Analysis: Saudis have few options as they push tougher foreign policy

Angus McDowall
Saudi Foreign Minister Prince Saud al-Faisal speaks during a joint news conference with U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry (not pictured) in Riyadh November 4, 2013. REUTERS/Faisal Al Nasser

By Angus McDowall

RIYADH (Reuters) - Saudi Arabia seems to have few viable options for pursuing a more independent and forthright foreign policy, despite its deep unease about the West's tentative rapprochement with Iran.

Upset with the United States, senior Saudis have hinted at a range of possibilities, from building strategic relations with other world powers to pushing a tougher line against Iranian allies in the Arab world and, if world powers fail to foil Tehran's nuclear ambitions, even seeking its own atomic bomb.

But alternative powers are hard even to contemplate for a nation that has been a staunch U.S. ally for decades. Russia is on the opposite side to Riyadh over the Syrian war and China's military clout remains modest compared with the United States'.

Robert Jordan, U.S. ambassador to Riyadh from 2001-03, said there would be limits to any Saudi alliances with other powers.

"There is no country in the world more capable of providing the protection of their oil fields, and their economy, than the U.S., and the Saudis are aware of that. We're not going to see them jump out of that orbit," he told Reuters.

While Jordan was a senior diplomat in the administration of President George W. Bush, some Saudi analysts also say the kingdom is well aware of what major foreign policy shifts would involve - particularly any pursuit of nuclear weapons.

This could end up casting Saudi Arabia as the international villain, rather than its regional arch-rival Iran, and Riyadh has no appetite for the kind of isolation that has forced Tehran to the negotiating table.

"Saudi Arabia doesn't need to become a second Iran," said a Saudi analyst close to official thinking. "It would be a total reversal of our traditional behavior, of being a reliable member of the international community that promotes strategic stability and stabilizes oil markets."

Diplomatic sources and analysts in the Gulf say the kingdom, while unsettled, will not risk a breach in relations with its main non-Arab ally and will explore, however warily, a purely diplomatic response to the Iranian opening.

Top Saudis are nevertheless furious with Washington. Senior U.S. officials held secret bilateral talks with Iranian counterparts for months to prepare for last month's interim nuclear agreement between six world powers and Tehran, raising Gulf Arab rulers' fears that Washington is willing to go behind their backs to do a deal with Iran.

Saudi leaders were taken unawares by the content of the deal that was struck in the early hours of November 24, despite an earlier promise by U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry to keep them informed of developments, diplomatic sources in the Gulf said.

In Washington, a senior State Department official said Kerry had been in close contact with his counterparts throughout the two rounds of negotiations in Geneva, and had talked to Foreign Minister Prince Saud al-Faisal on November 25.

"The agreement was reached in the middle of the night and Secretary Kerry spoke with the Saudi Foreign Minister soon afterward," said the official, who spoke on condition of anonymity.

The agreement offers Tehran relief from sanctions that are strangling its economy, in return for more oversight of its nuclear program. Riyadh, along with its Western allies, fears this is aimed at producing weapons, a charge Tehran denies.

Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammed Javad Zarif suggested on Sunday the deal should not be seen as a threat. "This agreement cannot be at the expense of any country in the region," he told reporters in Kuwait. "We look at Saudi Arabia as an important and influential regional country and we are working to strengthen cooperation with it for the benefit of the region."

Diplomatic sources in the Gulf say Riyadh is nervous that the deal will ease pressure on Tehran, allowing it more room to damage Saudi interests elsewhere in the Middle East.

The conservative Sunni Muslim kingdom is at odds with Iran's revolutionary Shi'ite leaders in struggles across the Arab world, including in Lebanon, Iraq, Bahrain and Yemen.

Most of all, Riyadh sees Iran's open support for Syrian President Bashar al-Assad in fighting a rebellion backed by Gulf states as a foreign occupation of Arab lands.

Two Iranian Revolutionary Guard commanders have been killed in Syria this year, and rebels have also said Iranian fighters are on the ground, although it is unclear whether they are there in any great numbers. The Lebanese Shi'ite movement Hezbollah, which is allied to Tehran, has also sent fighters to help Assad's forces, although these are Arabs.


Riyadh has expressed lukewarm support for the nuclear deal, couched alongside caveats that it was a "first step" and that a more comprehensive solution required "good will".

But some prominent Saudis have made bold declarations that Riyadh will develop a tough new foreign policy, defending its interests in keeping with its status as the richest Arab state and birthplace of Islam.

Prince Mohammed bin Nawaf, the Saudi ambassador to London, told The Times newspaper that "all options are available" to Riyadh, including seeking its own atomic weapon, if Iran managed to build the bomb.

But diplomatic sources in the Gulf and analysts close to Saudi thinking say the main problem in turning such rhetoric into action is the lack on an obvious replacement for the U.S. security umbrella in the Gulf, or for the American military's role in advising, arming and assisting the Saudi armed forces.

"There'll be more contact with the Russians and Chinese than in the past. They've gone elsewhere for weapons before and we'll see some more of that, but the overall environment will be America-centric," said Jordan.

A Western adviser to Gulf countries on geopolitical issues said senior Saudis have looked at ways of reducing the kingdom's long-term reliance on the United States.

France is one option, albeit one that remains firmly in the Western camp notwithstanding past differences with NATO allies.

Riyadh has worked closely with Paris in recent months on both Syrian and Iranian issues, and has awarded it big naval contracts. That said, the Saudi armed forces and economy are so closely tied to the United States that any serious attempt to disengage over the longer term would be prohibitively costly and difficult, diplomatic sources in the Gulf say.

Washington remains much closer to Riyadh on every Middle Eastern issue than any other world power at present except France, which has taken a hard line on Iran.

In Syria - the issue over which there is the greatest disagreement between Riyadh and Washington, the kingdom is already arming and training some rebel groups which the United States, wary about arming jihadists, views with caution.

Diplomatic sources in the Gulf say these efforts will continue and may expand, but logistical challenges will hinder any rapid attempt to increase training much beyond the thousand or so rebels now working in Jordan with Saudi special forces.

Riyadh's own fears of an Islamist backlash, reinforced by a bombing campaign inside the country in the last decade, prevent it from arming more militant groups with ties to al Qaeda.

The sources say Saudi Arabia still relies on a lot of support from Western allies for command and control expertise, and would find it very difficult to build its own coalition of Arab allies to join forces in a military campaign.

The kingdom and its five closest regional friends, the other members of the Gulf Cooperation Council, have been unable to agree on a shared missile defense shield after years of discussions, they note.


Prince Mohammed's warnings on the possibility of seeking a nuclear bomb have previously been voiced by other top Saudis, including former intelligence minister Prince Turki al-Faisal.

But on closer inspection this looks less like a serious statement of intent and more like an attempt to nudge world powers into being tougher on Iran by raising the specter of an atomic arms race in the Middle East, where Israel is already widely presumed to have nuclear weapons.

The analyst close to official thinking suggested that actively seeking nuclear arms would backfire, making Riyadh the proliferator of mass destruction weapons instead of Iran.

Media commentators have speculated the kingdom could obtain an atomic bomb from its nuclear-armed friend Pakistan, or on the arms market. But the analyst said it would never place itself in the position of being an international outcast like Iraq under Saddam Hussein and more recently Tehran.

"Iraq did it. Iran did it. Saudi Arabia would never do this type of behavior," he said.

Saudi Arabia is in the very early stages of planning an atomic power program, and has signed up to the nuclear non-proliferation treaty and a more rigorous safeguarding protocol with the International Atomic Energy Agency.

Any attempt to build a bomb in secret would probably take decades due to the kingdom's current lack of any nuclear technology, expertise or materials, analysts believe.

Even if it were to attempt to short cut that process by, for example, buying an off-the-peg atomic weapons system from Pakistan - a transaction itself fraught with difficulties - the obstacles would be formidable.

"There's a lot of infrastructure to put in place, to make the threat credible and deliverable. It's not clear to me that Saudi Arabia would be able to do that in short order at all," said Mark Hibbs, a senior associate at Carnegie Endowment for International Peace and nuclear proliferation expert.

Such an effort would also incur a massive price in diplomatic and economic relations with other countries, notably the United States. The Saudi economy, reliant on oil exports and the import of many goods and services from overseas, appears ill suited to withstand such pressures.

(Additional reporting by William Maclean in Dubai, Arshad Mohammed in Washington, Mahmoud Harby in Kuwait and Dominic Evans in Beirut; editing by David Stamp)

  • Washington state governor tells British Columbians don't be 'daunted' by Trump
    The Canadian Press

    Washington state governor tells British Columbians don't be 'daunted' by Trump

    Washington state's governor took aim at President Donald Trump in a speech to British Columbia's legislature Tuesday, saying travel bans on immigrants and refugees have caused economic and moral wounds in the United States. Gov. Jay Inslee said people are questioning whether the U.S. will continue providing leadership around the world as a result of Trump's presidency. "With everything happening in our White House in Washington, D.C., I know many nations have questioned our nation's leadership on some very important issues and have questions whether my nation will remain a shining city on the hill," said Inslee, who is a Democrat.

  • Calgary police interrogation tactics may cause charges to be dropped in fatal hit and run

    Calgary police interrogation tactics may cause charges to be dropped in fatal hit and run

    Robert Mark Varley, 60, is on trial for a hit and run resulting in the death of Farida Abdurahman, 33. Varley had beaten three sets of drunk driving charges in British Columbia before he moved to Calgary in 2011. On July 28, 2015, about 10 hours after Abdurahman was hit, Varley was arrested and brought to police headquarters once police found his damaged Buick Regal a few blocks away from the collision.

  • News

    The biggest container ship ever to dock in Canada was in Prince Rupert, B.C., last week

    The largest container ship to ever dock in Canada was welcomed in Prince Rupert, B.C., last week, marking another victory for the city's international port which was viewed by many as little more than a pipe dream just over a decade ago. At 366 metres, the ship is longer than Canada's tallest building, the 298-metre First Canadian Place in Toronto, is high. Earlier this year, Prince Rupert held a celebration marking 10 years since the first container ship arrived in the city.

  • Looming 'compassionate cuts' to Alberta budget worry nurse, teacher unions

    Looming 'compassionate cuts' to Alberta budget worry nurse, teacher unions

    Alberta's teachers and nurses are concerned about looming spending cuts in the province. Last week in a speech to the Alberta Association of Municipal Districts and Councils, Premier Rachel Notley warned the crowd her government plans to start compassionately cutting spending in the spring budget. The cuts are not good news for teachers right now, said Alberta Teachers' Association president Greg Jeffery.

  • Manitoba premier opens up about getting lost, injured in New Mexico desert
    The Canadian Press

    Manitoba premier opens up about getting lost, injured in New Mexico desert

    Manitoba Premier Brian Pallister choked up Tuesday as he recounted a harrowing night in the New Mexico desert that left him lost, wandering and with a broken arm. Pallister was on vacation with his wife Esther when they decided to do a hike in the Gila Wilderness — a remote protected area in southwest New Mexico with limited roads, amenities and cellphone coverage. Thinking it would be a short day hike, Pallister dropped his wife off at the north end of a trail, drove to the south end and started hiking toward a meet-up point halfway, he said.

  • West Edmonton Mall's micro mall a local take on holiday shopping

    West Edmonton Mall's micro mall a local take on holiday shopping

    A curated micro mall in Edmonton is pushing locally-made goods inside the biggest mall in North America in time for the holiday gift-buying frenzy. West Edmonton Mall opened the mini mall, which it calls Retail as a Service, last month with 23 retailers from Edmonton and surrounding area. Mark Ghermezian, with the WEM ownership group, came up with the idea, saying he wanted to create a unique space for local retailers to open themselves up to a different market.

  • Indigenous kids largely apprehended because of poverty, says former child protection worker

    Indigenous kids largely apprehended because of poverty, says former child protection worker

    A former child protection worker, once with the Ministry of Child and Family Development, says, in her experience, Indigenous children are largely being apprehended due to poverty, and their parents are being over policed when trying to reunite with them. According to a report from B.C.'s representative for children and youth, although Indigenous children are less than 10 per cent of the population, they account for 62 per cent of children in government care. In an MCFD 2016 performance management report, the main reason (43%) listed for Indigenous children being apprehended is because their parents were "unable/unwilling to care." The lowest percentages of reasons include sexual abuse (0.7%) and deprived of health care (0.5%).

  • Phoenix pay system troubles ‘beyond unacceptable’: Auditor
    Canadian Press Videos

    Phoenix pay system troubles ‘beyond unacceptable’: Auditor

    Auditor general Michael Ferguson says fixing the troubled Phoenix pay system should be a top priority for the federal government. Public Services Minister Carla Qualtrough admits it took time to “get to the bottom” of the issues.

  • VA study shows parasite from Vietnam may be killing veterans
    The Canadian Press

    VA study shows parasite from Vietnam may be killing veterans

    A half a century after serving in Vietnam, hundreds of veterans have a new reason to believe they may be dying from a silent bullet — test results show some men may have been infected by a slow-killing parasite while fighting in the jungles of Southeast Asia. The Department of Veterans Affairs this spring commissioned a small pilot study to look into the link between liver flukes ingested through raw or undercooked fish and a rare bile duct cancer. Of the 50 blood samples submitted, more than 20 per cent came back positive or bordering positive for liver fluke antibodies, said Sung-Tae Hong, the tropical medicine specialist who carried out the tests at Seoul National University in South Korea.

  • Pit bulls no longer classified as dangerous dogs in Prince George, B.C.

    Pit bulls no longer classified as dangerous dogs in Prince George, B.C.

    Prince George city council has voted to stop classifying pit bulls and other bully breeds as "dangerous" and instead focus on the behaviour of individual dogs, as part of new rules around animal ownership in the city. The new "Responsible Animal Ownership Bylaw" comes as cities across B.C. and across Canada try to update animal ownership rules, with pit bulls even becoming an election issue in Montreal. Under the old rules, certain dog breeds, including pit bulls, were automatically classified as dangerous.

  • News
    The Canadian Press

    Police: Body of Quebec man missing in northern California found

    The body of a young man from Sherbrooke, Que., who had been missing for two weeks in northern California, has been found. According to police in Arcata, the body of 25-year-old Felix Desautels-Poirier was found in a marsh in a city park by a member of his family. The man's father had arrived in California last week.

  • News
    The Canadian Press

    Witness testifies about bad blood between Dellen Millard and Laura Babcock

    A friend of Dellen Millard told court that there was "bad blood" between the accused killer and Laura Babcock, who disappeared five years ago and is presumed dead. Andrew Michalski, Millard's longtime best friend, said Babcock confided in him a few months before she vanished about a dramatic love triangle. Millard had been sleeping with both Babcock and his girlfriend, Christina Noudga, at the same time, Michalski told court on Tuesday.

  • Family of reservist killed during training says he'd just graduated university
    The Canadian Press

    Family of reservist killed during training says he'd just graduated university

    The family of a reservist killed during a military training exercise in Manitoba says he'd just graduated from university last month. Nolan Caribou's family has released a statement through the military after the infantryman died while training at Canadian Forces Base Shilo. The statement says Caribou completed a bachelor of arts and sociology at the University of Winnipeg.

  • Doctors plead with Senate committee to protect their income amid tax changes

    Doctors plead with Senate committee to protect their income amid tax changes

    Three doctors from Cape Breton stood before a Senate committee on national finance in Halifax Tuesday and pleaded with its members to do whatever they could to protect doctors' income. The doctors are worried the federal government will put an end to a 20-year custom in this province of incorporating their private practices.

  • The adventures of Maggie the Cat, home at last

    The adventures of Maggie the Cat, home at last

    Maggie the Cat has always been an explorer at heart. Denise and Jeremy Whalen, Maggie's owners, were devastated that Maggie was missing. "People would text me ... they would tell me stories and that kept me going even more," said Denise.

  • Estevan teacher sentenced to 5 years for sexual assaulting students

    Estevan teacher sentenced to 5 years for sexual assaulting students

    A teacher from Estevan, Sask. has been sentenced to five years in federal prison after sexually assaulting multiple students. Troy Ruzicka was sentenced in Estevan provincial court on Tuesday having been found guilty of sexual assault and sexual touching. According to the agreed statement of facts, the incidents Ruzicka was charged for spanned from 2014 to 2017 when he worked as a mechanics teacher at Estevan Comprehensive School.

  • Liberal candidate Bob Doiron in legal battle with Workers Compensation

    Liberal candidate Bob Doiron in legal battle with Workers Compensation

    CBC News has learned the Liberal candidate in District 11, Bob Doiron, is involved in a legal battle with the Workers Compensation Board. Doiron has applied to the P.E.I. Supreme Court Appeal Division to review a decision by the Workers Compensation Board Appeals Tribunal. Doiron told CBC he was cut off of benefits and denied payment of surgery, which he says he needs to repair a hip injury he got on the job.

  • MLA Fletcher joins Coun. Dobson in opposing addictions-recovery centre in west Winnipeg

    MLA Fletcher joins Coun. Dobson in opposing addictions-recovery centre in west Winnipeg

    Assiniboia MLA Steven Fletcher has added his name to the list of opponents to an addictions-recovery centre proposed for a residential neighbourhood on the west side of Winnipeg. The recovery centre would offer Winnipeg a long-term treatment option for men suffering from addiction, something proponents say the city needs. It's named after the 25-year-old son of broadcaster Scott Oake, who died of a heroin overdose in 2011.

  • Conyers confirms harassment settlement; ethics probe opens
    The Canadian Press

    Conyers confirms harassment settlement; ethics probe opens

    John Conyers has dealt with various ethics investigations and a public corruption case that landed his wife in prison during a U.S. House career spanning more than five decades — longer than any other current member. Allegations that the 88-year-old Michigan Democrat sexually harassed female staff members may be the toughest opponent yet for the party's top member on the House Judiciary Committee. "He's not as sharp as he used to be," said Adolph Mongo, a longtime follower of Detroit politics who has worked on mayoral campaigns.

  • CBS News and PBS cut ties to Rose following sex allegations
    The Canadian Press

    CBS News and PBS cut ties to Rose following sex allegations

    CBS News and PBS both cut ties to Charlie Rose on Tuesday, less than 24 hours after several women who worked with him on his PBS interview show alleged a pattern of sexual misconduct, including groping and walking naked in front of them. Both organizations stressed the importance of providing a safe, professional workplace. Rose joins a lengthening list of media figures who have lost jobs because of workplace behaviour , including Fox News CEO Roger Ailes, Fox host Bill O'Reilly, NBC News political reporter Mark Halperin and National Public Radio news chief Michael Oreskes.

  • Robert Mugabe resigns as Zimbabwe's president after 37 years
    The Canadian Press

    Robert Mugabe resigns as Zimbabwe's president after 37 years

    Zimbabwe's President Robert Mugabe, who once vowed to rule for life, resigned on Tuesday, succumbing to a week of overwhelming pressure from the military that put him under house arrest, lawmakers from the ruling party and opposition who started impeachment proceedings and a population that surged into the streets to say 37 years in power was enough. The capital, Harare, erupted in jubilation after news spread that the 93-year-old leader's resignation letter had been read out by the speaker of parliament, whose members had gathered to impeach Mugabe after he ignored escalating calls to quit since a military takeover. "Welcome to the new Zimbabwe!" people chanted outside the conference centre where the lawmakers had met.

  • News

    UBC student with rare disease first in B.C. to be approved for $750K drug Soliris

    Shantee Anaquod, a 23-year-old battling a rare disease, has been approved to receive coverage for Soliris, a $750,000 drug that, until this week, was not covered in B.C. Anaquod, a UBC student, was diagnosed with atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome (aHUS) last month — and was shocked to find that the medication that could save her, though approved by Health Canada, was not covered in B.C. — even in exceptional circumstances.

  • News

    EU agrees to end country-specific limits for online retailers

    The European Union has agreed a plan obliging online retailers operating in the bloc to make electrical goods, concert tickets or car rental available to all EU consumers regardless of where they live. Putting an end to "geoblocking", whereby consumers in one EU country cannot buy a good or service sold online in another, has been a priority for the EU as it tries to create a digital single market with 24 legislative proposals. The agreement late on Monday between the European Parliament, the EU's 28 member states and the Commission will allow EU consumers to buy products and services online from any EU country.

  • TTC CEO Andy Byford stepping down after 5 years to lead New York City Transit

    TTC CEO Andy Byford stepping down after 5 years to lead New York City Transit

    Toronto Transit Commission CEO Andy Byford is stepping down in mid-December to take a job as president and CEO with New York City Transit. Byford said his last task will be to deliver the opening of the Line 1 subway extension to Vaughan in York Region, with its six new stations and 8.6 kilometres of new track.

  • Past SNL performers, staff sign statement supporting Franken
    The Canadian Press

    Past SNL performers, staff sign statement supporting Franken

    A group of women who worked alongside Al Franken on NBC's "Saturday Night Live" have signed a statement of support for the Minnesota senator. Last week, broadcaster Leeann Tweeden accused Franken of forcibly kissing her in 2006. Thirty-six women signed the SNL statement supporting the Democrat, including performers Jane Curtin and Laraine Newman, and many behind-the-scenes staff.