Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    School bibles draw parent complaint

    A long-standing tradition that sees some schools handing out bibles to students should be scrapped, says a P.E.I. parent.

    For 46 years, a non-sectarian religious group has been offering free bibles to Island schools for grade five students. There is no discussion of religious issues in the classroom in connection with the handout, and many schools accept the offer.

    The offer came as a surprise to Michael Arsenault, whose daughter attends L. M. Montgomery Elementary School in Charlottetown. Last week Arsenault received a notice from the school asking him to fill out a form if he wanted his daughter to opt out of getting a bible.

    Arsenault called the school board.

    "I'll be held responsible for my child's belief system, not the schools," Arsenault told CBC News Tuesday.

    "I'm not against religion, any form or fashion. We've got a wide variety of Bibles here. We even went as far as to spend money to buy an English version of the Qur'an, I just don't like how the schools are getting involved in handing out these religious books."

    The question of whether Bibles should be handed out in schools is one that has been asked across the country.

    School boards in Ontario have been left on their own to sort out the question, after Premier Dalton McGuinty passed responsibility for the question to them.

    Eastern School District superintendent Ricky Hood says there's nothing in P.E.I.'s School Act that prevents schools from handing out religious material. He has never heard a complaint about it until now.

    "I think there's only one line in the School Act, and it talks about being nonsectarian, not being restricted to a particular religious group," said Hood.

    "I don't think anyone has pointed this out as contravening anything in the act for the past 30 years or so. I think if there was a local school group that said we don't want access to any of the Bibles, then we would abide by that."

    Hood said participation in the program is up to school principals, and any complaints should go to the local Home and School.

    What do you feel about this article?

     
    • teawithjim  •  4 months ago
      I remember being in a public grade school here in Ontario and those little red bibles were handed out.
      • Margaret 4 months ago
        And some of us cherished them.
      • Dann W 4 months ago
        Me too. I still have and use mine. And lone behold, I still turned out to not be a over zealous Christian fanatic. That little book gave me some solid advice in some times of need that I still use in my life today.
      • elizlucinda 4 months ago
        I believe in the concept of freedom of religion which also entails freedom from religion.
    • wes t  •  Winnipeg, Manitoba  •  4 months ago
      I remember getting those bibles in grade 5 (1980-81), most were torn up and littered the school yard for a week. If any parent was going to complain about their son/daughter receiving bibles in class they had a bigger issue to deal with: everyday after "Oh Canada" and "God Save the Queen" we had to recite the Lord's Prayer and listen to a short bible reading. This was a public school in an area of Winnipeg that wasn't very religious at all.
      • Jackyll 4 months ago
        Yep ... that religious stuff "brain washes 'em all" all the time. You are right ... it is really no big deal !
    • Jezebelle  •  4 months ago
      I think the only problem here is that it's required a parent fill out a form in order to opt out of the program. If a child says "no", leave it at that.
      • Alben 4 months ago
        Depends on the age of the child. Until 12 or so a child is not ready to make such decisions without a parent's influence.
      • tmoondancer 4 months ago
        Having to sign up in order to opt out is a very common stunt, known as "negative marketing". It relies on people not taking the time to understand what's going on and just letting it happen.
    • Et  •  Vancouver, British Columbia  •  4 months ago
      are they forced to read it or to take it? such to fuss over nothing. completely ridiculous. btw, i am not christian.
      • Dad 4 months ago
        Doesn't matter, the fact that it's handed out at all is offensive.
      • jaypeacdn 4 months ago
        To you dud
      • wp 4 months ago
        i don't think they are either forced to read or take it ! JUST SAY NO !!! no harm no foul !
    • MT Wallet  •  Central Kootenay, British Columbia  •  4 months ago
      I still have the one I was given by my school over 30 years ago!
      • A Yahoo! User 4 months ago
        Aren't you special...
      • Randy 4 months ago
        So do I, and I loved it at the time. Now knowing (40 years later) what I feel it really symbolises, I am not so impressed. But, hey, the best time to program someone is early in life.
    • unknown  •  4 months ago
      Believe whatever you want to believe, just don't push your beliefs on anyone who didn't ask.
    • jojo.coconut  •  Vancouver, British Columbia  •  4 months ago
      All religions should follow the 11th commandment...thou shalt keep thy religion to thyself!
    • Jethro  •  4 months ago
      I think theres a lot more things parents should be worried about there child picking up from school then a bible
    • Denise  •  Vancouver, British Columbia  •  4 months ago
      It would be probably be easier if the school sent home a form asking if you would like your child to receive a bible. It is not a big deal. I would not care if I was asked that nor would I mind if some other religion was offering their version of the bible. Lighten up people.
    • Robin  •  4 months ago
      Parents were given a choice, for this parent he chose to not accept the Bible, so it should have ended there for him. I'm sure other parents decided not to accept the Bible and they probably just went on with their lives. For those who want it then they should be able to receive it, I don't see how sending a form home and asking is invading his rights. He should have just ticked the no box.
    • Robin  •  4 months ago
      Another weirdo: "Robin, I am a science teacher and I can tell you that it is not fact. It is still considered a theory despite the assertions by some scientists that it is fact. The battle rages on so evolution is NOT accepted as fact."

      WOW. I hope you're not teaching in Canada.
    • Kevin L  •  4 months ago
      In Canada we have a saying when people hand something free to you ... it goes like this "Thank You"
    • k18  •  4 months ago
      i wonder how all of you guys saying "well if you don't want it, don't take it" would react if people started giving out free korans also.... then we'd see your true colours.... idiots, religion is bad unless it's YOUR religion, right? typical white conservative christian hypocrites....
    • the old dog  •  Burlington, Ontario  •  4 months ago
      So ... "one" guy gets to call the shots for a thousand people? How arrogant is this boy? Every single child given the books are given the right to say no. It is not forced on them at all. Every parent has to sign a form; or the child does not recieve the word.
      Who is this foolish parent to speak for all the other parents and all the other children?
    • carlh_777  •  Toronto, Ontario  •  4 months ago
      WHAT happened to free speach and separation of church and state?

      I am sure that not ALL parents oppose these bibles. Maybe the schools are afraid of children learning what they fail to teach... ethics!
    • bleagles  •  4 months ago
      No one controls another persons belief system. How many people are out there who grew up in a Catholic home and school who completely reject the Catholic religion as adults? We have freedom of choice and any book that has historical or literary significance should be made available to read by choice. Those who want to read the Bible will - and those who do not want to read it, will not. If you stand with a whip to force it or deter it - you will likely achieve the opposite of what you are attempting to do. Such is human nature.
    • brenda  •  4 months ago
      its freedom OF religion..not freedom FROM religion!!!!!!
    • Sarah  •  4 months ago
      Sheesh, sounds like laziness to me. You don't want your child to have one? Fill in the form and send it back to school with him/her. Don't ask them to stop it just because you can't be bothered to fill in the form. They've given you the choice. They aren't forcing it on you!
    • Canada First  •  4 months ago
      It is funny though. Christianity is forbidden, yet our schools are bending over backwards to "accommodate" Muslims. What is good for one group should be the same for the others.
    • Jim Sutherland  •  Halifax, Nova Scotia  •  4 months ago
      It's simple... I want my child to have a bible, I check yes. My neighbour doesn't, they check no. End of story, next controversy, please...

      In our zeal to protect my rights, we forget that otehrs have rights as well. It's a no brainer... those who want them check yes, those who don't, check no. And the Bibles are coming free from outside agencies... I live in the area and I haven't heard of any muslim or buddhist group stepping up to offer free literature.
    [ [ [['xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx', 11]], '27013743', '0' ], [ [['keyword', 9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999]], 'videoID', '1', 'overwrite-pre-description', 'overwrite-link-string', 'overwrite-link-url' ] ]
    Search

    News for You

    • Kansas governor signs bill effectively banning Islamic law

      KANSAS CITY, Kansas (Reuters) - Republican Kansas Governor Sam Brownback signed a bill aimed at keeping state courts and agencies from using Islamic or other non-U.S. laws when making decisions, his office said on Friday, drawing criticism from a national Muslim group. The law has been dubbed the "sharia bill" because critics say it targets the Islamic legal code. Sharia, or Islamic law, covers all aspects of Muslim life, including religious obligations and financial dealings. Opponents of state …

    • 'Disoriented' passenger subdued on flight in Miami
      'Disoriented' passenger subdued on flight in Miami

      An apparently "disoriented" passenger had to be calmed down and subdued on an American Airlines jet Friday as it was taxiing after landing in Miami International Airport, an airline spokesman said.

    • Alaskan crews gear up to tackle Japan tsunami debris

      ANCHORAGE, Alaska (Reuters) - Cleanup workers will soon attack a jumble of debris from Japan's 2011 tsunami that litters an Alaskan island, as residents in the state gear up to scour their shores for everything from buoys to building material that has floated across the Pacific. The cleansing project slated to start on Friday on Montague Island is expected to last a couple weeks, and organizers say it marks the first major project in Alaska to collect and dispose of debris from the tsunami. The March …

    • Apple CEO gives up $75 million in dividend income
      Apple CEO gives up $75 million in dividend income

      SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - Apple Inc Chief Executive Tim Cook will not be earning dividend income on the more than 1 million shares to which he is entitled, which will cost him about $75 million. Apple said in a filing with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission on Thursday that Cook had asked to be excluded from a recently instituted company program through which employees can accumulate dividends on their restricted stock units that are still vesting. Asked why Cook was doing this, Apple declined …

    • James and Durant headline All-NBA selections

      (Reuters) - Most Valuable Player LeBron James of the Miami Heat and top scorer Kevin Durant of the Oklahoma City Thunder headlined the list of players selected for the All-NBA team, the league said on Thursday.

    • Pope's butler arrested in Vatican leaks scandal
      Pope's butler arrested in Vatican leaks scandal

      Vatican police arrested Friday a man -- reportedly the pope's butler -- on allegations of having leaked confidential documents and letters from the pontiff's private study to newspapers.

    • Iran navy saves US freighter from pirates: report
      Iran navy saves US freighter from pirates: report

      Iran's navy said Thursday it saved an American-flagged cargo ship that was being attacked by pirates in the Gulf of Oman.