What would happen if Brian Laundrie is never found?

·5 min read
What would happen if Brian Laundrie is never found?

After a month-long search for Brian Laundrie, human remains were found near personal belongings of the missing man in the Myakkahatchee Creek Environmental Park, although no confirmation as to the identity of the deceased person has been made.

For over a month, searches led by both the North Port Police and the FBI turned up no new clues as to his whereabouts, and a scattering of reported sightings across the country were largely proven false.

Mr Laundrie disappeared after taking a hike into the Carlton Reserve near North Port, Florida, two days after his girlfriend, Gabby Petito, was reported missing. He returned from a cross country road trip without her, and her family became suspicious after the woman failed to check in for several days.

Since then, searches in the Carlton Reserve took place nearly every day, but survival experts agree that even a highly-trained survival expert would struggle evading capture and staying alive in the swamp for weeks on end, leading them to believe Mr Laundrie is either not in the swamp, or he is dead.

The North Port police agree, with Public Information Officer Josh Taylor claiming the likelihood of Mr Laundrie’s survival was “50-50.”

In the meantime, former FBI agents have warned that the agency cannot indefinitely task agents to hunting Mr Laundrie, and that at some point - likely soon - the agency will have to shift focus back to its primary mission. Even Dog the Bounty Hunter - who sustained an ankle injury - has left Florida to return to Colorado, vowing he would rejoin the search if a “solid lead” surfaces.

In October, Teton County Coroner Dr Brent Blue revealed that Ms Petito died from manual strangulation. The public’s attention once again turned to Mr Laundrie, who has still never explained to police what happened in Wyoming.

It is unclear if Mr Laundrie will ever be forced to tell that story, raising the question: what happens if he is never found?

Can his parents be charged with a crime?

The only charges that have resulted from the Gabby Petito case thus far has been a bank fraud charge against Mr Laundrie for using Ms Petito's debit card after he left her in Wyoming, and, presumably, after her death.

No charges have been brought against Mr Laundrie's family, and it’s unclear whether any charges could be brought against them.

Until the warrant for Mr Laundrie's arrest was issued, the Laundrie parents would have been well within their rights to assist their son in any capacity, as he was not a wanted criminal.

If it is found that the Laundries helped their son after a warrant was issued, they could potentially face charges for aiding and abetting a fugitive. However, if they have not, then there are no currently known reasons why a prosecutor would bring charges against the parents.

Brian Laundrie talking to police in Utah on 12 August (AP)
Brian Laundrie talking to police in Utah on 12 August (AP)

Can Mr Laundrie be tried in absentia?

In the event that Mr Laundrie is not located, and if murder charges are brought against him, some have wondered if he could be tried in absentia for her death.

In the US, Rule 43 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure dictate that an individual who flees during the course of a trial can be tried and convicted in absentia.

However, Mr Laundrie has not been arrested or faced a court date, meaning he can not be tried in absentia.

The 1993 Supreme Court ruling in Crosby v United States “prohibits the trial in absentia of a defendant who is not present at the beginning of trial”.

Until Mr Laundrie is found and brought in for a trial, he cannot be tried.

Chris and Roberta Laundrie leave their home in North Port, Florida (Twitter.com/BrianEntin)
Chris and Roberta Laundrie leave their home in North Port, Florida (Twitter.com/BrianEntin)

What if Mr Laundrie is dead?

Some have theorised that Mr Laundrie may have killed himself or died in the Carlton Reserve, where alligators and venomous snakes are plentiful. Human remains were found in the connecting Myakkahatchee Creek Environmental Park, close to personal items of Mr Laundrie’s, although no identity was immediately confirmed.

If Mr Laundrie has died, he could not be tried for murder posthumously. Under the US legal system, a defendant in a trial must be available to mount a legal defense. Since Mr Laundrie would be unable to stand trial in court in the event of his death, he could not be tried for murder or any other charges that may arise from the death of Ms Petito.

Ms Petito’s death could still be investigated and - providing evidence supports such a claim - a murderer could be identified, even if they were dead. However, that person would both need to be alive and be found and arrested before they could stand trial.

Are there any fugitives who have never been caught?

Mr Laundrie is hardly the first person charged with a crime to evade capture. When compared to other fugitives who have evaded capture, Mr Laundrie has not been on the run for that long.

Seth Ferranti, who was wanted for non-violent drug trafficking charges, evaded capture for two years before he was eventually caught and convicted.

John Lee Paul, an American race car driver, was wanted for questioning in the disappearance of his ex-girlfriend and was last seen on his boat in Thailand. He has been missing 2001.

Robert William Fisher disappeared in April 2001 after his house in Scottsdale, Arizona exploded, killing his family. He was suspected of rigging a natural gas explosion to kill his family, but has never been found.

While there are dozens of fugitives who have evaded capture, perhaps the most famous is the legendary DB Cooper, who hijacked a Northwest Orient Airlines flight in 1971 and parachuted out of it somewhere over the Pacific Northwest with $200,000, about the same purchasing power as $1.3m today, that he had extorted. No trace of Mr Cooper, save for a few bands of disintegrated $20 bills, has ever been found.

Read More

Brian Laundrie: Everything we know about Gabby Petito’s boyfriend as manhunt continues

Gabby Petito’s mother describes moment she was told Brian Laundrie had returned to Florida alone

Is Brian Laundrie still alive? Family attorney believes missing fugitive is in Carlton Reserve as campsite found

Gabby Petito live: Police note found on Brian Laundrie’s car

What has happened to Gabby Petito? Everything we know so far

A timeline of the disappearance of Gabby Petito

Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting