Surprise Elimination On Dancing With The Stars: All-Stars

Access Hollywood
The cast during Week 2 of 'Dancing with the Stars: All-Stars,' Oct. 1, 2012 -- ABC

There was a surprise twist on "Dancing with the Stars: All-Stars" on Tuesday night, as a former runner-up was eliminated from the race for the highly-coveted Season 15 mirrorball trophy.

"I'll miss everybody out here because everybody was great," Joey Fatone, a veteran of Season 4, told show co-host Brooke Burke Charvet after learning the news. "[I] had a great time. You know what? For me, I'm actually going to a wedding tomorrow so... I'm gonna have a good time."

PLAY IT NOW: Bristol Palin Turns Into A ‘Redneck Woman’ On Dancing With The Stars: All Stars

Joey and partner Kym Johnson had been in the Bottom 2 group, not with Bristol Palin and Mark Ballas, who scored just 18 points on Monday (the lowest score of the night), but with Helio Castroneves and Chelsie Hightower.

It was former "DWTS" winner Helio's first ever time in the Bottom 2.

VIEW THE PHOTOS: Dancing With The Stars: All-Stars — Week 2 Highlights

But it was Joey and Kym who got the bad news, and although he was forced to leave the competition, the former *NSYNC performer said he felt like he put in a good showing.

"I know that me and Kym, I didn't let you down," Joey said, turning to his partner. "We had a great time, people said I was fun and that's all that matters."

Kym, who made it to a second place finish in Season 4 with Joey in 2007 (losing to Apolo Anton Ohno and Julianne Hough), said she was actually disappointed.

VIEW THE PHOTOS: Kirstie Alley’s ‘Dancing With The Stars’ Transformation: A Look Back

"I'm upset, I'm sad, I'm not gonna lie," she said of their elimination.

"It happens," Joey said, trying to cheer his pro up. "It's the 'All-Stars.'"

VIEW THE PHOTOS: The (Nearly) Shirtless Pros Of ‘Dancing With The Stars’

"The 'All-Stars' -- it's an amazing season to be a part of," she said.

Also placed in the bottom group, although never defined as a "Bottom 3," were Kelly Monaco and Val Chmerkovskiy, who were saved to dance another week.

Beyond Joey's exit news, show co-host Tom Bergeron revealed next week, two celebs will be eliminated from the competition.

"DWTS: All-Stars" returns to ABC on Monday at 8/7c.

Copyright 2012 by NBC Universal, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.