Advertisement

Murder by medicine: Report warns of proliferation of fake pharmaceuticals

Counterfeit medications are a growing global pandemic killing hundreds of thousands of people a year, warn health scientists.

A series of 17 new studies found that as much as 41 per cent of some of the 17,000 drug samples tested from all over the world failed to meet quality standards.

The repercussions are all too real.

Substandard malaria drugs are believed to have killed an estimated 122,350 children in African in 2013, the research says.

And while fakes are found largely in low- and middle-income countries, western patients are not immune.

“Although previously thought to be limited to low-income countries with weak pharmaceutical regulatory systems and problems with anti-malarials, increasing reports of a large variety of poor-quality medicines and medicinal products, such as vitamin supplements, in high- and middle-income economies are illustrative of the pandemic nature of this problem,” says the summary article of the special report published this week in the American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene.

Canadian problem as well

Indeed, during a one-week operation last year RCMP and Canada Border Services seized 1,869 packages containing nearly 139,000 illicit and fake pharmaceutical products with a street value of $627,000.

The counterfeit products included erectile dysfunction pills, anti-depressants, cancer drugs, anti-psychotics, female sex hormones and ACE inhibitors.

In a similar sweep the year before, the two agencies found 3,223 packages containing 238,820 illicit and fake medicines worth more than $1 million.

“Counterfeit pharmaceuticals is one of the world’s fastest growing illicit industries,” RCMP Commissioner Bob Paulson said at the time. “As the organized crime groups behind this emerging threat become more and more sophisticated, it is all the more critical for the RCMP to continue strengthening its domestic and international partnerships to stop the flow of these illegal and dangerous products into Canada.”

The RCMP action was part of an international operation spanning 111 countries that resulted in 237 arrests and seizure of nearly 9.5 million pharmaceutical products worth US$36 million.

Ten years ago, RCMP seized illegal pharmaceuticals at a Kingston, Ont., pharmacy and charged the owner with 12 criminal offences including the sale of fake and non-approved drugs.

The pharmacist was acquitted but a subsequent investigation by the coroner into the deaths of 11 pharmacy patients found that the fake drugs could not be ruled out as the cause of four of those deaths.

A couple of years later, a B.C. coroner found that a Vancouver Island woman had died of metal toxicity from counterfeit drugs she’d purchased online.

For the 17-study series published by the American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, scientists inspected the quality of about 16,800 samples of anti-malarials, anti-tuberculosis medicines, antibiotics and anti-leishmaniasis drugs purchased all over the world, including Africa, Asia and the United Kingdom.

They found between nine and 41 per cent of the drugs in separate studies failed to meet quality specifications. Some were poor quality and some were just fake.

Joel Alleyne, former executive director of the Canadian Health Care Anti-Fraud Association and consultant on the issue, says the profits can be enormous.

“If you’re selling drywall dust in the shape of a pill, then your profits are better than the pharmaceutical manufacturer’s profits,” he tells Yahoo Canada News.

He’s seen dyed chalk and drywall dust pawned off as pharmaceutical drugs.

Alleyne says consumers should buy prescription drugs at reputable pharmacies and be vigilant. Consider the packaging, spelling, taste and whether the prescription is in any way different than in the past.

The research team says techniques for detecting fraudulent pharmaceutical products have improved and they would like a global agreement akin to the international convention on tobacco control.

They also urge individual countries to enact stricter laws to prosecute those involved in counterfeit medicines.