Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Daily Brew

    Italian cruise ship disaster focuses attention on safety, legal rights

    The Costa Concordia cruise ship that ran aground off the west coast of Italy is seen at Giglio island January 18, …Used to be people contemplating taking a luxurious cruise only had to worry about sea-sickness, maybe a touch of food poisoning or perhaps a norovirus blitz straining the ship's toilet facilities.

    Then came a spate of on-board fires that rendered a couple of these big floating hotels helpless at sea, and now the Costa Concordia disaster.

    At least 11 people died and some two dozen are still missing since the giant cruise ship blundered onto some rocks near an island off the Tuscan coast last Friday night.

    The evacuation of thousands of passengers and crew from the badly listing vessel was a Titanic-style fiasco, exacerbated by the fact the ship's captain was apparently on one of the first lifeboats.

    Cruise industry expert Ross Klein of Memorial University in St. John's told CBC News that Capt. Francesco Schettino's actions before and after the accident are highly questionable. He also thinks it's time to revisit safety procedures and crew training on cruise vessels.

    So you still want to take a cruise. What can you expect if the ship runs into trouble?

    The Toronto Star reports that experts believe only about 15 per cent of people remain calm during a severe crisis, while 70 per cent have impaired judgment and 15 per cent behave irrationally, i.e. panic.

    The experts say you can prepare yourself for an emergency but doing things such as knowing where your personal flotation device is located and how to put it on, and if you have kids, ensuring theirs are the right size.

    You should also familiarize yourself with the ship, looking for exits and lifeboats. Ask for an escape drill if the ship doesn't do one.

    Listen for all announcements - usually made in English - and the international signal to evacuate - seven short blasts of the ship's horn, followed by one long one. Also know where you can get direction if the crew speaks a different language from yours.

    In the absence of instructions or help from the crew, head to the upper decks and get off the ship. Take the quickest but not necessarily shortest route and don't use elevators or escalators. If there was no lifeboat drill and aren't sure where to find one, look for crew members helping passengers.

    The Costa Concordia sinking is also expected to focus attention on the cruise operator's civil liability.

    Reuters' correspondent Linda Stern reports passengers buy cruise ship tickets without reading the lengthy contracts attached to them.

    U.S. consumer lawyer Joseph Goldberg notes the Carnival Cruise Lines contract (a Carnival subsidiary operated the stricken ship) runs almost eight thousand words and mentions liability 20 times.

    The sinking will likely trigger years of litigation as the company tries to limit its liability while passengers argue the usual contract limitations shouldn't apply in a disaster like this.

    Goldberg advises would-be cruise passengers should read their ticket contracts carefully to know what rights you might be signing away.

    What do you feel about this article?

     

    89 comments

    • ICE CREAM  •  Espanola, Ontario  •  4 months ago
      I worked on a cruise ship for three years and every cruise before we sail we have a muster drill so you know where to go in case stuff happens. Most people don't care and can't wait to get back to the buffett and shove more food in their mouth.
      Know your surroundings and do a quick walk around from your cabin to your life boat, it will save your life and the people you are with.
      • thoughtful. 4 months ago
        I was on a very thoroughly organized cruise down the west coast from Vancouver to L.A. There was a lifeboat drill initially ... yes, most people were making jokes and having fun, but it was done and remembered by most! This was the Norwegian Princess. We had a very rough storm, and though I was scared that night, I knew where my lifejacket was, and where to get to my lifeboat. You're right! Do that walk, know your surroundings!
      • Just me 4 months ago
        I saw the same attitude toward the fire drills at an office tower that I worked at years ago. Sad part is that if something really bad happens and someone is hurt, fingers start pointing. The advice given here is common sense.
    • Cap...  •  4 months ago
      Been on several cruises, Three simple things to do.
      1) Take part in life boat drills you will know where to assemble.
      2) Listen to instructions these people are trained.
      3) Use your head and common sense.
      • Cap... 4 months ago
        Looks like the Good Ship Common Sense sailed with out you, OOPS sorry about that it never stopped to pick you up.
      • Wolfgang Canis Lupus 4 months ago
        The only thing you know about ships is breaking the bow and sucking out all the seamen.
      • Up2Me 4 months ago
        Don't worry about this guy Capt, he's just a sad individual who likes to make himself feel important by putting others down. He's not worth it.
    • Mr. J  •  Ajax, Ontario  •  4 months ago
      People with disabilities should think twice about cruising ...........Scooters and walkers are useless when the ships lists , and when elevators are diabled .
      A lot of foreign ports are not disabled friendly.......high curbs and rough sidewalks and streets .
      Now they are dependant on others for their safety..............there are not enough crew to look after everyone personally.
      • Paul . 4 months ago
        hey I'm in a wheelchair but can also walk a bit too but if your on a sinking ship you had better stick your head up your #$%$ LOL no pun intended
    • gooseberry  •  4 months ago
      Oh god now it's going to be a whole thing. The fearmongering articles begin:

      "COULD IT HAPPEN TO YOU?" "ARE YOU SAFE?" "DEATH FROM ABOVE" "RUN, RUN FOR YOUR LIVES" "THE CRUISE SHIPS ARE COMING, THE CRUISE SHIPS ARE COMING!"

      It doesn't happen everyday, so does it really need to be this now "are you safe, garbage? Only in North America that thrives on fear. In Europe? no. Caribbean or South America? no. Only here is it fear, fear, fear, Fear of Iran! Fear of Cruise ships, fear of Bad breath, fear of not being popular, fear of not being loved. It goes on and on, the puppetry. That's why unlike other places in the world, everything is fear based without even realizing it. That's what sells. You click on it and read and they sell advertising dollars.
      • J 4 months ago
        Sad but very true too!
    • hanzamy  •  Vancouver, British Columbia  •  4 months ago
      This cruise had no safety drill prior to sailing off. Thats a no no according to marine law.
      • colduphere 4 months ago
        Depending on the duration and embarcation points, we have had 3 on a 15 day cruise.
      • gradimir 4 months ago
        who told you there was no drill?
    • jacko  •  Burlington, Ontario  •  4 months ago
      In a case like this one at least halve of the lifeboats were rendered useless and people would not have been able to get to their life vests. So even if they had a drill 4000 people would have still been fighting for the remainder of the lifeboats and life preservers. They are just lucky this did not happen farther out to sea because the death toll would have been horrendous.
    • Happy Happy  •  Edmonton, Alberta  •  4 months ago
      I love cruising, I prefer it to an all inclusive vacation where you are on the same beach, same waters all the time. The entertainment and facilities are awesome, the food is excellent and you wake up in a different port every morning. There is nothing like having your breakfast on your balcony with the fresh Caribbean sea splashing down below. I always do the drill they provide, I make sure I check where all the exits are and make sure there are enough working life vests in the cabin for everyone..etc...Just because of this one idiotic, selfish, coward of a captain, i will not stop cruising and will recommend it to anyone thinking about cruising!
    • ally36_98  •  London, Ontario  •  4 months ago
      Know your surroundings, but really you are at the mercy of whoever is
      driving the ship, plane, train or what ever mode of transportation you are on.I will continue cruising because if you don't take the risk you might as well stay home in your bubble and that's not much fun!
    • Time_out  •  Burlington, Ontario  •  4 months ago
      How many people actually watch the pre-flight instructions when they fly somewhere. The same can be said for a cruise. We have the "it only happens to the other guy" approach to safety. The instructions have to be given of course or someone will get a lawyer after an event and try to cash in.
    • PAUL  •  Ottawa, Ontario  •  4 months ago
      reading the contract does not change anything because it is the cruise line's corporate position and they are not prepared to negotiate with you. The only action you can take is not to book the cruise. it is also not very practical because much of the language is in legal speak. There is also not a lot of choice because most cruise lines have similar contracts. Costa is one of the budget cruise lines and so is carnival so you get what you pay for.
    • Bill4US  •  Toronto, Ontario  •  4 months ago
      An Excellent Article for you cruisers
    • Bryan  •  Izumi-shi, Japan  •  4 months ago
      Ironically, knowing how to swim is not one of the things you should know in a cruise disaster; say the experts...
    • A Yahoo! User  •  Toronto, Ontario  •  4 months ago
      the captian of the ship should be jailed for life if you are a real captain you know not to go close to the coast line
    • cc  •  4 months ago
      A little personal responsibility goes a long way. Don't depend on or wait for others to spoon feed you the information. Whether you're traveling by plane or ship, read the safety information and pay attention to the safety demonstrations and drills. when you're in a hotel room, read the evacuation procedures and diagram to your emergency exits. The people who are prepared are the ones with a better chance at survival in the case of extreme emergencies.
    • Rockadero  •  Burnaby, British Columbia  •  4 months ago
      Here is a good one.
      " Don't Drive Over The Rocks. "
    • Paul .  •  Lesser Slave River No 124, Alberta  •  4 months ago
      Well cruise ship passengers we'll now be offering water wings just for the "What if situations" everybody theres no reason to worry we do this on all oceanic cruises everywheir now so please enjoy !!!!!
    • Luc  •  Ottawa, Ontario  •  4 months ago
      rule and regulation are priority for the safety no matter where you go, Captain should know that, and yes he should be charge to loosing lifes, they are no excuse, i agree what the expect said, and it is much important now then even to know what peoples should expect, after all it your life too, it should have a drill every time knew people come abord
    • Mr. Bill  •  4 months ago
      Its easy to say to passengers do this do that but the passenger is not to be blamed
      for not knowing what he/she has to do. They are all landlubbers who are there to enjoy
      themselves. None have any training in case of disaster nor is any required or given
      before sailing. When news that the Capt. has abandoned ship starts spreading like
      wildfire among the passengers panic sets in. The one way to avoid this is to sail on
      a ship that you know is crewed by real seamen and you will find this on a Cunard
      ship. The Queen Mary 2 is the best by far cruise ship ever built and crewed
      by masters of the ocean. I cant wait to use it again ,,it was an outof this world experience.
    • PensPwnJ00  •  4 months ago
      safety tip #1: make sure the captain of the ship is not an idiotic lying coward.
    • deegee  •  Toronto, Ontario  •  4 months ago
      I love cruises! Been on 6 so far. Lots to do, you wake up in a different place every morning. Lots of adventure for those who want it and leisure for those who don't. This incident will not stop me from going again.

    Blog Authors / Profiles