Calls grow for Indigenous-led inquiry into systemic racism

·3 min read
“We do so many studies, investigations, inquiries, commissions, court cases, human rights complaints, tribunals, and we find out over and over and over again, ‘Yeah, we still have the same problem and it's getting worse,’” said Palmater. (Pierre Fournier/CBC - image credit)
“We do so many studies, investigations, inquiries, commissions, court cases, human rights complaints, tribunals, and we find out over and over and over again, ‘Yeah, we still have the same problem and it's getting worse,’” said Palmater. (Pierre Fournier/CBC - image credit)

Two prominent Indigenous voices say they support calls for an Indigenous-led inquiry into systemic racism in New Brunswick, but action is what's really needed.

Pam Palmater, the chair in Indigenous governance in the department of politics and public administration at Toronto Metropolitan University, and David Perley, a Wolastoqi scholar, spoke at a fundraiser for Dialogue NB, a Moncton–based non-profit, about systemic racism in the province.

Last week, the six chiefs of the Wolastoqey Nation in New Brunswick renewed their appeal for an Indigenous-led inquiry into systemic racism after the conclusion of a coroner's inquest into the killing of Chantel Moore by an Edmundston police officer.

It has been the position of the chiefs since Moore was killed, but so far the province has only appointed a non-Indigenous systemic racism commissioner who is expected to make recommendations by September.

WATCH | Pam Palmater makes a case for an Indigenous-led inquiry into systemic racism

"Why is the Premier refusing to initiate an independent inquiry," asked Perley.

"Why is he not telling the justice people, 'Let's find the answers …  let's ensure that we have Wabanaki people involved as part of the investigation, as part of the inquiry.'

"They should be part of it and not exclude them from the process. But that's not happening."

Action needed

Palmater told CBC News that while she supports an Indigenous–led inquiry, it will be all for naught if action isn't taken afterwards.

"We do so many studies, investigations, inquiries, commissions, court cases, human rights complaints, tribunals, and we find out over and over and over again, 'Yeah, we still have the same problem and it's getting worse,' " said Palmater.

"But then everybody drops the ball instead of taking the next step, which is what do we need to do to fix it? It's not like there haven't been thousands of recommendations to say what to do about it. It's just that governments and society haven't taken up the call to do that."

Education system

One area where Perley would specifically like to see change is the education system.

"We've been asking for changes to the education system, even in my day back in the sixties," said Perley.

"The chiefs of the day were asking for changes to the education system … We're asking for the same."

 Pierre Fournier/CBC
Pierre Fournier/CBC

He remembers two sessions he held with Indigenous people, one with elders and another with youth.

Even though decades separated their time in school, they shared many of the same experiences.

"Here are the elders who were in the system in the 50s and the 60s talking about racism, talking about... how badly they were treated," said Perley.

"Then I listened to the stories from the students who were in the system two years ago. It's the same. They're saying, 'Oh, god, it's tough being in that school because we're always being called savage.' "

'Be brave enough'

Palmater says an inquiry into systemic racism should extend beyond the justice system to include all aspects of life in New Brunswick.

"We have to be brave enough to open it a little bit wider," said Palmater.

"What about also looking at health care? What about also looking at education? What about also looking at social work or any of the public services that we have?"

Pierre Fournier/CBC
Pierre Fournier/CBC

Palmater said life for Indigenous people has gotten worse in many of these areas.

She said we focus too much on specific examples of a person doing good instead of looking at the collective community.

"We point to individuals, 'Look, he has a job,' or, 'Look, this person's successful' and say things are better," said Palmater.

"But it's not better if the majority of our community isn't better."

Conflict

Palmater said confronting systemic racism in New Brunswick will inevitably lead to conflict.

But she also said it's a type of conflict that should be embraced not avoided.

"We can't avoid social conflict," said Palmater.

"That's how everything good in this world has ever happened. Human rights, women's rights, ending slavery, Indigenous rights. It comes after periods of conflict."

Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting