Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Daily Brew

    P.E.I. schools to keep handing out Bibles despite complaint

    A school district on Prince Edward Island plans to continue passing out Bibles to students despite the complaint of a parent, who wanted the program to be scrapped.

    "I'll be held responsible for my child's belief system, not the schools," said parent Michael Arsenault to CBC. He is not against religion and claims to have religious books at home, but doesn't like the school getting involved.

    Arsenault's daughter attends the public L.M. Montgomery Elementary School in Charlottetown. It is one of many Island schools which have been passing out Bibles given by the Gideons, a non-denominational Christian organization, for 46 years. If parents don't want their children to receive the book they must submit an opt out form.

    Arsenault may not like the idea, but Eastern School Board Superintendent Ricky Hood said the program will continue.

    "We don't see it as an educational issue because we don't spend any time in class," said Hood to The Guardian. Just because one parent complains about something doesn't mean we are going to stop the program.

    According to Hood, parents with complaints about any program are usually referred to the school administration, who then decides if it is a service they want.

    He said it is a service just like other programs they provide such as Girl Guides, basketball or hockey. The teachers just send the Bibles home and they don't do any teaching in the classroom. "We leave that to the home for the parents who want them."

    Each province and in some cases each school board has the choice of how to handle the issue of passing out Bibles in school. In Ontario, boards decide for themselves after Premier Dalton McGuinty passed over responsibility.

    According to Gideons, the same group who give Bibles to hotels, fewer school want the books. "There has certainly been a steady increase in the past couple of decades of schools closing their doors," said Gideons spokesperson Kelvin Warkentin to the National Post. "Due to the religious fabric of our country being re-woven," boards are re-evaluating their relationship with Gideons and often cutting the programs after complaints.

    Gideons began passing out Bibles to grade five students in Canada in 1946.

    As for Arsenault's complaint, Hood told CBC there is nothing in the School Act that contradicts the program and this is the first complaint he has received about it. People regularly complain to the board about many different issues, but he told The Guardian, "We don't stop doing things because someone doesn't like it."

    (Getty Images)

    What do you feel about this article?

     
    • tonadachi  •  Burlington, Ontario  •  4 months ago
      This program, offered by the Gideons to grade 5 school students is entirely voluntary and not paid for by the school board. If the guy doesn't like it, all he had to have his daughter say was "no thank you." Sheesh.
    • shanny  •  Nanaimo, British Columbia  •  4 months ago
      I wonder if this guy will complain to hotels next - every one I've ever stayed in has one in the drawer. If someone doesn't want to read it they can close the drawer and move on. Just say no thanks to the school and get on with your day. I'm so tired of people getting out of joint because of silly little things. At the end of the day will it really matter?
      • mudslinger2 4 months ago
        Shanny you have summed up this situation beautifully ,simply but with clarity!!!
      • Snake 4 months ago
        wounder what you would say if it was the KORAN in that drawer????
      • shanny 4 months ago
        If it was a Koran in the drawer, I would probably pick it up and flip through it out of curiosity, then place it back in the drawer, close it, and move on. Why would I be offended?
    • pancho villa  •  4 months ago
      What possible harm could come from the Gideons handing out Bibles to the students? Everyone has the freedom to just say "no thanks". End if issue!
      • SR-71 Blackbird 4 months ago
        of*
      • Jeff 4 months ago
        The Gideons were at my university last fall. They were very pushy, and didn't readily take no for an answer.
      • Hannah 4 months ago
        they wont let other religions do the same thing, so why should bibles be allowed to be passed out?
    • Always Happy  •  4 months ago
      Majority 1
      Minority 0
      • A Yahoo! User 4 months ago
        Please, it's usually the other way around.
    • ProudMom  •  Cambridge, Ontario  •  4 months ago
      This man clearly has too much time on his hands. If you don't want the Bible, opt out. It's just that simple.
      • Delphic Greek 4 months ago
        Why should my child be singled out by being forced to Opt out. The same organization will also give you a bible if "you" contact them. This is proselytizing and promoting one religious belief above others in a public school. Whats next Creationism rather than Evolution? :P
      • scottandamanda2000 4 months ago
        Wrong answer Proudmom, buy a clue.
      • S M 4 months ago
        Would you be ok with some hardcore religious non-Christian sect putting their religious book on your child's desk, even though they don't have to take it?

        If you are, then bring on the Bibles. But if the prospect disturbs you, then nobody should be allowed to force their religious books on school children.
    • Steve Nospam  •  Montreal, Quebec  •  4 months ago
      "We don't stop doing things because someone doesn't like it."
      Too bad the CRTC doesn't follow the same standards, or they would not have banned the Dire Straits "Money For Nothing" from radio last year after one complaint in all of Canada!
      • Isa Noman 4 months ago
        speaks to the hypocrisy of 'the moral majority'
    • G.R.  •  4 months ago
      Probably related to the morons that had issues with O Canada being played in the school in New Brunswick
    • JoeSmelt...  •  Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island  •  4 months ago
      Dear Michael A. Get a life.
    • mitch  •  Waterloo, Ontario  •  3 months ago
      According to Wikipedia, 92.8% of PEI's population was Christian in 2005. There was a total of 200 or so Muslims for example.

      Do we still want to play the "Why aren't ALL religions allowed to distribute their books" game?
    • knh959  •  Victoria, British Columbia  •  3 months ago
      The schools should be teaching kids language, science, mathematics etc. Churches/parents are responsible for teaching religion.
    • in2oil  •  4 months ago
      Education and religion should be separate.
    • Doug M  •  Hamilton, Ontario  •  4 months ago
      It's true that Gideon Bibles have encouraged people for decades . . . I know many adults who went back to the New Testaments they received in Grade 5 and their lives were changed.
    • A Yahoo! User  •  Toronto, Ontario  •  4 months ago
      Personally, I don't believe religion has any place in a public school. However, if the school board is going to insist on allowing this practice, they should change their policy to an opt in rather than opt out. Children usually lose their consent forms or they sit in the bottom of their backpacks until the deadline has passed. Besides, if it were an opt in program, it would save the company money. I wonder how many kids get bibles because they forgot to give their parents the opt out form and what happens to those books?
    • Gerda  •  4 months ago
      Can't you get a bible at church?
    • Jeff  •  Vermillion, United States  •  4 months ago
      I wonder what people would say if folks were handing out scriptures of Islam, Buddhism, or books about witchcraft to students. Me thinks there would be an uproar. But someone hands out Bibles and it's ok. I for one am sick of people trying to push their superstitions down my throat, and if I had children, I'd fight this, too.
    • Megan  •  Mississauga, Ontario  •  4 months ago
      I think kids should be given access to religious materials like the bible otherwise they'll never be able to make up their own mind, as a child, if religion is for them or not.
    • nono  •  4 months ago
      Oh yea of little faith and loud pontification if you don't want a bible then sign the opt out form and move on.
    • reddog  •  4 months ago
      I am so happy they will continue to hand out Bibles to the children.
    • Knightgamer  •  4 months ago
      Give me a break people! It's a book and free at that! It could be the Koran, Inspirations by Budda or any number of books. You don't have to take it! WOW, some of you really need to take a PILL!
    • Gothickangel  •  4 months ago
      Just take it then sell it...or donate it to a family or someone who wants it.

    Blog Authors / Profiles