Roach talks about "genocide". Yet: Both Intifadas made about 6000 Arab victims, half of ONE good DAY in Auschwitz, without counting Treblinka, Sobibor, Buchenwald, Mauthausen, etc. The second, Polish, Warsaw Insurrection took 250 000 victims, about 41 double Intifadas. Yet, in spite of the extreme brutality, we don't qualify the crushing of Warsaw Insurrection as "genocide", because it has been triggered by the Poles, who challenged the Nazi army, knowing the risks. Many thinking Poles consider Bor Komorowski's order to attack the Germans as a crime against the Polish nation and I share this view, without of course justifying the German brutality. Both Intifadas were triggered by Arabs, who knew the risks and who glorify their heroism, their martyrdom and endeavor to annihilate Israel; and they caused a half day Auschwitz number of victims. Israeli alleged brutality could not be too strong, as in 20 years it resulted in 1/41 of what the Germans realized in Warsaw in 3 months. So one may talk about the alleged relative brutality of Israelis, perhaps even about alleged Israeli crimes, but not about Israeli genocide. At least, one may talk, yet it does not qualify Israelis, but the utterer, as a livid, thoughtless anti-semite

POSTED BY: Georges M on SUN, MAY 18, 2008 03:00 PM -0500

0

0

Report Abuse

 

Same old negotiating stunts to avoid peace and keep killing Palestinians. Talk, pullout, create another impossible condition. Talk, pullout, create another impossible condition. And Bush is buying it. The U.S. could have ended the whole conflict 20 years ago, just by leaning on Israel to be reasonable and recognize what they stand to gain with peace. This is fast approaching deliberate, planned genocide. Very soon, nothing and no one will help Israel, and it will disappear.

POSTED BY: Roach on WED, JAN 16, 2008 09:46 AM -0500

0

1

Report Abuse