Brayford Trucking fined $100K for death of oilsands worker

Brayford Trucking fined $100K for death of oilsands worker

Jordan Gahan was just 21 when he died at an oilsands site in northern Alberta three years ago.

The New Brunswick man was doing remediation work at a site two hours north of Fort McMurray, Alta., on March 14, 2014, when the excavator he was operating fell through the ice.

According to his mother, Leica Gahan, her son somehow made it out of the cab, which was under four metres of water, but he drowned before he reached the surface.

"The next thing they reported was his hard hat floated up and his body floated up after," she said.

Company pleaded guilty

Jordan Gahan's family and friends were in a Calgary courtroom Friday as Brayford Trucking Ltd., Gahan's employer at the time of his death, was sentenced on charges of failing to protect an employee.

The company initially faced five charges in connection to Gahan's death: 

- Failure to ensure the health and safety of workers.

- Failure to ensure a worker is trained in the safe operation of equipment.

- Failure to eliminate or control an identified workplace hazard.

- Failure to ensure equipment is used in accordance with manufacturer's specifications.

- Failure to test the ice to ensure the ice would support the load placed upon it.

In the courtroom on Friday, three of the charges were withdrawn. Brayford pleaded guilty to failure to ensure its worker was trained in the safe operation of equipment and failure to test the ice.

Provincial court Judge Harry Van Harten accepted a joint sentencing submission that saw Brayford fined $100,000 and given two years of corporate probation.

"The Brayfords are clearly not hiding behind a corporate shield," the judge said. "I hope this provides the type of closure that allows people to move on in a better way."

Corporate probation means the company must complete a number of requirements over the next two years, including making a public acknowledgement of the incident, doing additional safety training, completing a third-party audit of the company's health and safety management systems and working with Alberta Construction Safety Association to create course content to better protect future workers. 

Leica said the ruling has provided a "sense of relief" for her family.

"The last year has been court proceedings," she said.

"There is a sense this is over but our fight will continue for work safety and health and safety for workers. Our fight will be not so much Jordan's fight any longer, it will be a fight for all workers."

Her efforts will be focused in New Brunswick, where she lives.

"I'm going to try to change legislation and work with Work Safe N.B. and continue promoting safety," she said.

'We can maybe save somebody in the future'

During the sentencing, Van Harten called the accident a "needless death of a young man who died as a result of insufficient safety protocol."

According to an agreed statement of facts, Gahan was not trained to operate an excavator on ice and was unaware of the need to calculate the load of his machine in relation to the thickness of the ice. 

Assessments done at the site to test the depth of ice and water were inadequate, the statement of fact said.

"In reality, when you lose a loved one because of somebody else's negligence, how do you possibly compensate for that loss?" said Leica prior to the sentence.

"We can't save my son, but we can maybe save somebody in the future, maybe we can change the way they look at things."

'Clearly no winners here'

Prior to the judge's decision, Brayford's defence lawyer Wilson Chan said the company's reputation and earnings suffered significantly since the incident.

Between 2013 and 2015, the company went from making close to $700,000 to losing more than $400,000. The company has also gone from 25 employees to five.

Since the incident, Brayford has hired a safety consultant and upgraded and expanded its safety program.

"Clearly no winners here," said Chan. "The family and the company have suffered significantly since Jordan's passing."

During a statement read by the company's safety officer and the wife of the owner, Susan Brayford, addressed the Gahan family directly.

Gahan's father interrupted her emotional apology.

"This is too much," he yelled, before the judge asked him to be quiet or leave.

Brayford said there are no words or actions to express how sorry the couple is.

"We take responsibility for the Fort McMurray incident, we take this tragic incident very, very seriously.

"We cannot take away your pain but we can promise you in this court by knowing better we're going to do better."

National Day of Mourning

Brayford Trucking's sentencing coincides with Canada's National Day of Mourning — a day to remember people who died from workplace-related illness or injury.

In 2014, Gahan was one of 169 people who died in a workplace accident in Alberta.

Leica, who is the health and safety representative for her family's construction company back in New Brunswick, says she's glad Brayford Trucking cooperated with the investigation and accepted responsibility in her son's death. She says the accident forever changed both the company and her son's co-workers.

"They never intended for Jordan to die," she said. "I know for a fact there's employees that worked with my son that never worked another day. I know that some of them are still in counselling. It affects everybody."

- MORE ALBERTA NEWS | 'She was not a surgical candidate': doctor tells gas-and-dash murder trial that victim could not be saved

- MORE ALBERTA NEWS | Imperial Oil posts first-quarter profit but falls short of forecasts