NDP, one of the parties that criticized Prime Minster Stephen Harper for not answering more than four questions at press conferences during the election, isn't letting its rookie MPs answer any - at least not to the national media.

    In a column for The Hill-Times, Kristen Shane describes how the NDP are "cautiously limiting media access to its 68 rookie MPs."

    "You watch (deputy leader and House leader) Thomas Mulcair walk behind them (new MPs) and he's got everything but an earpiece," Liberal MP Rodger Cuzner told Shane. "He looks like a secret service (agent) when he walks along with the younger members."

    Perhaps you can't blame the NDP. After all, there have already been some embarrassing blunders.

    Shortly after the May 2 election one rookie MP, Marc-Andre Morin, told a reporter he had been a supporter of sovereignty for Quebec.

    "I supported the Bloc for a long time," said Morin, whose riding is northwest of Montreal.

    "I saw that in a certain context it could have been justified," he added. "But I think that things have changed in Canada and Quebec, and it is perhaps not as pertinent now as it was in the past."

    The party's youngest MP, 19-year-old Pierre-Luc Dusseault, raised eyebrows with a" less than ringing endorsement of Canadian unity" in a radio interview.

    "Sovereignty will be done in Quebec. And Quebecers will decide if they want to be a country," he told Toronto radio host John Oakley. "(While) awaiting this moment, I've said why not give us a real government that is good for us . . . We will respect sovereignty with the NDP."

    Toronto Star columnist Gillian Steward compares NDP Leader Jack Layton's leash to that of Preston Manning's in 1993 when he also had to deal with a crop of rookies.

    "One of the Reform rookies was 34-year-old Calgary MP Stephen Harper, who made a name for himself with the Ottawa Press Gallery as Reform's "go-to" guy for quotes and comments. He could be found lurking in the background of almost every media scrum waiting to be asked for his point of view on issues of the day," she wrote.

    "Others were so outspoken on issues such as aboriginal rights, gay rights, abortion and capital punishment that Manning eventually put them on a very short leash."

    At the time, many criticized Manning for being too controlling but ultimately it paid off - Stephen Harper apparently did well for himself.

    (CP Photo: Thomas Mulcair)

    What do you feel about this article?

     

    98 comments

    • Mr  •  11 months ago
      Party leaders don't elect their MPs - voters do. And now Layton knows why Harper keeps his MPs on a short leash.
      • J00J 11 months ago
        Party leaders norminate name on the ballot..yes. they selected them..
      • Center View 11 months ago
        Huge difference. harper has ministers to whom he dictates, regardless of their experience and expertise. Actually, many of them (think Prentice) were/are way superior to harper as a smart, grounded, progressive conservative. What layton does is normal "handling"; when I was a raw constable, I was "handled" by a senior police officer until I was ready to do the job on my own. On the other hand, no one would have dared trying to "handle" a smart, experienced, and knowledgeable officer the way harper handles his pets.
    • Abe Paul  •  11 months ago
      These new NDP MPs were basically picked off the street just to have a candidate in every riding! They may not EVER have been in riding, know where it was, or speak their language!
      They will not be around after next election.
      • buck58 11 months ago
        Your exactly right, and look how many got elected, what does that tell you about what the other 60% of Canadians think about Harper and the so-called Conservatives.
      • mth020363 11 months ago
        Stop the false majority nonesense. It is meaningless in a Westminster parliamentary system with more than two parties nad more than two candidates.

        By the way, if you actually checked individual MPs, you'd see that in MPs having 50% or more of the vote of their ridings, Conservatives beat out all other parties by almost 3 to 1.

        I will agree that the Conservatives are so called because they are not much better than their predecessor in taxing and giving away hard earned dollars to layabouts and welfare bums and so-called victims.
      • Ray 11 months ago
        @ Buck58. By your logic you say 60 pecent of Canada didn't want Harper. So that would mean that 70% didn't want the NDP, 81% didn't want the Liberals, 94% Didn't want the Bloc and 96% didn't want the Green Party to get into office. 60% sounds pretty popular to me now. Plus only 61% of the country voted, which means 39% of the country don't get a say and you can't use their numbers.
    • kellym  •  11 months ago
      please...look at the source of the "Harper lurking..." comment. The Toronto Star. What a load of crap. The NDP doesn't need Mulcair protecting them while they have the CBC and STar, et to do that job.
      • buck58 11 months ago
        Truth is a bitch, or you can do what your great leader does, if the truth hurts just attack the ones presenting it.....just like you did here.
      • Marc Antony 11 months ago
        Let's no get into lamenting "attacks" here Buck58. At least 80% of the so-called opinions and comments that pour out of the Leftist camp are spiteful hate-filled attacks against our government, our electoral system, Mr. Harper himself, and even his family. The Harper family can't even adopt a kitten and promote the Humane Society without leftist dogs like you making a contentious issue out of it. At least try and sound civilized. Please.
      • Guy 11 months ago
        The liberal media is to blame for me stubbing me toe as well. Damn the TorStar, damn them! (*rubs toe*)
    • stephen  •  11 months ago
      This is no surprise. Jack Layton ran the NDP election campaign that had only one goal. To put him in the limelight. He made unrealistic promises to seduce vote because he knew he would never have to deliver them. He pandered to to any Quebecer including pro sovereignty voters. Many of the candidates they ran seem to have selected without any review if they were appropriate to represent the NDP, to represent the people in their riding, or even understood anything about the NDP. The campaign was all about Layton and feeding his ego regardless of the damage to Canadian Unity, the interests of the voters electing NDP candidates in the ridings his party was supposed to represent ridings, or the ideals of the members of the NDP. Like Brian Mulroney he has given the sovereignty movement a new tool. Using the power of a national federalist party to promote their agenda to destroy Canada.

      Layton succeeded in reaching they spotlight where Canadians can continually be fed more of his insincere speeches about his devotion to this country and its people working towards our best interests now and in the future. Look at what he does not what he says.
      • buck58 11 months ago
        Oh.. and Harper ran just because he wants to serve the canadian people and spread love and bliss, because deep down he just loves the Canadain people. Give me a break.
      • Alion 11 months ago
        At least Layton gutted the Bloc. That's a plus!
      • Bill 11 months ago
        The NDP took Quebec because they've already had majority Liberal and Conservatives and they both are crooks to all of Canada. They are just the first province that is smart enough know that when someone screws you once, they will do it again.
    • jojo  •  11 months ago
      Yes, Layton had better keep a tight hold on his kids from Quebec.
    • Bob  •  11 months ago
      There you have it, "do as we say, not as we do".
      • marquse1 11 months ago
        Like every political party does?
      • Center View 11 months ago
        The same way harper answered four (that's 4, you moron) questions a day prior to the election and NONE from his pets (read ministers and MPs). Bet that tactic made you have "broke back mountain" dream of harper, hey so-called loyalist.....
    • mathewsm1106  •  11 months ago
      Let them talk.
    • A Yahoo! User  •  11 months ago
      Sure there's an equivalence between the PM avoiding questions during a federal campaign, and rookie MPs sitting in the Opposition benches ducking the media.
    • Harry R. Sole  •  11 months ago
      This is going to be a three ring circus!
    • Tan Wei  •  11 months ago
      Its ok, I guess, considering that they are rookies. But not so good if they are still doing that couple of years down the road.
    • Factguy  •  11 months ago
      You useless leftest cry babies. The elections are over. Can you not bitch till the next election? You guys need to get your brains off that infinite loop. Try something new. How about a job for a change?
    • Gilbert  •  11 months ago
      Why would anyone be surprised?
    • A Yahoo! User  •  11 months ago
      with some luck, the ndp will implode in the near future.
      having one foot in each camp may not be sustainable!
    • JT  •  11 months ago
      Let her talk! She can't say anything more stupid than her leader.
    • Abe Paul  •  11 months ago
      should that surprise us?
      the socialists are the BIGGEST hypocrites!
    • TellinThaTruth  •  11 months ago
      Oh boy. Only four year to go!!!!
    • Jackal Va  •  11 months ago
      Who will keep a leash on Layton?
    • David H  •  11 months ago
      Typical hypocrites they only criticize Harper because they don't like that he came up with the great idea before they did. Vote Conservative and at least you will get integrity! :)
    • EMW  •  11 months ago
      The NDP is in for a major problem in the coming months
    • depew_40  •  11 months ago
      I hope Harper rams his polices through. Nothing beats listening to sore losers who know they are about to be kicked to the curb. Give it them hard Stevie!

    Blog Authors / Profiles