Larry Fedora ridiculed for speaking the truth about CTE

Eric Adelson
Columnist

Larry Fedora went out on a limb, or off the deep end, depending on your point of view. The North Carolina coach said his beloved sport of football was “under attack” by those who are calling out the perils of head trauma, and furthermore, “our country will go down, too” if football succumbs to this assault. It was Vince Lombardi meets Jack Nicholson in “A Few Good Men.”

Fedora went on, sending Twitter into a frenzy in real time and giving columnists a sure-fire soapbox to stand on.

“I don’t think it’s been proven that the game of football causes CTE. We don’t really know that. Are there chances for concussions? Of course. There are collisions. But the game is safer than it’s ever been.”

It’s heresy. It’s also backed up by some people who know the subject well.

Larry Fedora made quite a splash at ACC Media Days on Wednesday. (AP)

“I totally agree with him,” says Peter Cummings, a neuropathologist and associate professor of anatomy and neurobiology at Boston University School of Medicine. “Association is not causation. CTE has also been found in individuals not exposed to contact sports. It’s not a settled matter by any means. And football is safer today than it has ever been. In fact, I would argue that no other sport has made a more radical transformation in response to safety concerns than football. His comments reflect the reality of the scientific uncertainty surrounding CTE.”

Nevertheless, USA Today called Fedora’s comment “a coup de grace of stupidity” and said, “If Fedora actually believes what he said, he’s too dumb to coach college football and should be fired immediately.”

The problem is that the media at large has made conclusions that science has not. It’s assumed that football causes CTE (chronic traumatic encephalopathy) and CTE causes terrible later-life symptoms when, in fact, CTE still cannot be confirmed except through autopsy and scientists are not yet at the stage when they can state CTE’s effects as fact. This is what Fedora tried to convey, albeit inarticulately.

Fedora didn’t say CTE doesn’t exist. He didn’t say there is no link whatsoever between football and CTE. He didn’t say football is totally safe. Nobody believes any of those things. We are at the point now where everyone who cares about football is worried about the long-term health of players.

What he suggested is what dozens of respected doctors are saying: the onslaught of negative media coverage has skewed the reality. If you’re a football coach, it probably feels like an “attack.” (It may also feel like an attack when a North Carolina columnist suggests Fedora “might have had one Red Bull too many.”)

Studies expressing caution about “settled” assumptions regarding CTE are largely ignored by the media – a mere speed bump on the way to the inevitable conclusion that football kills. Only a couple of weeks ago, two leading CTE researchers came out with a study that said this: “Recently there has been a significant amount of media attention surrounding the commonness of CTE in professional athletes, particularly American football, based on several postmortem case series. However, despite the persuasive claims made by the media about CTE, research on the disease and the effects of mTBI [mild traumatic brain injury] in general remain in its infancy.”

The study goes on to state that “clinical analysis of CTE cases are fragmented, making potential risk factors for developing CTE impossible to determine with confidence. Despite these limitations, media coverage of CTE is giving the impression that developing symptomatic CTE is almost inevitable if you are a long-term contact sports player.”

Most members of the media do not quote these experts, or even seek comment from them.

No one is saying football is devoid of risk. No one is saying football cannot lead to brain damage. Fedora said “repeated blows to the head” cause CTE, and he even said tackle football should not be played before middle school.


But there are many other factors that can lead to the frightening outcomes we fear, including drug use, opioids, genetics and even poverty. Multiple studies link economic status to later-life mental health problems. It’s currently impossible to control for all of those factors.

“It’s very likely there are people who have the [CTE] pathology and who don’t have a behavioral impact,” says Dirk Keene, an associate professor of neuropathology at the University of Washington. “Some people are more resilient to pathology than others. It could be that all football players after certain exposure get CTE, but not all will get behavioral symptoms.”

How widespread is CTE in the football population? We don’t know that either.

“CTE has been seen in college athletes and high school athletes, but these are a few anecdotal cases,” says Daniel Perl, a neuropathologist at the Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences in Maryland. “How extensive this problem is, we don’t know. The concept that a kid who gets a concussion is at risk and on the way to developing CTE is a real stretch.”

In fact, one of the nation’s concussion experts is at the University of North Carolina, Fedora’s school. Kevin Guskiewicz would ban boxing but he has sons who played football. He told the News & Observer, “There’s probably no better time to play sports, including contact sports, than right now because of how much more we know today about concussions.”

Yet caution is treated as callousness. Anyone who wants to wait for more information is shouted into submission, cast as a Neanderthal who is on the wrong side of history. Fedora had an opinion that is not without merit, yet there were immediately calls for his ouster. It’s as if he said children should pick up smoking because he has a friend who smoked all his life and never got lung cancer. The result is that we have a completely one-sided discussion that ends up being misleading. Then every head injury can lead to fear and anxiety, which then can lead to some of the mental illness symptoms doctors are trying to prevent.

Saying football is “under attack” seems like something out of an overwrought movie preview. But then again, look up “Larry Fedora” on Twitter and come up with a better description of the reaction to his comments.

More from Yahoo Sports:
’Can’t trust ‘em’: DeMar Derozan reacts to being traded
Meet the most interesting player in college football
Dan Wetzel: Lakers appear to be the winners in Kawhi trade
Jeff Passan: The scene as Josh Hader’s horrible tweets surfaced at MLB ASG

  • Surging U.S. deficit a warning for Canadians wanting tax cuts: Don Pittis
    News
    CBC

    Surging U.S. deficit a warning for Canadians wanting tax cuts: Don Pittis

    According to a new Senate report, what Canada needs is for its rich people to get richer. Of course that's not what it says in so many words, but in calling on the Canadian government to follow the U.S. in cutting corporate taxes, that is effectively what it is asking for. Perhaps it's simply a matter of bad timing, but the Senate banking committee report titled Canada: Still Open for Business?, obviously in the works for a while, has hit the media just as two serious flaws in the U.S. tax-cutting strategy made headlines in the U.S.

  • TSMC sees modest fourth quarter revenue growth, shrugs off trade war impact
    News
    Reuters

    TSMC sees modest fourth quarter revenue growth, shrugs off trade war impact

    By Jess Macy Yu and Yimou Lee TAIPEI (Reuters) - Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC) offered a modest fourth-quarter revenue growth outlook, predicting weaker sales of high-performance computers for cryptocurrency mining will partially offset solid demand for chips from smartphones. TSMC , the world's largest contract chipmaker whose clients include iPhone maker Apple , also shrugged off concerns over Sino-U.S. trade tensions hurting its sales, betting investment in advanced chipmaking technology will help cushion the impact. ...

  • Putting seatbelts on school buses a 'money issue,' former N.L. operator says
    News
    CBC

    Putting seatbelts on school buses a 'money issue,' former N.L. operator says

    A former school bus operator in western Newfoundland says seatbelts aren't being added into school buses because of cost. "It's very much a money issue," Dave Callahan said. "The minute that they adopt school buses having seatbelts in them, they're going to require at least a third more buses in this province because there will no longer be three [students] to a seat.

  • Tasty street names could be in store for future agriculture-themed Calgary community
    News
    CBC

    Tasty street names could be in store for future agriculture-themed Calgary community

    The future southeast Calgary community of Rangeview is tentatively slated to have some unusual street names. It's a large area that will be built in years to come, south of the community of Seton in the far southeast corner of the city. The developer, Section 23 Developments, says the street names are themed around edible landscaping and food celebration.

  • Price of getting high too much for some Sask. pot shoppers
    News
    CBC

    Price of getting high too much for some Sask. pot shoppers

    It was the burning question for Saskatchewan residents eager to mark the legalization of cannabis with a purchase: how much? With a lack of supply leaving Saskatoon and Regina shops unable to open their doors on Oct. 17, residents travelled to neighbouring communities to satisfy their curiosity — and their cravings. "Oh, they're high compared to what you get off the street, for sure," said Alderson, at the Eden store in the RM of Edenwold, about 30 kilometres northeast of Regina.

  • New iNdigital space showcases digital and interactive media at imagineNATIVE
    News
    CBC

    New iNdigital space showcases digital and interactive media at imagineNATIVE

    The rising popularity of digital interactive work like VR experiences and video games has spurred the imagineNATIVE film and media arts festival in Toronto to add a dedicated digital space this year. 

  • Priced too high? Shoppers balk at marijuana price tag
    News
    CBC

    Priced too high? Shoppers balk at marijuana price tag

    Cannabis sales were brisk around New Brunswick on the first day of legalized retailing, despite prices on many products that appeared to be the highest in Canada. Dameon Pettis was one of the first shoppers let into the Cannabis NB store on Moncton's Main Street but left without making a purchase. "The prices are just not in our price range, honestly," said Pettis.

  • Specialized unit aims to curb aggression in dementia patients
    News
    CBC

    Specialized unit aims to curb aggression in dementia patients

    Peter Grace, a 69-year-old retired engineer with dementia, heard a resident in the next room where he lived cry out for help and mistakenly thought the personal support worker assisting the man was hurting him. "He grabbed her by the collar and I knew he wasn't doing anything with malice," Grace's wife, Lucie Bechamp, recalled. Bechamp said the incident was out of character, but she added her husband did hate when others "invaded his personal space" and he shouted at others when they bumped his wheelchair.

  • 6 ways to do takeout — without the waste
    News
    CBC

    6 ways to do takeout — without the waste

    Takeout is a great way to skip cooking and the dishes. But it often comes with a side of guilt about all the waste — much of it Styrofoam or black plastic that are non-recyclable in most cities across Canada. The good news, given that it's Waste Reduction Week in Canada, is there are a growing number of options for zero-waste takeout, including some high-tech systems that could one day be deployed across entire cities to make throwaway containers obsolete. The simplest ones — such as customers bringing their own containers and restaurants not automatically offering things like plastic cutlery — are free and can even save restaurants money, said Lisa Borden, who has been trying to reduce restaurant waste through her website, Takeout Without, since 2010.

  • Bargain price oil: How long will it last?
    News
    CBC

    Bargain price oil: How long will it last?

    As oil from Alberta and Saskatchewan continues to sell at record discounts, American refineries are enjoying lucrative profit margins at the expense of Canadian oil producers. The sharp drop in oil prices began in late September and is expected to continue for roughly another month. The culprit is limited export pipeline space and refinery maintenance outages in the U.S. Midwest.

  • France's OVH to triple spending to take on Google, Amazon in cloud computing
    News
    Reuters

    France's OVH to triple spending to take on Google, Amazon in cloud computing

    The privately-held company will invest between 4-7 billion euros ($4.6-$8.1 billion) over its next five-year plan starting in 2021, founder and owner Octave Klaba, 43, told reporters on Wednesday. It portrays itself as a transparent and secure alternative to Google, Amazon and Microsoft, which dominate cloud computing. The sector is currently thriving on a greater need for IT infrastructure to drive new digital businesses, and now represents a major part of Amazon's profits.

  • Uber enters trailer leasing business
    News
    Reuters

    Uber enters trailer leasing business

    Uber Technologies Inc [UBER.UL] said on Wednesday it is entering the trailer leasing business. The new business, called Powerloop, is affiliated with Uber Freight, which connects truckers with shippers, the company said https://medium.com/@UberFreight/how-powerloop-helps-unlock-access-to-power-only-loads-e83268b06ead. Powerloop, which would rent trailers to carriers, is currently available in Texas, Uber said, adding that it expects to expand the new business to other U.S. regions.

  • China's JD.com unwraps FedEx-style parcel business to bolster sales
    News
    Reuters

    China's JD.com unwraps FedEx-style parcel business to bolster sales

    The shift pits JD.com into greater competition with major rival Alibaba Group Holding Ltd's Cainiao network, as well as dedicated domestic parcel delivery firms such as ZTO Express and YTO Express Group Co Ltd. China's second-largest e-commerce firm said the new service would allow businesses and individuals in Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou to send parcels to locations around China, using the firm's app to schedule a pick-up by one of the company's staff. The logistics network - which would be able to deliver most packages the same or next day - has previously only been used to ship packages purchased on JD.com's e-commerce platform or by third party companies that lease JD.com's logistics assets. "This marks the next step in leveraging the nationwide logistics network that JD has built over the past decade," Zhenhui Wang, CEO of JD Logistics, said in a statement.

  • Lights out: Hockey fans disappointed with Fantasy Scoreboard gone silent
    News
    CBC

    Lights out: Hockey fans disappointed with Fantasy Scoreboard gone silent

    "It's pretty disappointing," said Stockal, who received the in-home mini scoreboard from his wife as a gift during the last hockey season. Will Nault and Tyler Richards, two Edmonton-area hockey dads, created the product and started marketing it in 2016.

  • Photos: Canadians celebrate pot legalization by lighting up
    Yahoo Canada News

    Photos: Canadians celebrate pot legalization by lighting up

    They were elated, thrilled, ecstatic, overjoyed… and some just wanted to chill. On Wednesday, some Canadians waited in massive lines to buy their first legal grams of cannabis. Plenty were also keen to celebrate by legally smoking weed in public for the first time — something that’s still illegal in some parts of the country. Of course, plenty of people, such as those in Ontario, blazed without standing in line first. The province is beginning its pot rollout with online sales and moving to private retail stores in April 2019 at the earliest. There were plenty of events, both planned and impromptu. Toronto potheads lit up in Trinity Bellwoods Park, University of British Columbia students poured onto a hill beside a student centre to partake, and some immediately got high right outside cannabis stores. Here’s a look at how some folks spent their first day using cannabis legally.

  • Developer vows to make condemned building 'brand new' now that evicted tenants are out
    News
    CBC

    Developer vows to make condemned building 'brand new' now that evicted tenants are out

    The city condemned the 64-unit apartment building on Oct. 1 after it was discovered the heating system had failed in a building already wrought with problems such as water infiltration, insect infestations and mould. About half of the units were occupied when the city gave tenants, many retired or living on social assistance, 17 days to vacate the building, located about one block north of La Fontaine Park at 1150 Marie-Anne East. The approximately ten people still living in the building were forced to pack up the last of their things Wednesday. Some loaded their belongings into a truck while others carried what they could onto a bus provided by the city.

  • Golden Retriever loves getting dragged across the floor
    Rumble

    Golden Retriever loves getting dragged across the floor

    Either this pup is super lazy or it enjoys the free ride across the smooth tiles. Either way it's hilarious to watch!

  • 'One lapse of judgment': Mom of teen killed in train crash pleads for drivers to put away cellphones
    News
    CBC

    'One lapse of judgment': Mom of teen killed in train crash pleads for drivers to put away cellphones

    Sandra LaRose had been looking forward to going grad dress shopping with her daughter this year. Instead, just one day after her 17th birthday, Kailynn Bursic-Panchuk died, a few days after a train crashed into her car on a warm August evening. "I don't get to go grad dress shopping.

  • Convicted killer William Sandeson sues private detective that tipped off police
    News
    CBC

    Convicted killer William Sandeson sues private detective that tipped off police

    A former Dalhousie University medical student convicted of murdering a fellow student is suing the private detective hired to help his defence team but who instead tipped off Halifax police to incriminating evidence. In documents filed in Nova Scotia Supreme Court, William Sandeson alleges Bruce Webb, along with his former employer Martin & Associates Investigations Inc. and its owner Tom Martin, failed in their fiduciary duty to him. Sandeson was found guilty by a jury last year of first-degree murder for killing Taylor Samson in August 2015.

  • Rotor problem caused helicopter to crash down mountain near Tulita
    News
    CBC

    Rotor problem caused helicopter to crash down mountain near Tulita

    An accident in which a helicopter fell down the side of a mountain near Tulita, N.W.T., seriously injuring the pilot, was caused by a number of factors, says a report by the federal Transportation Safety Board. The Sahtu Helicopters aircraft was being operated by Great Slave Helicopters when it crashed on the morning of Feb. 15. A few hours later, he was taken by another helicopter to Yellowknife for medical care.

  • Out-of-province ID rejected at cannabis store, says P.E.I. woman
    News
    CBC

    Out-of-province ID rejected at cannabis store, says P.E.I. woman

    A P.E.I. woman says her government-issued photo ID wasn't accepted at the Cannabis P.E.I. store in Charlottetown. Rebecca Kelly is originally from P.E.I., and moved back to the Island just over a month ago. A supervisor was called, she said, and told her her card couldn't be accepted because it is a health card.

  • Conscientious dog learns how to recycle
    Rumble

    Conscientious dog learns how to recycle

    Teach your dog to recycle, reuse, reduce just like this clever pup! How cool is that?

  • 'Extensive' cockroach infestation, poor sanitation closes Edmonton Chinese restaurant
    News
    CBC

    'Extensive' cockroach infestation, poor sanitation closes Edmonton Chinese restaurant

    A north Edmonton Chinese food restaurant has been ordered closed after inspectors discovered a slew of health code violations, including a cockroach-infested, grime-and- grease-covered kitchen. The health inspection on Oct. 3, found Taipan Cafe at 10627 97th St. found evidence of an "extensive cockroach infestation" throughout the entire building, including the food. "Many live and dead cockroaches of all life stages noted in food and on glue boards, counters, food equipment, utensils, containers and structures," reads the Environmental Public Health inspection.

  • Take it or leave it? EU offers May few options on Brexit deal
    News
    Reuters

    Take it or leave it? EU offers May few options on Brexit deal

    An EU offer to extend a status-quo transition period by a year to end-2021, keeping Britain in a customs union to diminish the chances of the backstop being triggered, was not enough. Britain is due to leave the EU on March 29, 2019, less than three years since Britons voted for an exit in a referendum. ACID TEST All governments insist, though, that they want a deal in the coming weeks that can avoid chaos when Britain leaves in March.

  • Cannabis and Coffee: Pot info with your morning java
    News
    Yahoo Canada News

    Cannabis and Coffee: Pot info with your morning java

    Although cannabis is newly legal in Canada, the shop Cannabis and Coffee in Toronto has been a resource for those interested in the substance. No, they haven’t been selling marijuana, but people have been coming in to grab quality, artisanal coffee and snacks – including an impressive assortment of specialty cereals.