Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Daily Brew

    Study suggests chances of landing a job better if your name is Smith, not Singh

    Over 50 people stand up to take the Oath of Citizenship in Ottawa..Canada's officially a multicultural society and visible minorities are increasingly present in politics, academia, big business and the media.

    So a survey that suggests your chances of landing a job are better if you have an English-sounding name comes as something of a surprise.

    A study for federally funded Metropolis B.C., which researches immigration and diversity issues, found that resumes with English-sounding names received 35 per cent more callbacks than those whose applicants had Chinese or South Asian names, despite having identical qualifications.

    Researchers sent out several thousand resumes of job applicants with identical experience to online job sites to gauge the response of would-be employers. Only the names were changed.

    They found employers in Toronto, Vancouver and Montreal, cities with fairly diverse populations "significantly discriminate" against applicants with non-English names, the Toronto Star reported.

    Recruiters in Toronto and Montreal were 45 per cent more likely to call Alison Johnson over Min Liu, while the number in Vancouver was 20 per cent.

    "The name draws unconditional stereotypes, no matter what else is on the resumé," researcher Philip Oreopoulos, a University of Toronto professor, told the Star.

    The study concluded employers were prompted by fears applicants with non-English names would have language troubles.

    Oreopoulos said applicants with Greek-sounding names were also less likely to receive callbacks.

    The study was probing why highly qualified immigrants still have trouble moving past the low-paying, entry-level work many must settle for after winning landed-immigrant status.

    "A lot of our immigrants are let in based on a desire for them to assimilate into the high-skill labour market, but it's just not happening," Oreopoulos said.

    The research team sent out resumes in response to ads for office jobs requiring a bachelor's degree and four to six years of work experience.

    The study found employers likely to overlook those with non-English names even if the applicants stated their language skills and noted their experience was with Canadian universities and jobs.

    Oreopoulos said researchers did followup interviews with recruiters - at least the few willing to participate -  and found that language and social skills were the main concerns.

    Oreopoulos said it appears the discrimination seems to be subconscious rather than active. With little time to sift through applications, recruiters tend to pigeon-hole those with non-English names even if the resume includes information that would remove any questions about language or social skills.

    One solution, he said, would be for employers to blank out the names of applicants to ensure the best-qualified prospects are interviewed.

    "It's an easy thing to try out to see if hires actually improve from doing so," he said.

    (CBC Photo)

    What do you feel about this article?

     

    385 comments

    • Santa  •  7 months ago
      This is not true if you were applying for a job in at the East York Town Center in Thorncliffe Park......Or in Brampton Ont.
      • Ben 7 months ago
        You must be mistaken. Didn't they change the name to Bramledash, Ontario?? LOL.
    • Davinder Singh  •  7 months ago
      I laughed so hard at the title, maybe because my last name is Singh.
      • Andrew McCulloch 7 months ago
        I'd hire you because you can take a joke ;)
      • To 7 months ago
        well Andrew typically those with the last name Mc are less racist then those with Smith lol. simply because Mc is typically an Irish name and the British screwed us for hundreds of years so are less likely to treat others like that. :D people seem quick to forget 150 years ago no one would hire Irish when we came over and were treated poorly though not quite as bad as say for example black people but bad enough that Irish typically had better relations with other races looked down upon by the white protestents. suppose that's why you find so many african americans with a little bit of irish mixed into them lol.
      • namso 7 months ago
        you guys are jokers !
        lol
    • M  •  7 months ago
      This is old news - and the report is totally biased by the fact that the researchers designed the study to support their political agenda
      • Anonymous 7 months ago
        Show me a report that is not biased...
      • Jimmy G 7 months ago
        Show me an Asian not discriminated against or never experienced it in the job world.
    • tabootrailer  •  7 months ago
      Been in any Government offices lately? What a KNOB.
      • gord 7 months ago
        looks like pakistan india and china to me oh! did i forget somolia check out your aids clinics as well!
      • Economist 7 months ago
        You forgot to mention all the French people, as well.
      • 407 7 months ago
        Yes even though the country is still predominately white and English speaking, we have to endure all our government employees with an accent so bad you need a translator to understand them. I live in Canapakiquebinaranolia!
    • I, person  •  7 months ago
      Not in Surrey.
      • AngelaD 7 months ago
        Who's country is this one? Aboriginal's because they have been here thousands of years. I lived in Europe (worked and travelled for 20 years) and I can tell that real discrimination is not here, we find challenges everywhere when looking for a job.
      • A Yahoo! User 7 months ago
        actually it is here,im black and have an english european name [thank you slavery...not] but then they see me and see that im not what they expected what do you call that?
      • Iqbal Aminzai 7 months ago
        so mannny brown guys ... hahaha
    • phil c  •  7 months ago
      I work in Vancouver and the Indo Canadians that I work with always speak punjabi amongst themselves but when I speak french they complain to my Asian boss who warns me to be more understanding of my fellow esl staff members.I am the only white male in a company that employs ten fulltime and six part-time staff members I am also the only one that was born in Canada.
    • W  •  7 months ago
      We hire minorities where I work. In Toronto, white people are the minority.
    • orionstyles  •  7 months ago
      First name is probably the most important. I have seen this with 2 of my friends, one named Irakli the other Quasai. All if took was a 1st name change to George and David, and they started getting interviews (they didn't have to change their last names)
    • boshuda21  •  7 months ago
      As with many studies like this there is a lack of control experiments. Resumes should have also been sent out with the names Allison Liu and Min Johnson. This would the result be more conclusive regarding whether it was a language barrier issue or a race issue. If all names containing first/surnames that were Asian where chose less, then one could conclude it's more of a racial thing. If names (i.e. Allison first names with either surname) were more commonly called back then it would be a stronger implication that it was a language barrier fear.
    • Mike B  •  7 months ago
      Unless applying for a job at Pearson Airport
    • Lurch  •  7 months ago
      East Indians are racist to begin with. In Vancouver there is an Indo-Canadian business directory. This is to ensure that a white man gets none of their business. I never understood how they can get away with it. Imagine a white mans business directory!!
    • Fari  •  7 months ago
      My name is not English but I have been always chosen to be employed due to my achievements and backgrounds. For any reason we are in Canada, we should be together and make the world a better place to live in for our next generation. If we realize how short is the life, we wouldn't hate each other and instead try to be helpful and cooperative.
    • Frylock  •  7 months ago
      well, I see this issue as double edged - indeed there many Singhs [& Wongs, Ali-s & Tryphonopoulous! ] that cannot utter a shit of English! But on the other hand, there are several Singhs [ & Wongs, Ali-s & Tryphonopoulous! ] who know English way better than any prideful English native. So i guess the employers should be more prudent than just plainly stereotyping. May a short phone call to asses the language is a good idea - instead of out-rightly rejecting just by the name as well as loosing a potentially good candidate.
    • ashkara17  •  7 months ago
      Try applying for a job to a small business owned by someone from India or China... they would NEVER hire anyone with the last name Smith- it works both ways!!!
    • german helmet  •  7 months ago
      Also if your butt ugly ,over weight and have a cold sore leaking from your face your screwed!!!
    • corvusmark  •  7 months ago
      Buchanan in the U.S. famously asked: "Who would integrate faster into American society...100 Zulu immigrants or 100 English immigrants?" Anyone who is honest knows the answer. Multiculturalism brings conflict.
      When a company is hiring they must consider more than qualifications. Workplace morale and worker compatibility are vitally important so any smart business owner would choose someone they think has a better chance of fitting in. Human nature is the same in every culture -we all associate with our own kind. Most people who espouse the "benefits of diversity" actually do very little mingling with other cultures.
    • lina22346  •  7 months ago
      Hey the sad truth is that companies are aware of what certain immigrants do when they enter the Canadian workplace. And now they are very weary of who they hire. They are looking for those who are more likely to conform to the Canadian lifestyle. I don't blame them.
    • mataabunaideka  •  7 months ago
      This is a BS story... Here in Lower mainland BC you can't get a decent job unless your name is Singh or Wong... Indians and Chinese have over run everything here.
    • no better than u  •  7 months ago
      if your white apply to a chineese resturant on spadina see what happens then
    • sasi  •  7 months ago
      This issue is predominant with the 1st generation of immigrants but dependents who land up very young or are born here should not get affected.But still the name has an effect for sure and most Indian families would not like to make sacrifices on tradition.

    Blog Authors / Profiles