Ontario family waits 'many, many hours' for ambulance for dad in emergency need: 'Wait kills people'
A post on social media viewed 70,000 times suggests it's an all-too-familiar ordeal for families across Canada
An Ontario resident and his family suffered an all-too-familiar ordeal when they had to wait "many, many hours" for an ambulance for their father — an issue for which writer Mike Gerald Gibbs blames "the Ford government 100%."
On Sunday, Oct. 15, Gibbs, from Ajax, Ont., posted on X, formerly known as Twitter, that his father had been waiting for an ambulance for hours.
According to Gibbs, a nurse checked his father and declared it as an emergency. The request for the paramedics was made by the nurse.
We've been waiting for an ambulance and emergency assistance for Dad for many, many hours now.
Our health system is in a permanent state of collapse that is killing people every day.
It didn't have to be like this. I blame the Ford government 100%.#onpoli— Mike Gerald Gibbs🏳️🌈 (He/Him) (@Mikeggibbs) October 16, 2023
His tweet got over 300 responses and has since been viewed more than 70,000 times. Many of the replies included people sharing similar experiences and frustration with emergency healthcare across the country.
One reply read:
“I’m sorry. In 2021, it took me 2 days to get a non-emergency ambulance for my dad. He then spent 6 hrs in a hallway.”
I’m sorry. In 2021, it took me 2 days to get a non-emergency ambulance for my dad. He then spent 6 hrs in a hallway. But he did get a diagnosis (stage 4 prostate cncr) catheter, urologist and CTscan which we’d been waiting months for. Got another 18 mths with him. Good luck.
— Drawing a Blank - SHAME on Therme Canada (@drawingablank10) October 16, 2023
Another user responded with a similar experience in which an injured 12-year-old had waited over 90 minutes for an ambulance to arrive.
same experience in Markham in August. 12yo kid injured at an arena, nurse went on the ice, unable to mobilize kid as he lay on the ice, arena staff called ambulance. 90+ minutes later, ambo arrived. Kid had to be rushed to surgery at hospital in fears of permanent nerve damage
— L𝔼ℕN𝐘 𝔹𝕚𝕔𝕜𝕗𝕠𝕣𝕕 (@SuiteTuites) October 16, 2023
'You have to be literally dying' to get help
Gibbs wrote follow-ups to his initial tweet, stating his father was “ok” at the moment, but in severe pain and had trouble breathing. He also called out the provincial government, saying you need to be “literally dying” or you will have to wait a long time for emergency assistance.
So far, the responses to Gibbs’ tweet call for change, with Canadians from other provinces chiming in about their emergency services.
Dad is "ok" at the moment, not in danger of imminent death as far as we can tell but he can't breathe well and is in severe pain.
He requires a check by paramedics and physical adjusting we can't do ourselves.
A nurse checked and declared it an emergency requested paramedics— Mike Gerald Gibbs🏳️🌈 (He/Him) (@Mikeggibbs) October 16, 2023
Yahoo Canada reached out to Gibbs, but did not hear back by publication time.
In today's world created by the Ford government, you have to be literally dying or you have to wait endless hours for emergency assistance.
And that wait kills people.
So sure, he's holding on now but that could change any second.— Mike Gerald Gibbs🏳️🌈 (He/Him) (@Mikeggibbs) October 16, 2023
No data on 'code black'
Currently, there is no data gathered in Ontario for situations labelled as “code zero” or “code black” — where there are no ambulances available in the region. There is also no agreement on who should be tracking said data. Neither the province nor the municipalities claim responsibility.
Niko Georgiadis, chair of the CUPE Ambulance Committee of Ontario, told The Canadian Press in a July 20 article, that since the province primarily runs ambulance dispatch centres, it should be keeping track of how frequently there are no ambulances available.
However, according to a representative for Health Minister Sylvia Jones, the province does not keep track of such data since municipalities are in charge of ambulance deployment strategies.
While searching through the statistics for his own region, Essex-Windsor EMS Chief Bruce Krauter discovered that between January and May 2023, code blacks tended to occur between 3 p.m. and 11 p.m. He attributes this to the lack of urgent care centres and primary care during those hours and has requested that Jones pay for those services during additional hours.
What do the governing health bodies track?
In accordance with provincial legislation, local towns annually set goals for emergency medical response times. Response times are determined by the Canadian Triage Acuity Score (CTAS), a widely used metric that ranks patient treatment according to severity, indicators, and symptoms.
CTAS is categorized into five levels. CTAS 1, the most prioritized level, is for the severest cases that require resuscitation and immediate aggressive interventions. CTAS 5 is for conditions that may be acute but non-urgent.
In 2022, The Region of Durham, the municipality Ajax belongs to, had a goal of eight minutes per response time with a success target of 75 per cent for CTAS 1 cases. They were only able to achieve their target 63.7 per cent of the time.
Patient Type | Plan in Minutes | Plan in Percentage | Performance in Percentage |
---|---|---|---|
CTAS 1 | 8 | 75% | 63.7% |
CTAS 2 | 10 | 75% | 72.0% |
CTAS 3 | 15 | 75% | 87.6% |
CTAS 4 | 20 | 75% | 93.5% |
CTAS 5 | 25 | 75% | 96.2% |
SCA | 6 | 60% | 44.8% |
The government also collects data on time spent in hospital waiting rooms by paramedics, which is a key factor in response times. However, they do not share the data with the public.