Tell me if you've heard this before: The Toronto Maple Leafs have a multi-goal lead but their opponents come back to win the game.
Wednesday’s tilt against the New York Rangers played out exactly like that, with the Leafs having a 3-1 lead at the first intermission, and the hometown Rags storming back to earn a 6-3 victory with five consecutive goals.
Toronto head coach Sheldon Keefe called out his team’s effort during his post-game availability, specifically citing the defensive side of their performance.
“I just thought we got exposed today for being a team that was just soft… soft and purposeless.”
Leafs head coach Sheldon Keefe reacts to blowing a 3-1 lead and losing on Wednesday night pic.twitter.com/V9b4TIsZOu
— Tim and Friends (@timandfriends) January 20, 2022
"Today, I just thought we played soft, and we made poor decisions defensively," Keefe said.
"We couldn't sort anything out. It was just far different. Each game has been different, so it's hard to talk about patterns other than the obvious that we've been giving up leads. I just thought we got exposed today for being a team that was just soft, soft and purposeless, and just kind of playing the game and hoping it was going to work out.
"I didn't think we had anybody that played well tonight. Coaches didn't coach well tonight. So, today is a much different game than we've played in the others where we've given up leads and such. I just didn't think we had nearly enough urgency or purpose."
The Leafs were without two of their top four defenseman in Jake Muzzin (concussion) and Justin Holl (COVID protocol) in New York, but missing personnel is something that can be overcome. Keefe pondered if it was a larger-scale issue that keeps putting the Leafs in this position.
“We’ve had a lot of really good starts,” Keefe said. “Obviously it’s been the finish or the second half of games that haven’t gone well. ...Maybe a fast start was working against us. We thought it would be easy the rest of the way. We paid for it.”
Toronto let three third-period leads get washed away by their opponents in the previous four games before Wednesday, making it more of a concerning trend than coincidental bad luck.
The Leafs will take another stab at trying to hold a multi-goal lead when they visit Islanders on Saturday.
More from Yahoo Sports