Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Daily Brew

    National panel says aboriginal education falls short, calls for better reforms and more money

    Here's some shocking news: a new report finds major failings with aboriginal education in Canada.

    The report by a national panel on First Nations elementary- and secondary-school education called on the federal government to set up an oversight body, The Canadian Press reports.

    It also recommended that local organizations similar to school boards be set up.

    And it called for more money to be put into the system.

    Specific recommendations in the report, entitled Nurturing the Learning Spirit of First Nation Students, include creating a child-centered First Nations Education Act, setting up a national commission on First Nation education to support reform and improvement efforts, setting up regional organizations to provide support and services for First Nations schools and students, ensure adequate funding for the system and establish a system of accounting and reporting.

    "We were struck by the passion and commitment of the young people that we met and all of the people who are committed to First Nations education," said panel chairman Scott Haldane.

    "We recognized, however, that they do not have a system of support. There isn't, in fact, a First Nations education system in Canada. And without that support, it's very difficult for them to achieve the goals that they have for young people and for young people to achieve their full potential."

    Aboriginal Affairs Minister John Duncan and Shawn Atleo, national chief of the Assembly of First Nations, set up the three-member panel last year.

    Duncan wouldn't say if the government would implement any of the report's recommendations.

    "I'm not going to speculate on the budget, because I have no idea," Duncan told The Canadian Press.

    "The timelines that we're talking about are aspirational timelines. Money can't do everything. What we need is to change structures and other things. Everybody recognizes that. The national chief recognizes that. The national panel recognizes that."

    While non-committal on funding, Duncan told Postmedia News it's a government priority to "provide First Nation students with quality education that enables them to acquire the skills they need to enter the labour market and be full participants in a strong Canadian economy."

    Ontario Regional Chief Angus Toulouse told the Toronto Star he's optimistic about the panel's findings but he warned not everything can change overnight.

    "There have just been too many years of neglect," said Toulouse who speaks for 133 Ontario First Nations.

    Toulouse said Ottawa can prove its commitment to improving aboriginal education in the upcoming federal budget.

    In the short term, bringing funding for reserve schools up to the level of their provincial counterparts would help, he said.

    Aboriginal students receive on average $2,000 to $3,000 less than non-native students, which critics condemn as a form of discrimination.

    "The fact is the gap between delivery of education to First Nations and non-First Nations students has widened," New Democrat MP Linda Duncan said in a statement. "First Nations students should not be forced to wait any longer for their right to education to be honoured."

    What do you feel about this article?

     

    87 comments

    • Giles the 3rd  •  3 months ago
      Anybody as tired as I am with all this crap about how 'we' failed 'them' again for the umpteen millionth time?! Maybe they've been failing us!
      • stan s 3 months ago
        yeah like they want to go back to no modern inventions that we brought here
      • stan s 3 months ago
        oops forgetting about all the native inventions over the years...which one was that?
      • charles 3 months ago
        ***** em...
    • Brunhilda Swecker  •  Montreal, Quebec  •  3 months ago
      seriously? According to the housing crisis, the reason they couldn't pay for housing was because they were paying for schooling. Native kids receive free university, and education under university is, oh, you guessed it, free to.
      Furthermore, why can't they just go to the same schools as everyone else? This is like saying 'oh, we don't residential schools for Native kids only, but oh, we do want special schools for Native kids only.' Bit stupid really.
      • burlcoat 3 months ago
        they go to the same schools here......so where did the money go to fund their schooling.Did not go to the Public/Separate school boards.Enough of their squandering
    • raymond  •  3 months ago
      So the recommendations work out to wanting more tax money poured in. Oh and a couple of overseer groups to play "hide the dough" with it. The gap is a real thing between the school systems. Most of it can be traced to the money disappearing and alcohol and drug abuse. Treat those symptoms and the kids will have a far better chance at an good eduction.
      • Jason 3 months ago
        pretty sweeping comments there Raymond......Drug and Alcohol abuse is rampant EVERYWHERE......guess we should "fix" the drug problems in Toronto and across canada in ALL ethnic groups too eh?........and there is more "hide the dough" that happens with "main stream" cities and towns than in Native communities.......

        Perhaps IF you knew anything....A Reserve CAN'T spend anything WITHOUT it going through INAC first for "approval"....it;s total fiction that the Government doesn;t know where EVERY dollar goes.....because they do.......
        The "reporting" process is far more stringent than "regular" municipalities endure...
      • ANGRY 3 months ago
        you are starting to whine .get rid of the chiefs and councel and just maybe things would change they had a pic up of the chief she must weigh in at 350 lbs. and the people in the back ground looked like they were starving.....hum see the problem.............you know everthing go fix it
      • Jason 3 months ago
        wow.......maybe you should go get rid of the 350 lb mayor of Toronto and his stealing, lying "council" too...look at all the starving people in Toronto on wellfare barely keeping food on the table and a roof over their heads.......in your logic......you judge people on their body size?.........

        And as for whinning.......It's YOu people whinning.once you pay taxes , YOU no longer HAVE any say in where it goes..it belongs to the Government.......The same as MY taxes.......personally I don;t want MY share of taxes to go to foreign countries....BUt I have NO Say.........

        In effect, you comments are bitter, racist and "elitist" not to mention condecending even towards peoples physical appearance....

        Perhaps YOU should grow up and become educated.....as for many natives "appearing" to be very heavy.....perhaps an educated person would realize that Diabetes plays a large part in that.....and realization that the levels of Diabetes is extremely high in Native populations.

        Go cry about "Your taxes" somewere else......
    • Nate  •  3 months ago
      They need to be cut loose from the Government's apron strings. This is the only way Aboriginal people in this country will succeed. If they blend into society like all other minorities and quit living on handouts, they will be fine.
      • Garnetrose 3 months ago
        totally agree
      • maggie 3 months ago
        your both immigrants am guessing
      • grandadr 3 months ago
        they will dissappear like the dinos.
    • Chachi R. Cola  •  3 months ago
      Natives must first "want" to learn before educating them can be successful!
      • Garnetrose 3 months ago
        and they won't learn as long as we keep throwing money at them
        they need to go to the normal schools like everyone else
      • hippyfreezin 3 months ago
        way to copy someone elses post
    • Stan  •  Medicine Hat, Alberta  •  3 months ago
      more money for education? good accounting should be the first course taught.
    • RobF  •  3 months ago
      All you have to read in to this is who the panel was set up by.John Duncan and First nations chief,Shawn Atleo.Both bleeding hearts to the native cause.I wonder how many natives students would actually take the time to attend since they are already getting the education for free,and could not be bothered to attend.
    • richard B  •  Brantford, Ontario  •  3 months ago
      More money, are you kidding, how many ski doo's and ATV's can one family have.
    • Cory  •  3 months ago
      You need to WANT to be educated for it to be a success. By getting drunk everyday with my hard earned money that the government takes away and gives to them, of course it's going be a failure
    • 121  •  3 months ago
      Always MORE Money. How about inventing the wheel for a start !!!
    • Mike  •  London, Ontario  •  3 months ago
      Get rid of the reserves and that will end most of the problems.Iwent to school with many of them ,some were brilliant ,but as soon as they went back to the reserves they fell into their old ways.Those that stayed away and intergrated did well.
    • beachbum-  •  Edmonton, Alberta  •  3 months ago
      how much more money are we going to piss away on the first nations..they don;t pay for anything now..between them and quebec it;s the same old story..need someone on the hillto say enough is enough
    • Inacoma123  •  Vancouver, British Columbia  •  3 months ago
      Their school system doesn't need more money...what it needs is parental help to keep the brats in school. They are allowed to leave school whenever they want because " it's too tough to learn the white man's ways." Well here's a shocker for you, my native friends...you have two choices - a life of addiction and welfare or LEARN the white man's ways...suck it up and become part of our society, because, like it or not, your society failed and is gone.
    • interested  •  Saskatoon, Saskatchewan  •  3 months ago
      We tried to give them an education and all that happened was we had to pay more money for a bunch of crap about being pulled from their homes and culture. The natives have to get up on there back legs and start walking. I am tired of carrying them I am getting old and my back hurts.
    • John Smith  •  Medicine Hat, Alberta  •  3 months ago
      How long do you have to live here before you're a native?
    • A Yahoo! User  •  Ajax, Ontario  •  3 months ago
      First Nation?

      More like Lost Nation.
    • Ed  •  Squamish, British Columbia  •  3 months ago
      Cut them loose so that they can have respect for themselves. If you give any people just enough money to live they will end up like this.
    • ANGRY  •  3 months ago
      as soon as I read the title I knew the next words were going to be NEED MORE MONEY..,,,tax the reserves we pay school taxes why the heck cant they have a bit of pride and fend for them selves..they are the about as lazy as they come .........
    • mike k  •  Thunder Bay, Ontario  •  3 months ago
      give every one of them a pair of work boots and a swift kick in the #$%$ the treatys called for education and health care , BASIC. NOT UNIVERSITY AND PRIVATE HOSPITAL ROOMS WITH ADJOINING FAMILY SUITES . WHAT A GREAT DEAL THE BRITISH SIGNED US UP FOR. reproduce only what u can afford to care for .im tired of paying for those wastes of food.
    • JBong  •  3 months ago
      Just look at calgary. the alberta government was going to give them 400 million and 2000 hectares in exchange for 400 hectares to build a ring road. they turned it down. they want free money for nothing.

    Blog Authors / Profiles