Franchise Futility: Jaguars' QB History Filled With Failure

·4 min read

JACKSONVILLE, Fla.: Doug Marrone cant help but chuckle when reminded what hes had at quarterback during his NFL head coaching career.

Gardner Minshew might just be the best of the bunch.

Marrones QB depth charts read like a whos who of first-round busts, failed projects and career backups: EJ Manuel, Thaddeus Lewis, Jeff Tuel, Kyle Orton, Chad Henne, Blake Bortles, Cody Kessler, Nick Foles, Minshew and Mike Glennon.

Its borderline comical, really. Marrone is 39-51 in six seasons with Buffalo and Jacksonville, and inconsistent quarterback play has been a major reason for the coachs lack of sustained success.

Its the most important thing, he said. At the end of the day, you have to do the best job you can with the players that you have. I think even the best ones, there are some things that youre limited to, so I think you have to play to their strengths, and when they have a lot of strengths then you can play more to it and they can make a lot of other people better.

Now, Marrone might be headed in another direction at the all-important position.

Minshew has a strained ligament and multiple fractures in his right thumb, according to a person familiar with the situation. The injury could prompt Marrone to turn to rookie Jake Luton after the teams bye week.

The person spoke to The Associated Press on the condition of anonymity Thursday because the Jaguars (1-6) have not disclosed Minshews injury publicly. NFL teams are not required to submit injury reports during byes.

Minshew has played through pain since throwing for 301 yards and two touchdowns in a lopsided loss at Houston on Oct. 11. He had a season-low passer rating (70.5) against Detroit two weeks ago and misfired early and often last Sunday at the Los Angeles Chargers. He completed 14 of 27 passes for 173 yards and two TDs and was sacked five times in a 39-29 loss, the teams sixth straight.

Although Glennon served as Minshews backup through the first seven games, Marrone and general manager Dave Caldwell said Luton won the No. 2 job in training camp. A sixth-round draft pick from Oregon State, Luton has prototypical size and arm strength. But he lacks mobility and experience.

Marrone might as well give him a shot. Whats he got to lose? Whatever little job security he had entering the season has evaporated during the teams skid.

Marrone said earlier this week he already was planning to shake up things during the bye. He offered no details, but he insisted repeatedly he was fired up to make sweeping changes before Jacksonville hosts the Texans (1-6) on Nov. 8.

Im sure people are going to mock me for that or say whatever the (heck) they want, Marrone said. But I really dont give a (care). Im fired up. Im going to go after it and however it falls, it falls, but its open for me.

Ive done crazy (stuff) before.

Few expect Marrone and Caldwell back in 2021, believing a complete makeover is long overdue in Jacksonville. Owner Shad Khan hasnt made wholesale changes since firing general manager Gene Smith and coach Mike Mularkey following the 2012 season.

A new regime surely would select one of the top quarterbacks available in the next draft: Clemsons Trevor Lawrence, Ohio States Justin Fields or North Dakota States Trey Lance.

Getting it right is something thats eluded Jacksonville for decades, a stretch of QB futility that started with Byron Leftwich in 2003 and includes stints with David Garrard, Blaine Gabbert, Henne, Bortles, Kessler, Foles and Minshew. Adding to fans’ frustration: The team passed on a number of big-time college QBs in recent years, including Dak Prescott, Patrick Mahomes, Deshaun Watson and Lamar Jackson.

Khan, meanwhile, signed off on drafting Bortles in 2014, re-signing him in 2018, bringing in Foles a backup who became a Super Bowl MVP in Philadelphia but never played a full season in 2019 and then giving Minshew a chance to prove himself this season. Those moves cost the owner more $70 million and failed to fix a troubling trend at the position.

The result: The Jaguars are 41-97 during Khans tenure. He has a chance to tie former New Orleans Saints owner John Mecom Jr., as the second-fastest owner to reach 100 losses. If the Jaguars lose their next three games, hell hit the dubious mark in 141 games, one more than late Tampa Bay Buccaneers owner Hugh Culverhouse.

It might be up to Luton to help Khan avoid tying Mecom.

Its easy to place the blame on one player, one position, Marrone said. But its our job to … never use that as an excuse. So well see where we are. I think that well take a good look at it.


More AP NFL: and