Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Canada Politics

    Harper could be the most powerful political executive in the world: professor

    Stephen Harper has been accused of having a "my way or the highway" attitude towards governing the country.

    Now with a majority government, some would argue that attitude has been exclaimed.

    This past week, the prime minister has flexed his proverbial political muscle once again with the introduction of a draconian terror law which will allow for police detention of suspects without charges for up to 72 hours and for judges to compel witnesses to testify at trial.

    The laws were first introduced in 2001 following the Sept. 11 attacks in the United States, but opposition parties blocked their renewal in 2007.

    Now with a majority, Harper is free to push this legislation through. In fact, he's pretty much able to do what he wants - with very few obstacles.

    Although it seems benign, Harper ordered all Canadian embassies to have a portrait of the Queen hung prominently. He makes no bones about being a staunch monarchist.

    Ralph Heintzman, a professor at the University of Ottawa and head of the federal Office of Public Service Values and Ethics, says Canada might just have the most centralized political system in the world.

    "The Canadian prime minister is probably the most powerful political executive in the world because there is nothing, once he has a majority in Parliament, to restrain him or her," he told the Winnipeg Free Press in a recent interview.

    "In most other Westminster democracies, there are peculiarities of the system, which act as checks, formally or informally."

    Heintzman cites parliamentary systems in the U.K. and Australia where the party leaders are chosen by MPs, as opposed to party members like in Canada.

    "That turns the power relationship upside down," he says. "The leader controls the caucus. The caucus does not control the leader."

    In other words, members of Parliament in Canada are inclined to vote the way the prime minister wants them to or risk losing opportunities to serve on cabinet or even in caucus.   In the U.K. and Australia, MPs yield more power over their leader.

    Canada's prime minister even has more power here than the president does in the United States. The American head of state can find his or her agenda blocked by either or both houses of Congress as well as a politically activist Supreme Court.

    But in Canada a prime minister with a majority government and an appointed, unaccountable Senate has no real obstacles to passing bills.

    For the next four years at least, it might just be appropriate to call him King Harper.

    (CP Photo)

    What do you feel about this article?

     

    358 comments

    • Reginald Bauld  •  8 months ago
      Well, this was an interesting article. Personally I don't agree with all of Harper's policy stances, but I would rather have a system like where legislation can be passed even in a divided country. This naturally has the downside that the majority of people are going to be unhappy with legislation, but it also means that the Canadian government can react much quicker to a crisis and therefore not run into a situation similar to the US where no legislation gets passed when it is needed the most.

      Also, I am disappointed to see an extensive amount of mudslinging on these comment threads. The bonus is that people are clearly passionate and involved in the democratic process, but the downside is that mudslinging obfuscates a real discussion of the subject matter.
    • roodles  •  8 months ago
      Good luck Canada. Conservative politics worked so well for us in the U.S. Remember the huge financial crash and pre-emptive war? You're on your way!
      • AL 8 months ago
        we're not as dumb as the US
      • Steve Lucas 8 months ago
        But sometimes it seems that we want to be, Alain. If it wasn't for the Liberal Government of Paul Martin, the banks wanted to be, and would have been, de-regulated like the US ones. With the same problems that they had.
      • p 8 months ago
        you voted for harper didn't you? what a dumbbazzzzz lol
    • Ian  •  8 months ago
      so much for democracy & free thinking here in our Canadian gov't. Its Steve's way or the highway for the next 3 1/2 yrs.
      • Please don't tickle m ... 8 months ago
        Harper was charging $11,000 a week for Journalists to cover him during the campaign. He also limited the questions asked and as soon as elected he eliminated the vote subsidy. As you say "so much for democracy."
    • BLAXEL  •  8 months ago
      Joan

      It was a sorry day when you went to the polls to vote for no cutbacks and lots of spending. You on illegal drugs, or take schizophrenic Meds? Every 2nd person in the welfare lineup is a druggie laughing at people like yourself for footing part of their drug bill. Plant yourself in a welfare line and judge for yourself. Maybe you could hand out free doobies to lessen the terrible anguish of those poor souls who wait for your money, that is if your not already on the dole.
    • BLAXEL  •  8 months ago
      Beingthere2002
      Is definitely not all there!
    • Oliverio  •  8 months ago
      this guy is a detectator with same ideals is Hitler, he will goin to run this country is gestapo style.
      • A Yahoo! User 8 months ago
        Does he reward neigbors for spying on each other?
        Does he set children against their parents?
        Has he rounded up all the young white boys, Hitler Youth style?
        Has he rounded up all the young white girls, breeding stock style?
        Has he rounded up all the non whites, disabled and gays into concentration camps and started systematically exterminating them?

        Of course, the answer to all those questions is a resounding "NO!"

        Until the day he does all those things, any comparison to Hitler will be so far off base as to be utterly laughable.
      • jg 8 months ago
        Please! Learn to spell , and your point is?
      • MAREK 8 months ago
        you must stupid
    • jason  •  8 months ago
      yes becuase the world loves having crimanals and tyrants run country he's not my hero he going to drive my beloved country into the ground following the americans and buying there stupid planes that we dont need oh and not to robbing our troops of there benifits and pay not to ripping students
      the list goes on and on king gimme a break
    • PatrickPrincivil...  •  8 months ago
      Guys,

      I want you to know that, I am a christian without hypocrisy, I like Paul Martin so much, like God in heaven love us a lot, but I hate sin

      Matthew 12;30 say: if you are not with God, you are against him and if you are against him, he will destroy you in the future.

      What God have done against you? he give us Exodus 20:3-17 to practice his law. You don't even want to hear anything from him, you even say we come from monkeys; can monkeys make you sleep and wake you up?
      • motormouth 8 months ago
        skratches head .. um i dont know if politics and god could all fit in the same boat...
      • stu 8 months ago
        @motormouth, agreed!
        @pp...seriously, there is zero evidence of god, beyond so called belief...but there is evidence of evolution...even if u say "god" created everything, then u cant deny all evidence of all skeletons from every animal, human or variation of human ever found...n if u put all those skeletons in a row, from earliest to latest, that gives proof to evolution...

        alos i find it funny, u follow a book, that was written by humans, not god...there is nothing to say ne of it is tru...n all the chapters r supposed to be word from that person, ie matthew, therefore, god didnt say these things, matthew (or paul, or whoever did), yet u still follow their words like god said them...

        its funny those who r religious tell others to stop shedding a blind eye to the truth, but infact it seems religion sheds a blind eye on the truth...

        ps. monekys dont make me wake or sleep, but everything comprised within the human body does...n last time i checked god is not comprised within the human body (yet the similarities between monkey n human bodies r strickingly similar, go figure)
      • dr chis 8 months ago
        what the heck are you ranting about? you idiot
    • PatrickPrincivil...  •  8 months ago
      Hey Guys,

      I believe God gives everybody, gives choice to serve him or not, but I don't care if a men marry men, women marry women under the table, event thou it is so painful for the Christians to hear something like that. Paul Martin came and mess us up by the legalization of same sex wedding; The prime minister Stephen Harper come to help you to have more moral as immoral people now you complaint, you talking about king of Canada, I know God in heaven is already King, but instead of let you choose different politics party and fake judges corrupt to change Canada in Sodom and Gomorrah, it will be better for Canada if God fix Stephen Harper the way he wants and anointed him as king of Canada to stop you to bring no more shit in this country.
      • dr chis 8 months ago
        drop dead you idiot
      • CDC 8 months ago
        God? Really? Please show the proof if its existence first. Then, comment your cr*p.
      • Alex 8 months ago
        "God gives everybody, gives choice to serve him"
        You must be very proud to be a servant all your life
    • motormouth  •  8 months ago
      you lazy .C**TS all i see here is pass the buck non of you want to deal with the real problem so you all ignore it F**k YOU F**K YOUR GOVERMENT AND F**K CANADA you selfish... this planit pisses me off i want to be a terrorist cause im pushed to be ..
    • real guy  •  8 months ago
      I hope he won't be a Dictator
    • Larry King kerman  •  8 months ago
      Harper is QUEENS BICHHHHHHHHHHHHH.
    • Realist  •  8 months ago
      Silly article, Harper has not done anything to be called a dictator:
      let the the majority party do what they are capable of (& not blaming opposition for holding their arms) - and we'll assess that at the next elections
    • David Mortensen  •  8 months ago
      we have had this kind of gov't for over a century and the parliamentary proceeders have been close to the same as well. We have to trust in the people we have elected to do their job. Not to be hindered by so many checks and balances that nothing ever gets done eg.(US health care, economy) At least here in Canada PMs can make mistakes or make wonderful decisions all dependant on them, and if they screw it up, we have the freedom to vote them out in the next election. So what ever leader we have responsibility is on us. Canadians.
    • Minx  •  8 months ago
      give him his 4 years and see what's up... we need stuff like the f-35, no one else would do that... it just seems like parliament would move too slowly to keep up with change if done like the UK or Aus.
    • Grannie  •  8 months ago
      Harper the most powerful!?!?! - Heaven help us
    • Sean  •  8 months ago
      This idiot will never be more powerful than an American president regardless of his majority.He might be most powerful in Canada but elsewhere in the world he is just another f- -king politician,come on folks this is a whole lot of b/s.
    • Wilbur  •  8 months ago
      In our system we elect people to govern, Have all you kooks forgotten the war measures act, in critical times critical measures are necessary.
    • Harperisafraud!  •  8 months ago
      Why was Harpo making a speech to a British audience in NYC on Sept 11, can't this jackazz address his own people. Poor guy was not invited to the actual ceremony at ground zero so he decided to speak at the British Embassy, where was the Brit PM, oh he was in Britain speaking to his own people. Harpo you are a jackazz, ya come jail me for saying it. We need to revolt against this idiot.
    • cjf  •  8 months ago
      Someone commented on the fact that we finally have a PM that is not an embarrasment (like Chretien), runs a tight ship. Fights for our rights internationally, and works with a sustainable economic policy. Why is this so hard for lefties to get? There is no "hidden agenda". This is the guy we need in place.....for now.

    Blog Authors / Profiles