1 / 20

Team Michael Pro: They have the cutest “meet cute” ever.

Jane mistook Michael for a stripper cop at her 21st birthday party, even taking his gun and shooting it into the ceiling! Party foul! But he stayed, watched telenovelas all night with her, and share a sweet first kiss under the fake snow produced by the bullet hole.

(Credit: The CW)

Team Rafael vs. Team Michael: Which Guy Should Jane the Virgin Choose?

Kelly Woo
Writer, Yahoo Entertainment

The titular heroine of Jane the Virgin has faced many romantic ups and downs in the last season and a half. When we first met Jane (Gina Rodriguez), she was dating and later got engaged to Det. Michael Cordero (Brett Dier). Then, she was accidentally inseminated and impregnated by Rafael Solano (Justin Baldoni), a wealthy hotelier whom she once had a crush on.

Since then, Jane has bounced between the two men — her first love and the father of her baby, Mateo. This being a telenovela, we don’t see this love triangle getting resolved anytime soon. Fans are passionately divided between the two camps, Team Michael and Team Rafael. But which team’s got the better case? Here are their pros — and cons!

Jane the Virgin airs Mondays at 9 p.m. on The CW.