Even though Keith made a point to say that he's "not a dancer," it sure seemed like he had some pretty good moves and tricks. Especially when Keith surprised judges by busting out so many break dancing spins that he fell off the stage.
Fortunately, Keith's temporarily terrifying fall was intentional and all part of the act, and viewers ate it up. In fact, so many people took to Twitter comparing Keith to Napoleon Dynamite, and hilariously shared tweets like: "Keith belongs as the next Bachelor. These moves are a thirst trap." (@kpzimmerman75) Even hard-to-impress judge loved the act.
Cowell shared, "Keith, I've gotta be honest with you. Based on our little talk before, I thought, 'This is gonna be just awful.' And then, I just loved every second of it. I thought you were amazing! I mean, I'm not a dance expert. I'd rather watch you than the ballet, I've gotta be honest with you. I would!"
In the end, Keith got emotional from all of the judges' compliments, and walked away with four yeses.