Barry and Honey Sherman were murdered by multiple killers, private investigators believe: source

1 / 3
Barry and Honey Sherman (CP)

Private investigators believe that the billionaire Toronto couple found dead at their home in December were murdered by multiple killers, a source with direct knowledge of the parallel probe into their mysterious deaths told CBC Toronto.

The new information contradicts a widely circulated theory that Barry and Honey Sherman died as a result of a murder-suicide — a notion that is regarded as fiction by those who knew the Shermans well.

Barry, 75, and Honey, 70, were found dead by a real estate agent in the basement of their Toronto mansion on Dec. 15. The source said their bodies were in an upright seated position on the floor near an indoor pool. Police deemed the deaths "suspicious" but have said little else since their investigation began. 

The Sherman family has hired a team of experts, which includes a number of former Toronto homicide detectives, to conduct a separate, independent investigation.

The private investigators have found evidence that both Barry and Honey Sherman had their necks wrapped with leather belts that were then knotted around a handrail that runs adjacent to the pool, the source told CBC Toronto. A coroner previously ruled that the couple had died from "ligature neck compression," or strangulation.

Their wrists showed evidence that they had been, at one point, bound together. No rope or other materials that could have been used to tie their wrists were discovered, the source told CBC Toronto.

Their bodies were otherwise limp and their arms unbound when they were discovered, the source said. The day the Shermans were found police said that there was no evidence of forced entry into the home.

The team of private investigators believes that the Shermans were, in fact, killed on Dec. 13, two days before they were found. This conclusion is based on the fact that Honey was wearing the same clothes she was last seen in, on Dec. 13, according to the source.

Private investigators also believe that Honey struggled with her killer or killers. She had cuts on her lip and nose, and was sitting in a pool of her own blood when she was discovered. However, there was comparatively little blood apparent on her upper-body clothing, suggesting that she had been face-down on the tile, bleeding, for some time before being bound to the handrail in an upright position, the source said.

Various media outlets have reported that Toronto homicide detectives are probing the deaths as a possible murder-suicide. The couple's four children, who plan to have their parents' North York home demolished once a team of private forensic investigators have had time to scour it, have soundly rejected that theory. So have close friends of the Shermans. 

Barry Sherman is the founder of Canadian pharmaceutical giant Apotex, and both he and his wife have been recognized internationally for their generous philanthropy. The couple, who were quite socially active among the city's gala class, was believed to have amassed a fortune of some $4.77 billion before their deaths. 

Neighbour Eli Kanter said he was unsurprised to hear that private investigators are approaching the case as a double murder. He told CBC Toronto that he's been skeptical about the possibility that the Shermans died in a murder-suicide since it was first reported as a possibility that the police are considering.

"They wouldn't do that. They wouldn't end that way," he said.

Contacted by telephone on Saturday morning, a Toronto police spokesperson said the force's own investigators have no updates at this time. 

  • Calgary arena deemed structurally unsafe by engineers day before roof collapsed
    News
    CBC

    Calgary arena deemed structurally unsafe by engineers day before roof collapsed

    No injuries were reported after the roof collapsed at Fairview Arena in southeast Calgary, one day after it was deemed structurally unsafe by city engineers and the Calgary Fire Department. Leslie Ann Kalman, director of the Fairview facility and league development for the Southern Alberta Women's Hockey Association — which operates the city-owned arena — told CBC News structural problems were first detected on Monday.

  • North Korea canceled planned meeting with Pence
    News
    Reuters

    North Korea canceled planned meeting with Pence

    By Matt Spetalnick and Christine Kim WASHINGTON/SEOUL (Reuters) - U.S. Vice President Mike Pence was scheduled to meet with North Korean officials, including leader Kim Jong Un's sister, while in South Korea for the Winter Olympics this month but the North Koreans canceled at the last minute, U.S. officials said on Tuesday. "North Korea dangled a meeting in hopes of the Vice President softening his message, which would have ceded the world stage for their propaganda during the Olympics," Pence's chief of staff, Nick Ayers, said in a statement.

  • Bid for damages against RCMP in Lisa Dudley death dismissed by B.C. judge
    News
    CBC

    Bid for damages against RCMP in Lisa Dudley death dismissed by B.C. judge

    Rosemarie Surakka alleges her daughter died because of negligence by an RCMP officer who went to check up on a report of shots fired in Mission, B.C,. Four days later, Dudley was found alive but later died. Surraka launched her court action in October 2011, three years and one month after Dudley died.

  • News
    CBC

    Montreal police arrest 6 after stabbing in Côte Saint-Luc

    Montreal police say they have arrested six people in connection with a stabbing in Côte Saint-Luc. Police got a 911 call just before 9 p.m. Tuesday about an armed assault that had taken place at the corner of Kildare Road and Eldridge Avenue. When officers arrived, they found the victim inside a home near Léger Avenue and Kildare Road.

  • How bike-mechanic apprenticeships could tune up the cycling industry
    News
    CBC

    How bike-mechanic apprenticeships could tune up the cycling industry

    A rise in demand for high-end services and skilled labour has some bike mechanics and service shop owners calling for a formalized apprenticeship program in British Columbia. "I think now that we're getting into such high performance bikes and more and more people are riding and more and more people want the best ride ... it's opened up a ton of room for high level service," said Dave McInnes, owner of Bicycle Hub, a service-only shop in North Vancouver. McInnes believes an apprenticeship program would raise the skill level of mechanics and increase trust between shops and the consumer and help increase the perceived value of shop services.

  • News
    The Canadian Press

    Widow of avalanche victim sues guides, lodge operator for negligence

    The widow of an Alberta man who died in an avalanche near Golden, B.C., is suing the guides, their mountain guide association and the lodge operator for negligence. Douglas and Sheila Churchill were among 13 people skiing in the backcountry, about 50 kilometres northwest of Golden, when a large avalanche struck in February 2016. Five others were partially burried in the slide, including his wife, Sheila Churchill.

  • News
    CBC

    Errol Greene was to see doctor before given anti-seizure medication, inquest told

    The nurse who treated both of Errol Greene's seizures at the Winnipeg Remand Centre had tears in her eyes when she told the court she initially called him by the wrong first name. Beverly Reeves was not scheduled to work on May 1, 2016, but came in to help the nurse who was working alone. "It was an extremely busy day in a normally busy place," Reeves told the court on Tuesday.

  • Inuvik company fined $100K for safety breach after death of 19-year-old Australian
    News
    CBC

    Inuvik company fined $100K for safety breach after death of 19-year-old Australian

    A Northwest Territories judge has ordered Inuvik's Allen Services & Contracting Ltd. to pay $100,000 after the workplace death of David Vinnicombe. David Vinnicombe, a 19-year-old from Australia, was working for Allen Services in Inuvik in June 2016 when a piece of heavy equipment he was operating rolled and killed him. Allen Services and a company supervisor originally faced nine charges under the territory's Safety Act, but pleaded guilty in October to one charge: failing to ensure that all workers are sufficiently and competently supervised.

  • Scent encounter sends Charlottetown student to hospital
    News
    CBC

    Scent encounter sends Charlottetown student to hospital

    Someone used a scented spray in a school bathroom and it wafted into the hallway, said the school's principal Dominique Lecours. "It's very unsettling and this last episode was especially very upsetting for students and staff because it is so serious, and people don't necessarily understand how serious it is until they see it," said Lecours.

  • News
    CBC

    Mining company working with environmentalists to clean up old mining sites

    Calgary-based mining company Margaux Resources has announced a plan to clean up old tailings sites by using new mining technologies to extract the remaining minerals. Tailings have long been known to cause environmental damage including loss of animal habitats and contamination of soil, groundwater and waterways. "What we have here is an industry leader that is sympathetic and realizes the situation that historic mining efforts have left," said Gerry Nellestijn, the coordinator of the Salmo Watershed Streamkeepers Society.

  • Computer shops embrace lucrative business: outfitting cryptocurrency miners
    News
    Reuters

    Computer shops embrace lucrative business: outfitting cryptocurrency miners

    By Wyman Ma, Dewey Sim and Joyce Lee HONG KONG/SINGAPORE (Reuters) - Some of the biggest electronics bazaars in Asia are being flooded with customers looking for the latest piece of technology: cryptocurrency mining rigs. Scores of miners from around the world are traveling to places like Hong Kong's Sham Shui Po and Singapore's Sim Lim Square to buy the rigs, which the shops' hardware geeks expertly build behind counters in their cramped boutiques.

  • Judge says IMDb can show Hollywood actors' ages under First Amendment
    News
    Reuters

    Judge says IMDb can show Hollywood actors' ages under First Amendment

    A federal judge on Tuesday declared unconstitutional a California law requiring IMDb, the movie and television information website, to remove actors' ages at their request. U.S. District Judge Vince Chhabria said the law violated the First Amendment rights of IMDb, a unit of Amazon.com Inc that challenged the law, by singling out age data for special treatment, despite being intended to serve the compelling interest of curbing age discrimination in Hollywood. "California has not shown that it adopted a measure 'actually necessary' to combating age discrimination." The law was passed in 2016.

  • PM announces Canada-India investment deals worth $1B
    Global News

    PM announces Canada-India investment deals worth $1B

    The Prime Minister -- who was criticized for looking like he was on a family vacation in India -- got down to business today. Justin Trudeau spent the morning meeting with a string of business leaders. Abigail Bimman breaks down what sectors could benefit most from their discussions.

  • News
    CBC

    McMorris, Parrot lead trio of Canadians into men's big air final

    Mark McMorris, Max Parrot, and Sebastien Toutant have qualified for the men's big air final at the Olympics in Pyeongchang, South Korea. The trio of Canadians will compete in the medal round beginning on Friday at 8 p.m. ET.

  • Who is TappCar? The story behind the Alberta firm that plans to beat Uber and Lyft to Winnipeg
    News
    CBC

    Who is TappCar? The story behind the Alberta firm that plans to beat Uber and Lyft to Winnipeg

    The Edmonton company poised to become Winnipeg's first new vehicle-for-hire company was founded by conservative Alberta lawyers who worked with disenfranchised cab drivers to create a labour-friendly ride-hailing service. The company started picking up passengers in Edmonton in 2016 at a time when Uber, the largest global player in the ride-hailing industry, temporarily ceased operating in the Alberta capital.

  • Patrick Brown accused of 'dirty and crooked politics' as Ontario MPP calls for investigation
    News
    CBC

    Patrick Brown accused of 'dirty and crooked politics' as Ontario MPP calls for investigation

    Ontario Progressive Conservative MPP Randy Hillier is calling for a "significant" investigation into Patrick Brown's personal finances over allegations the former Tory leader engaged in "dirty and crooked politics" that breached the province's ethics rules. 

  • Comber doctor who makes house calls receives award for service
    News
    CBC

    Comber doctor who makes house calls receives award for service

    Friends, family and patients packed the Lakeshore town council as local doctor, Raymond Anderson, received the council award from the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario. Dr. Debroah Hellyer presented the awards to Anderson. The Town of Lakeshore also recognized his dedication and service to the community.

  • What is the future of jobs in Newfoundland and Labrador?
    News
    CBC

    What is the future of jobs in Newfoundland and Labrador?

    How will people be earning a living in Newfoundland and Labrador 20 years in the future? A panel of experts organized by Memorial University's Harris Centre tackled the future of the provincial economy Monday at a public meeting. Kendra MacDonald, chair of the Newfoundland and Labrador Association of Technology Industries, said the province's tech sector comprises 160 companies and is worth $1.6 billion — numbers the association wants to double by 2025.

  • First Cree lesson draws dozens to North End community centre
    News
    CBC

    First Cree lesson draws dozens to North End community centre

    Ralph Brown Community Centre was transformed into a coffee house and classroom Tuesday night, catering to Cree speakers and those who want to learn the language.

  • No groceries, no rooms, few complaints: economic boom returns to northeastern B.C. community
    News
    CBC

    No groceries, no rooms, few complaints: economic boom returns to northeastern B.C. community

    A combination of pipeline projects and coal mining have added an influx of workers into Chetwynd, a small community in northeastern British Columbia — and made it difficult for locals to get fresh produce. Stuart said his community of just over 2,000 people has been noticeably busier in recent months and, lack of groceries aside, he was happy to see the change. Located about 300 kilometers northeast of Prince George, Chetwynd sits at an intersection of highways leading to Hudson's Hope and Fort St. John in the north, Dawson Creek in the east and Tumbler Ridge to to the south.

  • Exclusive: Japan to buy at least 20 more F-35A stealth fighters - sources
    News
    Reuters

    Exclusive: Japan to buy at least 20 more F-35A stealth fighters - sources

    By Tim Kelly and Nobuhiro Kubo TOKYO (Reuters) - Japan plans to buy at least 20 additional F-35A stealth fighters over the next six years, some or all of which it may purchase directly from Lockheed Martin Corp in the United States rather than assemble locally, three sources said. The sources said buying complete aircraft from the United States, at about $100 million each, will save Japan about $30 million per airframe. The purchase will add to an earlier order for 42 of the fighters, most of which are being constructed at a "final assembly and check out" plant in Japan operated by Mitsubishi Heavy Industries , the country's leading defense contractor.

  • 'Ignored for too long:' B.C. NDP government takes aim at housing costs with tax measures
    News
    CBC

    'Ignored for too long:' B.C. NDP government takes aim at housing costs with tax measures

    Stabilize, crack-down, build and protect — key tactics the provincial government says it will use to put a dent in B.C.'s housing crisis. On Tuesday, B.C.'s NDP unveiled its first full budget since taking office seven months ago and along with it came a separate 33-page publication on how the government plans to make housing more affordable. "The problem has been ignored for too long and the consequences are being felt throughout B.C. with housing costs skyrocketing," said Finance Minister Carole James as she presented the budget in the legislature.

  • News
    CBC

    Alberta chainsaw artist to carve public memorial for bullrider Ty Pozzobon

    Chainsaw artist Marina Cole will sculpt an image of the late bull-riding legend Ty Pozzobon for his family and his hometown in B.C.'s southern Interior. The City of Merritt and the Pozzobon family commissioned Cole to create a piece to display publicly in memory of the young rodeo champ after she won a local carving competition. Pozzobon, 25, died in January 2017 and was later diagnosed with chronic traumatic encephalopathy, a disease linked to repetitive brain injury. "I think foremost, I just want to bring something to Ty's family that will be able to fill a tiny piece of their heart,"  she said.

  • ING says cryptocurrency exchange Bitfinex has an account with it
    News
    Reuters

    ING says cryptocurrency exchange Bitfinex has an account with it

    Dutch financial services company ING on Tuesday confirmed that Bitfinex, one of the largest exchanges for trading in cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin, has a bank account with it in the Netherlands. Bitfinex, whose parent company iFinex is incorporated in the British Virgin Isles and which has offices in Taiwan, could not be reached for comment. ING spokesman Harold Reusken confirmed in an email that Bitfinex has an account in the Netherlands but would not provide details on the amount held or whether ING also provides banking services for other Bitfinex-related companies.

  • Same scam, new emotional twist almost cons Corner Brook woman
    News
    CBC

    Same scam, new emotional twist almost cons Corner Brook woman

    When Ruth Brewer's phone rang a couple of weeks ago, she thought it was her son Brian on the line — a call that kickstarted a harrowing experience that had her scrambling for cash.