Video shows rally in Norway, not response to Columbia University protest | Fact check

Andre Byik, USA TODAY
·2 min read

The claim: Video shows pro-Palestinian rallies held in response to student suspensions at Columbia University

An April 28 Instagram post (direct link, archive link) shows several clips from large pro-Palestinian protests.

"This what happens when you suspend 15 students for supporting Palestine @ Colombia (sic) University," reads texts atop the video.

The post was liked more than 4,000 times in two days.

More from the Fact-Check Team: How we pick and research claims | Email newsletter | Facebook page

Our rating: False

The video is miscaptioned. It shows pro-Palestinian demonstrations that were held in Norway before students at Columbia University set up a protest camp.

Video shows pro-Palestinian rallies held before Columbia protest

Pro-Palestinian activists protesting the Israel-Hamas war established an encampment at Columbia University on April 17. In an April 18 letter to the New York Police Department, the university's president, Minouche Shafik, said Columbia University students participating in the encampment were informed they had been suspended. More than 100 protesters were arrested the same day.

Tensions have escalated since then, with the university shutting down most of its campus April 30 after protesters seized an academic building.

But the video of pro-Palestinian rallies in the Instagram post was not taken after students set up the protest camp at Columbia University. A nearly identical version of the video was posted on Instagram on March 20 – nearly a month earlier – and included no references to Columbia University.

Fact check: Photo of 'rape is resistance' flyer predates pro-Palestinian camp at Columbia

The video shows pro-Palestinian protests in Norway. One clip was previously posted on Instagram on Nov. 4, 2023, the same day the U.S. Embassy in Norway issued an alert about a scheduled demonstration in Oslo. Another clip shows a demonstrator waving three Palestinian flags above a crowd of protesters. The same demonstrator is seen in a video that was posted on Instagram on March 16.

Both clips show the same public square in Oslo.

The Instagram user who shared the miscaptioned video did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Our fact-check sources:

Thank you for supporting our journalism. You can subscribe to our print edition, ad-free app or e-newspaper here.

USA TODAY is a verified signatory of the International Fact-Checking Network, which requires a demonstrated commitment to nonpartisanship, fairness and transparency. Our fact-check work is supported in part by a grant from Meta.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Video shows Oslo pro-Palestinian rally, not Columbia | Fact check

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest Stories

  • Israeli defence chief challenges Netanyahu over post-war Gaza plans

    Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was publicly challenged about post-war plans for the Gaza Strip on Wednesday by his own defence chief, who vowed to oppose any long-term military rule by Israel over the ravaged Palestinian enclave. The televised statement by Defence Minister Yoav Gallant marked the most vocal dissent from within Israel's top echelon against Netanyahu during a seven-month-old and multi-front conflict that has set off political fissures at home and abroad. Netanyahu hinted, in a riposte which did not explicitly name Gallant, that the retired admiral was making "excuses" for not yet having destroyed Hamas in a conflict now in its eight month.

  • ‘They have crossed a line’: Australian university orders pro-Palestinian protesters to leave building

    Pro-Palestinian protesters occupying a building at the University of Melbourne have been told to leave by university officials, who say they’ve “crossed a line” by entering the building and disrupting thousands of students’ classes.

  • Israeli military calls for investigation after releasing video showing armed men at UN facility in Gaza

    The Israeli military is calling on the United Nations to investigate the presence of armed militants at a UN facility in southern Gaza after releasing video that shows armed men at the facility.

  • Jordan foils arms plot as kingdom caught in Iran-Israel shadow war

    AMMAN (Reuters) -Jordan has foiled a suspected Iranian-led plot to smuggle weapons into the U.S.-allied kingdom to help opponents of the ruling monarchy carry out acts of sabotage, according to two Jordanian sources with knowledge of the matter. The weapons were sent by Iranian-backed militias in Syria to a cell of the Muslim Brotherhood in Jordan that has links to the military wing of Palestinian group Hamas, the people told Reuters. The alleged plot and arrests, reported here for the first time, come at a time of sky-high tensions in the Middle East, with an American-backed Israel at war in Gaza with Hamas, part of Iran's "Axis of Resistance" network of proxy groups built up over decades to oppose Israel.

  • A Palestinian converted to Judaism. An Israeli soldier saw him as a threat and opened fire

    JERUSALEM (AP) — At first, it seemed like the kind of shooting that has become all too common in the Israeli-occupied West Bank. A Palestinian aroused suspicions and an Israeli soldier killed him. But then the deceased was identified as David Ben-Avraham, a Palestinian who had made the almost unheard-of decision to convert from Islam to Judaism years earlier. His unusual journey had taken him across some of the deepest fault lines in the Middle East and led to some unlikely friendships. Most Pal

  • Columbia University president hit with no-confidence vote from faculty group over handling of pro-Palestinian campus protests

    Pro-Palestinian encampments have been cleared from more US college campuses as school officials have called in law enforcement in recent weeks to quell mounting demonstrations over the institutions’ ties to Israel amid its military action in Gaza. Here are the latest developments:

  • There's 'no humanitarian catastrophe' in Rafah, Netanyahu insists

    Israel is "fulfilling our obligation to (Rafah's) humanitarian needs," Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says.

  • Gaza fighting intensifies, Israel asks why armed men were at UN site

    CAIRO/JERUSALEM (Reuters) -Israeli troops battled militants across Gaza on Wednesday, including in the southern city of Rafah that had been a refuge for civilians, in an upsurge of the more than seven-month-old war that has killed tens of thousands of Palestinians. Antagonism between Israel and the United Nations worsened as the Israeli army sought an explanation for footage showing armed men next to U.N. Palestinian relief agency vehicles. Separately, India was working to bring home the body of a U.N. staffer killed in Rafah by what the global body said was tank fire.

  • Egypt warns Israel of ‘dire repercussions’ over Rafah operation in Gaza

    Egypt could consider downgrading relations with Israel if it presses on with a military operation in Gaza’s southernmost city of Rafah on the Egyptian border, an Egyptian official told CNN.

  • The Latest | Israel says it will send more troops to Rafah, as fighting also rages in Gaza's north

    Israel's defense minister said the military would send more troops into Rafah, a city along Gaza's southern border with Egypt, as fighting also rages in northern Gaza, where Hamas has regrouped. South Africa is seeking emergency measures at the U.N.'s top court to halt Israel’s escalating offensive in Rafah, calling the incursion “the last step in the destruction of Gaza.” Israel has portrayed Rafah as the last Hamas stronghold, brushing off warnings from the United States and other allies that

  • France imposes emergency in Pacific territory of New Caledonia as violent unrest turns deadly

    PARIS (AP) — France imposed an emergency Wednesday in the French Pacific territory of New Caledonia for at least 12 days, boosting security forces’ powers to quell deadly unrest in the archipelago where indigenous people have long sought independence. Armed clashes and other violence that erupted Monday following protests over voting reforms have left four people dead, including a gendarme, and injured more than 300, French authorities said. French military forces were being deployed to protect

  • Interior Department staffer is first Jewish Biden appointee to resign over Gaza war

    A Jewish official in the U.S. Interior Department has become the first staffer appointed by President Joe Biden to resign over the administration's stance on Israel's war in Gaza.

  • Judge refuses McGill's bid for injunction to dismantle pro-Palestinian encampment

    MONTREAL — A Quebec Superior Court judge has refused McGill University's request for an injunction to dismantle the pro-Palestinian encampment that has been set up on its downtown Montreal campus since late April. Justice Marc St-Pierre ruled Wednesday that the school did not prove the situation at the encampment was sufficiently urgent to justify the measure. In a written decision, he said the case also raises questions of conflicting rights — in this case, the protesters' freedom of expression

  • Biden's move to send $1 billion in weapons to Israel could backfire

    It comes days after the US withheld a shipment of bombs to Israel amid concerns over a major military operation in the southern Gazan city of Rafah.

  • Russian troops leave Karabakh, now back under Azerbaijan's control

    Russia shut down a military base in Azerbaijan on Wednesday where nearly 2,000 of its troops had been deployed, after Azeri forces recaptured the area last year despite a two-year Russian mission to prevent war between Azerbaijan and Armenia. A total of 1,960 Russian peacekeepers had been housed in 10 barracks at the base in Khojaly, a town in the Karabakh region. Despite the deployment, Azerbaijan recaptured Karabakh in a lightning offensive last September, prompting an exodus of 100,000 ethnic Armenians who had enjoyed de facto independence since breaking away in the 1990s in the first of two wars between the South Caucasus neighbours.

  • Video appears to show moment Slovakia’s prime minister was shot

    Five shots are heard in a video that appears to capture the moment Slovakia’s prime minister Robert Fico was shot in the town of Handlova on Wednesday.

  • The Latest | Palestinians mark 76 years of their dispossession as more catastrophe unfolds in Gaza

    Palestinians are marking 76 years of dispossession on Wednesday, commemorating their mass expulsion from what is today Israel, as a potentially larger catastrophe unfolds in Gaza where over a quarter of the population has been displaced by fighting in the last few days alone. Israel has been pressing its military operations in Rafah, a city along Gaza's southern border with Egypt, and in northern Gaza, where Hamas has regrouped. Around 600,000 Palestinians have been driven out of Rafah since the

  • US anchors aid pier to Gaza, now comes tough distribution job

    WASHINGTON/UNITED NATIONS (Reuters) -The United States anchored a floating pier in Gaza on Thursday to boost aid deliveries, but Washington is facing the same challenges that have beset the United Nations and aid groups for months when it comes to distributing assistance to millions in need amid a war between Israel and Palestinian militants Hamas. The United Nations said on Thursday it was still finalizing its operational plans to handle the distribution of aid once it comes off the pier. Aid trucks are expected to begin moving ashore in the coming days, the U.S. said on Thursday when announcing the anchoring of the temporary pier.

  • Israel Admits Killing Five of Its Own Young Soldiers by Mistake

    Amir Cohen/ReutersThe Israeli military said Thursday that five of its soldiers were killed in Gaza when they were hit by Israeli tank shells in what is thought to be one of the deadliest instances of friendly fire since the outbreak of the war.Another seven troops were wounded—including three seriously—in the incident in the northern city of Jabalia on Wednesday evening. All of the deceased victims served in the 202nd Battalion of the Paratroopers Brigade and were between the ages of 20 and 22.I

  • Hezbollah says it launched drones at military base west of Israel's Tiberias

    BEIRUT (Reuters) -Hezbollah said it launched a drone attack at a military base west of Israel's Tiberias on Wednesday, in the deepest strike into Israeli territory since the Lebanese armed group began exchanging fire with Israel in parallel with the Gaza war. Hezbollah said it was targeting part of a surveillance system used by the Israeli air force, and that the swarm of attack drones "hit its limited targets accurately and accomplished what it wanted in this limited operation."