'I'd be pissed': PC education critic says AG report highlights lack of confidence in MUN leadership

CBC
·3 min read
A series of tarps along the tunnel system catches liquid from the ceilings. (Sarah Antle/CBC - image credit)
A series of tarps along the tunnel system catches liquid from the ceilings. (Sarah Antle/CBC - image credit)

PC education critic Paul Dinn says a scathing report from Newfoundland and Labrador's auditor general on facility management at Memorial University validates what students already know, and says a different approach needs to be taken to address outstanding repairs.

"It justifies exactly what they've been saying for so long. That the university's infrastructure is crumbling. Literally crumbling," Dinn told reporters Wednesday.

The report, released by Auditor General Denise Hanrahan, gave MUN a failing grade in the management of its facilities. It showed the university had $481 million in deferred maintenance liabilities as of March 2024, and that the student-paid campus renewal fund — which aims to address those liabilities — was used to purchase things like software, laptops and a tractor.

Dinn didn't hold back when asked how students should feel about the report's findings.

ADVERTISEMENT

"I don't know if I can say this in public, but I'd be pissed. I'd be severely pissed over this," he said. "I don't have a huge amount of confidence [in leadership] right now."

Nicolas Keough, the executive director of external affairs at Memorial's student union, said none of Hanrahan's findings was surprising.

"It really frustrates me when the administration of the university continues to mismanage funds. And honestly, when that's let happen by the provincial government and the lack of oversight that they seem to have," he said.

A series of tarps along the tunnel system catches liquid from the ceilings.
A series of tarps along the tunnel system catches liquid from the ceilings.

Hanrahan said Tuesday that Memorial has a "facilities management problem," outlining over $481 million in deferred maintenance liabilities as of March 2024. (Sarah Antle/CBC)

Keough said the union hopes to meet with Education Minister Krista Lynn Howell following the report, but hopes a strategy can be developed to ensure funds are going directly into deferred maintenance and tuition reduction for students.

ADVERTISEMENT

"We do need to see an investment in the university as a whole, so that students don't feel the cuts. Because right now, it's students that are feeling it," he said.

Dinn believes there are routes that can be taken to inject more government funds into the university, like tapping into the province's future fund. The fund, established in 2022 from contributions from non-renewable resource royalties, has grown to more than $360 million.

WATCH | Here's how government can address MUN's maintenance problems, according to Paul Dinn:

Money can be withdrawn from the fund under extraordinary circumstances, and Dinn argued the state of Memorial's infrastructure warrants it.

"Memorial University is the future for a lot of our residents. It's the future. So why are we not, if we're struck on cash, why are we not using some of that fund now?" he asked. "This is a can that can't be kicked down the road."

ADVERTISEMENT

Dinn said he'd also like to see work done to assess Memorial's buildings and prioritize the most important work, and believes the government should wield more influence over how the university spends its money.

Howell was not available for an interview Wednesday. However, in an emailed statement to CBC News, the Department of Education said it was pleased to hear MUN has committed to implementing Hanrahan's recommendations in the report.

The statement also noted the province is investing close to $400 million into the university this year — which accounts for over 70 per cent of the total operating revenue.

Download our free CBC News app to sign up for push alerts for CBC Newfoundland and Labrador. Sign up for our daily headlines newsletter here. Click here to visit our landing page.

Latest Stories

  • Middle East latest: Israel launches a major West Bank operation, days after Gaza ceasefire

    Israel launched a major military operation Tuesday in the occupied West Bank city of Jenin that killed at least nine Palestinians and left at least 40 more people wounded, Palestinian health officials said, as Israel’s fragile ceasefire with Hamas in Gaza entered its third day. Israel’s top general resigned Tuesday, taking responsibility for security failures tied to Hamas’ surprise attack in October 2023 that triggered the war in Gaza.

  • Documents reveal who donated to Halifax mayor, councillors in 2024 municipal election

    Halifax financial campaign documents from the recent municipal election reveal how much money candidates for mayor and council raised — and from whom.The Halifax Regional Municipality released campaign contribution and expense statements from the October 2024 municipal election last week.Mayor Andy Fillmore raised $302,969 in both cash and in-kind contributions of services, none of which was his own personal money. He spent $298,255 on his campaign, slightly under the $300,000 maximum limit.Roug

  • These exercise classes aim to keep seniors in tip-top shape

    A new report from the seniors' advocate says the province's aging population scored below the national average when it comes to health measures — like proper exercise — and it’s leading to more falls among older adults. However, there are a number of classes offered in St. John’s to help curb the issue, and the CBC's Julia Israel took part in one to learn a little more.

  • Israeli military patrols outside Jenin hospital amid violent crackdown in West Bank

    In the days since a fragile ceasefire took hold in the Gaza Strip, Israel has launched a major military operation in the occupied West Bank and suspected Jewish settlers have rampaged through two Palestinian towns. Video filmed by the Associated Press showed people leaving Jenin Hospital queuing up next to Israeli army vehicles. (AP video shot by: Sam McNeil)

  • Germany's likely next chancellor demands migration crackdown after knife attack

    BERLIN (Reuters) -Germany's main opposition leader vowed on Thursday to impose immediate border controls if he becomes chancellor, as expected, after elections next month, a day after an Afghan asylum seeker was arrested for a deadly knife attack targeting children. Friedrich Merz, whose plan would need buy-in from coalition partners after the Feb. 23 vote his party is set to win with a minority, said the attack, which killed a two-year-old boy and an adult passerby, could not become the new normal. "We are faced with the ruins of a ten-year-long misguided asylum and immigration policy in Germany," he told reporters, criticising European Union migration rules as "dysfunctional".

  • Province adds temporary shelter beds as temperatures dip

    With temperatures dipping well below zero and biting wind chill expected into the weekend, community organizations across Nova Scotia are ramping up capacity to help more homeless people come inside.The provincial government said it activated its "extreme weather protocol" this week, which means providing increased funding to help shelters add more beds and staff, or to open temporary shelters where they're needed.Two new emergency shelters have opened. One in the St. Mary's Boat Club reception

  • Scholz's challenger vows tough border rules as attack puts migration in German election spotlight

    BERLIN (AP) — Germany's opposition leader vowed Thursday to bar people from entering the country without proper papers and to step up deportations if he is elected chancellor next month, as a knife attack by a rejected asylum-seeker spilled over into an election campaign in which he is the front-runner.

  • Supreme Court agrees to hear appeal of Quebec's secularism law

    OTTAWA — The Supreme Court of Canada has agreed to hear a legal challenge of Quebec's secularism law, known as Bill 21.

  • One dead, baby among injured after Russian attack on Zaporizhzhia overnight, Ukraine authorities say

    Footage released by the Ukrainian state emergency service showed the aftermath of the drone attack, with buildings scorched and severely damaged. Firefighters worked throughout the night to extinguish the fires in the area, using water hoses and ladders.

  • Federal government using AI to tackle Phoenix backlog as it tests replacement system

    OTTAWA — The federal government is expanding its use of artificial intelligence to clear a backlog of Phoenix pay system transactions as it transitions to a new platform.

  • Close call involving wheelchair user stuck in train tracks underscores winter accessibility issues

    It was like a scene out of a movie.A close call involving a man in a wheelchair stuck in the railway tracks waving for help has underscored issues with accessibility in the winter months.It happened near Lauzon Road in Tecumseh last week. Shellley Renaud came to the man's rescue."It was very thick ice," she said."The snow was very compacted, and it looked very slippery too, because my little red-heeled boots were sliding on it also ... That's why it was giving me such a hard time to move him."Sh

  • Some children given flu shots at Tuktoyaktuk, N.W.T., school without consent, parents say

    Some families in Tuktoyaktuk, N.W.T., are upset after they say their children were given flu shots at school, or were pressured to get them, despite a lack of consent from parents.John Noksana Jr., a parent and a grandfather of school-aged children, said his 12-year-old daughter received two vaccinations at her school. He says one was a flu shot and that he hasn't been able to confirm what the other one was.Noksana Jr. said his daughter returned home the day of the vaccination clinic in November

  • During his first term in office, U.S. President Donald Trump, left, is shown meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping at the G20 leaders summit in Osaka, Japan, on June 29, 2019.

    As U.S. President Donald Trump announces plans to withdraw from various international organizations and agreements, China is positioning itself as a global leader and capitalizing on the opportunity to fill a void left by the United States on the world stage, analysts say.On his first day in office after Monday's inauguration, Trump signed executive orders that started the process of pulling out of the World Health Organization (WHO) and the 2015 Paris Agreement on climate change, as he did in his first term.The moves by the Republican president call into question the future of global public health responses and climate goals, and leave a leadership vacuum that China could try to fill."This creates potential for China to further bolster its influence in the multilateral institutions of the world and help govern the world," said Gregory Chin, associate professor of political economy at York University in Toronto.Indeed, China appears to be sending those signals already. China's messagingIn what could be seen as a strategically timed meeting, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin spoke via video just hours after Trump's inauguration, underscoring their continued alliance."I'm willing to work with you to continue guiding China-Russia relations to a new height in 2025, to respond to external uncertainties," Xi reportedly told Putin.The Chinese leader said he wanted to "uphold international fairness and justice."Concurrently, Chinese officials echoed this messaging on Tuesday at the World Economic Forum annual meeting in Davos, Switzerland, touting the country's commitment to fighting climate change."China has always been a staunch supporter of true multilateralism," Vice-Premier Ding Xuexiang said, adding the country was "steadfastly upholding the international system ... and firmly maintaining the international order based on international law."In terms of "peace and security," Ding said that "China has the best record among the world's major powers."Vice-Premier Ding Xuexiang of China delivers an address at the 55th annual World Economic Forum annual meeting in Davos, Switzerland, on Tuesday. Chinese officials touted the country's commitment to fighting climate change. (Yves Herman/Reuters)Also on Tuesday at a news conference in Beijing, Chinese Foreign Affairs Ministry spokesperson Guo Jiakun reiterated China's concern about the U.S. withdrawing from the Paris Agreement."Climate change is a common challenge facing all mankind," he said. "China's determination and actions to actively respond to climate change are consistent."During Tump's first term, the U.S. also withdrew from multiple international agreements, including the Paris Agreement on climate change, the Trans-Pacific Partnership and the United Nations Human Rights Council.It appears he is continuing on the same path.When Trump won the presidential election over Kamala Harris, the Democratic vice-president, in November, Jia Wang, senior fellow and senior adviser at the China Institute at the University of Alberta in Edmonton, told CBC News that China could capitalize on the situation."China could take this opportunity to make more friends or at least reduce rivals and enemies," she said. The cost of developmentAs the U.S. turns inward, and as the new president touts the beginning of the "golden age of America" and the end of its "decline," China is asserting itself."Inadvertently, the Trump administration may be weakening America's positioning in the world relative to China," York University's Chin said.At least on the climate front, China has been positioning itself as a green leader for years, undertaking initiatives aimed at achieving its goal of carbon neutrality by 2060 — including investing in renewable energy and leading the world in electric vehicles and batteries. That's despite still being the world's largest emitter of greenhouse gases, responsible for a third of the world's emissions.The Guohua Power Station, a coal-fired power plant, operates in Dingzhou, in northern China's Hebei province, in November 2023. China is the world's largest emitter of greenhouse gases. (Ng Han Guan/The Associated Press)But this positioning, however strategic, is coming out of necessity, said Yongjing Zhang, an associate professor of economics and politics at the University of Ottawa."China really cares about climate change," Zhang said, adding that the country is now suffering from the "cost" of its rapid development. "No matter what's happening with other countries, China will [address it]."Simply put, it has no choice. Global health securityOn Tuesday, Chinese Foreign Affairs Ministry spokesperson Guo also expressed strong support for the World Health Organization following Trump's announcement, saying China will "as always, support the WHO in fulfilling its duty, deepening international co-operation in public health."Trump accused the institution, a United Nations agency, of being biased toward China and criticized its handling of the COVID-19 pandemic — as he did during his first term in power, when he also moved to extract the U.S. Joe BIden, who succeeded Trump as president following his first term, later reversed the decision.However, China's future role in the health sphere is more unclear, despite its messaging. The U.S. is by far the agency's largest financial backer, accounting for about 18 per cent of its overall funding. The WHO's most recent budget for 2024-25 was $6.8 billion US.It is currently unclear how that financial void would be filled, as experts have warned the move could weaken the security of global public health — and could weaken the world's defences against future pandemics and infectious diseases. Being allies 'means nothing now'What is emerging in the early days of Trump's presidency are indications that American allies are increasingly concerned about what a more confident Trump would mean in his second term, considering his unpredictability."You have to throw the terms of friendship and allies out the window," said Lynette Ong, a distinguished professor of Chinese politics at the University of Toronto. "That means nothing now."Ong said while China could very well assert itself, she would like to see more evidence of the country putting its words into action.But York University's Chin said U.S. isolationism will ultimately mean other countries will face a decision in the alliance system."It's choosing between aligning themselves with America moving forward or some multi-polar set of options," he said.Those options, Chin said, could include the BRICS countries, of which China and Russia are a part.WATCH | Canada, China, Mexico win temporary reprieve from Trump tariffs:"If you're in the West, you might see this as a threat to the so-called rules-based international order," he said. "But if you're in the rest of the world, you might say some of these changes may in fact be improvements."As Trump threatens higher tariffs for countries like China, Canada and Mexico, China reduced tariffs on hundreds of goods this month coming into the country. And regardless of motivation, Chin suggests it may be just one reason other nations may bolster relations with the country while the U.S. distances itself.

  • Manitoba mother wants answers after IV treatment leaves toddler with swollen arm

    A two-year-old boy is still dealing with a painful reminder of his visit to the hospital. Last week his mom took him to the emergency room for a problem with his collarbone, but an IV with medication left him fighting an infection.

  • Dr. Vera Etches looks back on her time as Ottawa's top doctor as she departs to head CHEO

    Dr. Vera Etches, whose calm demeanour and informative updates made her the face of Ottawa Public Health (OPH) during the tumultuous COVID-19 pandemic, is leaving her job as the city's top doctor.After more than 15 years at OPH, during which she became the city's first female medical officer of health in 2018, Etches is about to take over as president and CEO of CHEO on March 3. She officially leaves OPH at the end of this month.CBC sat down with Etches to look back at her time leading OPH, and t

  • Man charged after Scarborough fire leaves baby girl dead

    A 39-year-old Toronto man has been charged after an 8-month-old baby girl died in hospital following a Scarborough house fire on the weekend.The fire happened in the area of Finch Avenue East and Brimley Road. Toronto police were called to the home on Saturday at 11:15 a.m.In a news release on Wednesday, police said the fire broke out in the basement. Police said on the weekend that four people were taken to hospital following the fire: the baby girl, a four-year-old boy, a woman in her 70s who

  • In the news today: Liberal leadership deadline, Trump versus Canada's digital tax

    Here is a roundup of stories from The Canadian Press designed to bring you up to speed...

  • 'People are pretty upset': Peavey Mart store closures in Ontario, N.S. seen as a loss for farm owners

    Tanya Leckie didn't come empty-handed when she arrived at the Peavey Mart location in London, Ont., on Wednesday.As a gift to staff at the soon-to-close store on Hyde Park Road, she brought six cupcakes, their multi-coloured sprinkles visible through the clear plastic package. It's a gift she's given to staff many times before. "They deserve a treat every once in a while," she told CBC News on Wednesday. "They are a very community-based operation." Leckie loves Peavey Mart because she lives on a

  • Fort Smith, N.W.T., mother says husband's love persists, 1 year after crash that killed him and 5 others

    The wife of one of the six people who died when a plane crashed and caught fire near the airport in Fort Smith, N.W.T., says she can't believe it's been a year since the tragedy happened. "I feel lost," said Bev Chepelsky. "Joel is somebody that just made everything OK, you know, if you're having a bad day … losing him, it's really hard 'cause I don't have my friend, my husband, to help me feel OK." Chepelsky's husband, Joel Tetso, was on the Northwestern Air Lease plane that crashed shortly aft

  • Scarborough plaza business owners frustrated by illegal garbage dumping

    Business owners in a Scarborough plaza say they're frustrated with recurring piles of illegally dumped trash surrounding their stores.Nigansha Puvirajah's family-owned grocery store has been at the Knob Hill Plaza, near Eglinton Avenue E. and Danforth Road, since 1994. But in recent years, she says people have been tossing their trash everywhere."It's been really, really bad to a point where we go out of our own way to clean it up — then we get charged by the city," Puvirajah told CBC Toronto.So