Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Canada Politics

    Toronto’s Rob Ford and Calgary’s Naheed Nenshi: A tale of two mayors

    Toronto Mayor Rob Ford.Calgary Mayor Naheed Nenshi.Canada's two most high-profile mayors are proving this week they couldn't be any more different in their approach to politics.

    One day after Toronto Mayor Rob Ford skipped out on Toronto's massive Pride parade, Calgary Mayor Naheed Nenshi revealed he will serve as his city's parade grand marshal.

    While Ford was widely criticized for not participating, Nenshi is being lauded for his involvement.

    "The participation of Naheed Nenshi, the mayor of calgary, as grand marshal for his city's Gay Pride celebrations this coming September is a model of the kind of acceptance that Pride events are meant to exemplify," wrote the Globe and Mail editorial board.

    "It is an expression of leadership and inclusion that Mr. Nenshi, to his great credit, understands fully."

    Calgary voters elected Nenshi just days before Toronto voters swept Ford into power, and since then the comparisons have been stark.

    Both mayors are young - Ford is 42 and Nenshi is 39 - and both campaigned on fiscal responsibility. That is where the similarities end.

    As described by Marcus Gee in a Globe and Mail column, the two mayors are very different people.

    With regards to style, Ford is chippy and combative, while Nenshi consistently strives to reach out to potential opponents and get beyond partisan bickering.

    "Despite his image as a down-to-earth everyman, Mr. Ford is rather reserved and withdrawn in person," wrote Gee. "Mr. Nenshi, by contrast, has a boyish, almost impish air."

    With regards to substance, Gee says Nenshi is more progressive.

    "Both mayors cut their office budgets when they took office as a symbol of restraint but unlike Mr. Ford, Mr. Nenshi has steered away from cutting or freezing taxes," he noted.

    Nenshi, for example, has raised property taxes and allocated one per cent of all spending toward capital projects for public arts. Ford, on the other hand, has threatened to fire city managers who fail to cut spending

    The Pride parade issue further solidifies the public perceptions of both men.

    It also provides fodder for journalists who still wonder how Calgary, traditionally one of Canada's most conservative cities, can have a progressive mayor, while Toronto, historically one of Canada's most liberal cities, elected a very conservative mayor.

    Maybe Christopher Hume of the Toronto Star was on to something when he wrote, "The rednecks have all moved east."

    (CBC Photos)

    What do you feel about this article?

     

    447 comments

    • Will  •  10 months ago
      When, oh when, are we all going to grow-up? As a gay man, I have never been to a Pride Parade. A little too loud and crass for my taste. I don't really care if the mayor of whatever city decides not to go. Treat us equally under the law and let's leave it at that!....
      • wapsfstupid 10 months ago
        @william. finally a gay person who is not asking for too much thank you!
      • HARRY 10 months ago
        well said man...you should mayor...People should not beg fo friendship and just have pride in themselves and who they are.
      • R 10 months ago
        Here's a guy who isn't pushing and I can respect that. So many gay people have been fighting for the live and let live ideal and now they have it and yet they want to push more and more. It just a parade and just because I guy doesn't show doesn't mean he wants to take your rights away. Its not fair and it can backfire. William - David is right. Live and let live. Dont try to make people act in a way that is not them.
    • Whargoul  •  10 months ago
      Wow two people from two different cities, from two different parts of the country, from two different backgrounds have two different opinions. What are the odds?
      • Legal Eagle 10 months ago
        Lol! Spot on. Imagine, Ford already had plans and couldn't make a parade, he must be a virulent homophobe! Even most reasonable people from the gay and lesbian communities were not offended. This is a non-story.
    • Jamie  •  10 months ago
      I am a lesbian and I am proud to be canadian and i am proud to be a kind loving person my sexual preference is not my source of pride. Neither mayor is wrong in attending or not attending.
      • Mr 10 months ago
        Well said. I think it's wrong to "bully" others into giving the illusion of support for something they don't care about.
      • ampless 10 months ago
        at last a couple of sensible voices from the gay community. (William-David & Jamie)
      • dette_f 10 months ago
        The gay parade, a bunch of people advertising their 'wares' is not quite something I'd go out of my way to watch. I really don't see what difference it makes that Ford wasn't there. He has a family and indicated he wanted to spend quality time, away, with them. As a family man, Ford would have been critized for not spending time with his own. It's only a gay parade and I wouldn't take my family there either. I get tired of hearing about gay rights - demanding more than rights than anyone else. Gays are not special people and do not deserve special treatment.
    • leprecaun28  •  10 months ago
      So what are they going to say about Ford when he chooses his family over the Caribana Festival, now renamed Jambana? People should mind their own business...
    • Steve84563  •  10 months ago
      If I were gay, I would be completely embarrassed by the select few idiots who make the gay community look bad by making such a fuss over something like this. The pride parade used to be about gays standing up for equal rights, now it is simply an excuse to act like a retard in public.
      • Abakar 10 months ago
        u r a gay
      • Naymar 10 months ago
        What abot showin off your hairy ass to kids?
      • Dentrh 10 months ago
        please do not use the third last word in your comment. If you wish to say fool, use that word or one of the many synonyms for the word, not the word that was pejoratively applied to the people with a developmental disability, such as Downs Syndrome or Autism.
    • Kathy  •  10 months ago
      Yahoo, you're becoming the Jerry Springer of internet information. Thank you for constantly setting low standards in journalism.
    • LAZARUS  •  10 months ago
      every person has a right to stand for what they think is right, not what people want them to be.
    • Bob Smith  •  10 months ago
      Mayor Ford, regardless of his position to represent all the people, should be respected for his personal and family decisions. Get over it! Allow him to be mayor on issues that affect the efficient running of the city - not parades!
    • Dave  •  10 months ago
      Things must be going well in the country as well as Toronto if this is what we are debating.
    • Horizon  •  10 months ago
      What a story! How come the activity of a city Mayor should be "appreciated" as efficient related ONLY to the fact that he/she participates to a gay parade?
      The former Toronto Mayor David Miller (very appreciate by media because his main activity was to participate at all the gay parades) has neglected his main Mayoral duties, weakened dangerously the Toronto Economy by increasing foolishness the taxes and throwing in wind all the taxpayers money!
      How come the media - which have to be impartial and promote the real work of a Mayor has arrived to "promote" only the gay virtues and judge a Mayor work and achievements ONLY if he was or not at the guy parade? Why the Toronto Mayor Bob Ford have to spend important funds of taxpayers money to ''finance and support'' the gay parade, than to repair the disastrous Toronto infrastructure of streets, highways, sidewalks inherited from his predecessor David Miller?
      What is the fuss to compare the Calgary Mayor mentality to participate at all gay parades, with the honest, passionate and taking good care of taxpayer's money mentality of Mayor Bob Ford?
      This is a shame, and BRAVO to Mayor Bob Ford for his courage and determination to do not be intimidated by any partisan groups (including gay parade) and to put an end once for all at this unfair media pressure which in quest of so called "news" has transformed the Toronto Mayoral activity in a real circus!
      The Mayor Bob Ford it's the Mayor of 5 millions of Torontonians and not ONLY of a few hundred guy peoples and their desuete parade!
    • R  •  10 months ago
      The gay population of Canada has the freedom to live their lives as they choose but they do not have the right to demand that everyone else be super pro gay. They are a small portion of the population but are always complaining and trying to justify themselves and push themselves on the rest of us. Mayor Ford may just not be into the whole gay thing, did you ever think of that. Maybe watching a lot of people acting in a way that the rest of us don't do ourselves is not Ford's think. It's certainly not my thing. Gays have freedom and rights in this country and why are they complaining for more. If you gays out there don't want us Straights trying to make you straight like us then stop trying to make us into gaylords like you.
    • Rob  •  10 months ago
      There is a Toronto Star article about him where he says he is heterosexual. It seems that because he is openly non-discriminatory against gays that he is therefore deemed gay. As for Rob Ford, he clearly said he had other previous family commitments. A family tradition that has continued for decades in his family. That does NOT constitute discrimination in any way. Unless someone can demonstrate that he had no other commitments then STFU. It seems that what this article is saying is that once you are mayor you MUST attend the gay pride parade irrespective of any other commitments. That is unreasonable. It's not like he cut funding or attempted to stop the parade in any way. Nor did he voice any opinions against the parade. Nor did he try to deter anyone else from attending. He simply did not attend due to other commitments. This article is probably about the Globe and Mail trying to get people to buy their product by stirring up controversy.
    • Jeremy  •  10 months ago
      Perhaps Ford would have attended if the parade was a little more serious about gay pride and less about getting your freak on in the middle of the street.
    • RAY  •  10 months ago
      Mr. Ford does not have to prove that he is a good mayor or person by attending a gay pride parade. everyone forgets what great work or accomplishments ford has done all because he decided to be with his family on this day. all the people who got offended should just grow up and shut up already.
    • PETER  •  10 months ago
      Brian Burke, whose deceased son was gay, said that it was entirely Ford's business to attend or not attend the parade. A poor article with a pretense of being objective. I guess according to the esteemed Mr Hume Toronto has a majority of rednecks. Go figure.
    • Gary M..  •  10 months ago
      I think Rob Ford is doing a great job. I hope he don't have to kiss ass to be reelected
    • mike  •  10 months ago
      OK I have heard about enough of this Ford thing.Who cares if he goes to the parade or not?? Many gay people don't attend the parade......I think that the Santa Claus parade would be far more important to attend.Children do not belong anywhere near the prancing of queers and queens dancing naked on the streets,and yes they do !!
      Who cares if your gay !! Do you see a heterosexual parade for married couples.
      Your sexuality belongs to you and your partner.....not to be displayed in public like a circus show (which it is).Everyone is smoking dope and getting drunk.....I don't blame Ford for not wanting to be involved.....he did the right thing....he spent the weekend with his family,thats what long weekends are for !!
    • ᗪᗩᗰᖇᗩḰ  •  10 months ago
      I lived in Toronto for 15 years...Great City!!...I have been to a lot of great festivals and events, but I have never been to the gay parade. I don't have any respect for >anyone< who shoves
      their sexuality in your face!
    • K M  •  10 months ago
      From the editorial: "a model of the kind of acceptance that Pride events are meant to exemplify". Wrong - in the current climate they are meant to DEMAND approval, participation and abundant blessing. When will the gays stop these demands on the rest of us??
    • dogheels  •  10 months ago
      When it comes to the Gay community, it's there way or no way. Don't comply with their ideologues, and your labelled as a homophobe. Ford chose not to attend. Take it for what it is. His choice.

    Blog Authors / Profiles