Hate political email spam? You have little time to express your feelings on a potentially pivotal federal ruling.
Dave Levinthal
Updated ·4 min read
Google has asked the Federal Election Commission to rule on its request to make it easier for political candidates to reach potential donors with email solicitations.Jaap Arriens/NurPhoto via Getty Images
Google has asked federal regulators to OK a plan letting political committees avoid spam filters.
Gmail users could expect to see more political emails in their main inboxes.
A public comment period on the Federal Election Commission case is ending soon.
Google wants to ease its Gmail spam filters when political candidates and committees email you for donations or otherwise try contacting you — and it's asked the Federal Election Commission for its legal blessing.
But few Americans are aware of this pending case. And a deadline for public comment is fast approaching with little publicity from Google or the FEC on the case — or its implication for consumers.
An affirmative ruling by the nation's bipartisan campaign finance regulator could affect tens of millions of Gmail users who could expect more political solicitations landing in their main inboxes unless they proactively opt-out.
"People care about getting spam email, including political email. They have opinions," said Rick Hasen, a law and political science professor at the University of California, Irvine, who edits the Election Law Blog. "The FEC should give the public sufficient time to weigh in on an issue that affects the public in direct way."
But, in an email to Insider, FEC spokesperson Judith Ingram said the public comment deadline would actually be Saturday, July 16. She declined to comment on whether the agency believes it has given the public adequate time to comment on the matter.
Axios in late June first reported Google's intentions to seek a ruling from the FEC.
Among its duties, the Federal Election Commission is tasked with providing political committees, corporations, unions, and other political actors with "advisory opinion" rulings that help them interpret campaign finance laws.Sarah Silbiger/CQ Roll Call
What Google wants
As described in its request to the FEC, Google wants to "launch a pilot program for authorized candidate committees, political party committees, and leadership political action committees" that would ensure the emails of accepted committees "will not be affected by forms of spam detection to which they would otherwise be subject."
Google said that its spam-skirting political pilot program is "not intended to favor or disfavor any particular candidate, party or speaker, nor intended to influence the outcome of any election."
Any committee registered with the FEC, whose emails comply with Google's terms of service and don't contain prohibited content such as malware or phishing schemes, could apply to participate.
However, Google's concerns — articulated in a 15-page letter to the FEC from Allen & Overy LLP attorney Claire Rajan on July 1 — center on whether its efforts would constitute "prohibited in-kind contributions" to political committees.
Put simply: Google wants the government's reassurance that it isn't breaking any law by giving politicians and political operatives a potentially valuable service. Suspected violations of federal campaign finance laws can result in costly investigations and potential civil fines, say nothing of bad press.
The FEC's 6-member, bipartisan board of commissioners must decide on Google's request by the end of August. Google has requested the FEC give its request an "expedited review" and rule on it "within 30 days due to the proximity to upcoming elections."
Anne P. Mitchell, an attorney and CEO of the Institute for Social Internet Public Policy, tweeted a comment she already sent the FEC. In it, she argued that it is a "very bad time indeed to give candidates and campaigns such a free pass" given accusations of abusive political email fundraising practices.
—Anne P. Mitchell Esq (@annepmitchell) July 9, 2022
More broadly, political campaigns on both the left and right have taken in recent years to blasting out increasingly hyperbolic, clickbait-y, and sometimes misleading emails in search of money. Recipients of such emails sometimes have not signed up to receive them, as campaigns routinely rentlistsof email addresses from data brokers or other political committees.
By Tuesday morning, several dozen people had written the FEC about Google's request, according to a list of comments released by the agency. Almost all of those issuing comments expressed displeasure, with many urging the FEC to reject the Google request.
"This is a HORRIFIC idea — My 85 year-old mother gets over 20 emails A DAY from political campaigns — each one screaming that if she doesn't give today, it will be the end of the USA as we know it," one commentor wrote.
"In this divisive time where lies are regularly crammed down the public's throat and our legislators and representatives are without ethics. We need NO more political spam!" wrote another.
The FEC has directed people to email comments about the case to the email address ao@fec.gov.
This article was originally published on July 10 and updated to include new comments received by the FEC.
Non-MAGA America seethes at Trump's lies, bluster and authoritarianism. But neither Biden nor any younger, healthier Democrat directly moves to shut down his appeal at its root — toxic whiteness.
WARNING: This story contains discussion of intimate partner violence and suicide.Three family members in Harrow, Ont., south of Windsor, died of gunshot wounds in June, the Ontario Provincial Police announced on Saturday.Carly Walsh, 41, and her children, Madison, 13, and Hunter, 8 — who were found dead in their home on June 20 — died of gunshots wounds, OPP Sgt. Ed Sanchez said in a video posted to OPP West Region's social media accounts.Sanchez also said that Steve Walsh, Carly's husband and t
P!nk shares incredible news about her world tour with a picture of the singer in a cheek-baring leotard and diamante jacket. Find out more and see pictures here...
President Biden gave the most important TV interview of his career Friday. Biden spoke to George Stephanopoulos of ABC News for 22 minutes during a campaign trip to Wisconsin. The conversation came with his presidency in real peril. There has been profound agitation among Democrats over Biden’s disastrous performance at his June 27 debate with…
BONFIELD, ONT. — Ontario Provincial Police say they found a large amount of lobster that had been dumped along a highway east of North Bay. Police say they received calls about lobster on the shoulder of Highway 17 in Bonfield on Tuesday. They say it was disposed of "for unknown reasons." Officers are reminding the public that it's illegal to litter or dump items along the highway. They say it can also cause safety issues when it attracts wildlife to the road. Police are asking anyone with infor
Meghan McCain, the daughter of the late Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.), said President Biden will not be elected to another term “one way or another.” “Joe Biden can step aside for another candidate or lose in historic numbers in a few months — but one way or another he will not be President soon and…
Brittany Mahomes — who was also in attendance at the show — appeared to check on the NFL star, who was spotted wiping his face several times during the performance